| Verzani M, et al. 2021 (15) |
Retrospective analysis of consultations in outpatient clinic of Endocrinology |
Italy |
Patients referred to Endocrinology Unit for suspected precocious puberty |
March to September of 2020 |
March to September of 2019 |
302 females |
Suspected precocious puberty consultations |
87 |
215 |
2.47-fold increase in consultations for suspected PP |
| 15 males |
9 |
6 |
No difference observed in males; |
| Jimenez A, et al. 2022 (17) |
Case-Control Study |
Spain |
Patients < 14 yo referred to Endocrinology Unit from primary care |
March to December of 2020 |
March to December of 2019 |
133; no info on sex |
Percentage of endocrinology referrals attributed to precocious puberty |
45/598 (7.5%) |
87/471 (18.5%) |
Risk Ratio of 2.46 |
| Barbieri C, et al. 2022 (18) |
Case-Control Study |
Italy |
Girls referred to Tertiary Center for different forms of precocious puberty |
March 9th of 2020 to April 30th of 2021 |
January 1st of 2019 to March 8th of 2020 |
154 females |
Incidence of CPP in a tertiary center (endocrinology referrals) |
9/67 (13.43%) |
17/87 (19.54%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.45 |
| Chen Y, et al. 2022 (19) |
Cross-sectional study (Retrospective cohort) |
China |
Girls admitted in endocrinology ward |
2020 (January to December) |
2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019 (January to December) |
2,802,387; no info on sex |
Frequency of precocious girls admitted in endocrinology ward |
106/698 (15.18%) |
372/1161 (32.04%) |
Risk Ratio of 2.10 (only girls) |
| All consultations in outpatient clinic |
Incidence of precocious girls in outpatient clinic |
6,547/1,611,699 (0.4%) |
9270/1,188,829 (0.77%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.91 (only girls) |
| Chioma L, et al. 2022 (20) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Patients investigated in five Italian tertiary centers of Pediatric Endocrinology |
March to September of 2020 |
March to September of 2019 |
|
Subjects referred for suspected precocious puberty |
152 |
338 |
2.22-fold increase in referrals. |
| 490 (22) |
Incidence of CPP in tertiary centers |
37/140 (26.42%) |
135/328 (41.15%) |
Risk Ratio 1.55 in females; |
| - |
- |
No difference in males |
| Itani A, et al. 2022 (23) |
Retrospective cohort |
Lebanon |
Medical records of Lebanese patients referred to pediatric endocrinology clinics in multiple Lebanese regions |
March of 2020 to February of 2021 |
2018 and 2019 |
1380 females |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
4/964 (0.41%) |
19/416 (4.6%) |
Risk Ratio of 11.21 |
| Incidence of accelerated puberty diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
8/964 (0.83%) |
6/416 (1.44%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.73 |
| Mondkar SA, et al. 2022 (25) |
Case-Control Study |
India |
Single center, retrospective study, wherein data at the first visit to a tertiary level pediatric endocrinology center were mined |
March of 2020 to September 2021 |
September of 2018 to February of 2020 |
7261; no info on sex |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
42/4208 (0.9%) |
130/3053 (4.2%) |
Risk Ratio of 4.66 in females |
| 2/4208 (0.1%) |
06/3053 (0.2%) |
Risk Ratio of 2 in males |
| Mutlu GY, et al. 2022 (26) |
Case-Control Study |
Turkey |
Girls who had been referred to pediatric endocrinology clinics due to precocious puberty (retrospective evaluation of medical records) |
March of 2020 to September of 2020 |
March of 2019 to March of 2020 |
359 females |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals due to precocious puberty |
19/214 (8.8%) |
42/145 (28.9%) |
Risk Ratio of 3.28 during first 6 months of pandemic |
| Peinkhofer M, et al. 2022 (29) |
Cross-sectional study |
Italy |
Children and adolescents performing a stimulation test in a tertiary hospital (retrospective analysis) |
January to December of 2020 |
January to December of 2019 |
83 females |
Diagnosis of CPP using LHRH test from suspected cases |
16/38 (42.1%) |
26/45 (57.7%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.37 in females; p = 0.03 |
| 19 males |
8/10 (80%) |
2/9 (22.2%) |
Risk Ratio of 0.27 in males; p > 0.05 |
| Trujillo MV, et al. 2022 (31) |
Retrospective cohort |
USA |
Patients referred to Endocrinology Unit for evaluation |
May of 2020 to April of 2021 |
May of 2018 to April 2019 |
4601, no info on sex; |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
28/2340 (1.2%) |
62/2261 (2.8%) |
Risk Ratio of 2.33 |
| Umano GR, et al. 2022 (32) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Female patients that attended the outpatient clinic of pediatric endocrinology because of CPP |
April of 2020 to April of 2021 |
2017 to 2020 (April to April) |
69 females |
Absolute increase in number of CPP case |
11† |
35 |
3.18-fold increase in the period. |
| CPP incidence rate |
2% |
5% |
Risk Ratio of 2.5 |
| Chioma L, et al. 2023 (30) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Patients consulting for suspected precocious or early puberty in outpatient clinic |
March to September of 2020 |
March to September of 2019 |
550 females |
Prevalence of suspected precocious puberty among endocrinology consultations |
78/1260 (6.2%) |
202/747 (27%) |
Prevalence Ratio of 4.35 in 2020. |
| Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
18/78 (23%) |
86/202 (42.57%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.85 during the lockdown. |
| Goffredo M, et al. 2023 (32) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Patients referred to Endocrinology Units |
March of 2020 to February of 2021 |
March of 2019 to February of 2020 |
2532, no info on sex. |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
34/1469 (2.3%) |
45/1063 (4.2%) |
Risk Ratio of 2.12 |
| Benedetto M, et al. 2023 (36) |
Retrospective cohort |
Argentina |
Patients diagnosed with ICPP and receiving treatment with GnRHa |
January to December of 2020 and 2021 |
January to December of 2018 and 2019 |
8874 (0) |
Annual incidence of CPP |
3,95% |
10.9%¥ |
Risk Ratio of 1.64-3.92. |
| Matsubara K, et al. 2023, (37) |
Retrospective cohort |
Japan |
Patients referred for suspected precocious puberty and diagnosed with CPP |
April of 2020 to April of 2021 |
April of 2019 to April of 2020 |
1292 females |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
28/248 (11.29%) |
51/271 (18.81%) |
Risk Ratio of 1.66 in females. |
| 1051 males |
5/204 (2.4%) |
12/170 (7.05%) |
Risk Ratio of 2.93 in males. |
| Fava D, et al. 2023 (38) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Health records of girls referred to a tertiary-level academic center for suspected precocious puberty |
March of 200 to June of 2021 |
January of 2016 to February of 2020 |
133 females |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
72 |
61 |
1.3 fold-higher during COVID pandemic |
| Goggi G, et al. 2023 (39) |
Retrospective cohort |
Italy |
Children who were referred by their Primary Care Pediatrician for suspected precocious puberty |
March of 2020 to July of 2021 |
2014 to February of 2020 |
49 females |
Incidence of CPP diagnosis in endocrinology referrals |
30 |
19 |
3 fold-higher during COVID pandemic |