Abstract
I critically discuss Sutton’s 2012Sutton, C. 2012 “Colocated Objects, Tally Ho: A Solution to the Grounding Problem”, Mind 121: 703-30. attempt to solve the so-called “grounding problem” for coincident objects, namely, the difficulty of explaining how such objects, such as a statue and the lump of clay from which it was made, can have distinct kind and modal properties, even though they share the same proper parts and basic microphysical properties. Sutton bases her solution on an account of the extrinsic composition of the different sorts of objects involved in such cases - in particular, artefacts, organisms and persons. I show that the accounts she gives of their composition are flawed, and that her proposal therefore does not solve the grounding problem.
Keywords:
Material Object; Kinds; Identity Conditions; Composition