ANÁLISE DA COMPETIÇÃO, COOPERAÇÃO E COOPETIÇÃO: UMA COMPARAÇÃO ENTRE CLUSTERS VAREJISTAS PLANEJADOS E NÃO PLANEJADOS NA CIDADE DE SÃO PAULO

Rosângela Sarmento Silva

Universidade Federal de Sergipe - UFS. Aracaju, Sergipe - Brazil.

Denis Donaire

Universidade Municipal de São Caetano do Sul - USCS. São Caetano do Sul, São Paulo, Brazil.

Marcos Antonio Gaspar

Universidade Nove de Julho - UNINOVE. São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.

AUTHORS

1. Rosângela Sarmento Silva Professor PhD at the Department of Administration at the Federal University of Sergipe-UFS. PhD in Administration from the Municipal University of São Caetano do Sul - SP. Professor at the Department of Administration at the Federal University of Sergipe-UFS, at the master’s in administration Program - PROPADM and at the Professional master’s in public administration Program - PROFIAP. E-mail: rosangelasarmento13@gmail.com ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3044-9699

2. Denis Donaire Professor PhD at the Department of Administration at the University of São Caetano do Sul (USCS). Degree in Economics and Administrative Sciences from the Municipal Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences of Santo André, Masters in Administration from the University of São Paulo, Doctorate in Administration from the University of São Paulo and Full Professor in Administration from the University of São Paulo. Currently, he works in the Master's and Doctoral Program in Administration at the Municipal University of São Caetano do Sul (USCS). E-mail: denis.donaire@prof.uscs.edu.br ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8686-6520

3. Marcos Antonio Gaspar Professor PhD at the Department of Informatics and Knowledge Management at the Nove de Julho University - UNINOVE. PhD in Administration from the University of São Paulo - SP. Line of research: Knowledge Management. Professor and researcher at the master and doctoral’s in Informatics and Knowledge Management (PPGI) at University Nove de Julho. E-mail: marcos.antonio@uni9.pro.br ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2422-2455

Contribution of authors.

Every author should account for at least one component of the work. Paper approved for publication need to specify the contribution of every single author.

Conflict of Interest

The authors have stated that there is no conflict of interest.

2nd Ord. Const. No/PLN	1st Order Const.	AVE No/PLN	2nd Ord. Const. PLN	AVE PLN
AVE = 0.549 Coop/Collab.	EJI	0.663	AVE = 0.549 Coop/Collab.	0.585
AVE = 0.549 Coop/Collab.	JA	0.598	AVE = 0.549 Coop/Collab.	0.574
AVE = 0.295 competition	IF	0,685	AVE = 0.273 competition	0.588
	CPT	0.465		0.625
	CI	0.581		0.405
	SC	0.519		0.633
AVE = 0.395 Coopetition	VL	0.673	AVE = 0.434 Coopetition	0.594
	COOP	0.618		0.626
	PF	0.637		0.632
	CR	0.554		0.688

2nd Ord. Const.No/PLN	1st Order Const.	No/PLN	2nd Ord. Const PLN	PLN	p-V. "t" PLNI
CR = 0.930 Coop/Collab.	EJI	0.922	CC = 0.909 Coop/Collab.	0.892	0,000
CR = 0.930 Coop/Collab.	JA	0.881	CC = 0.909 Coop/Collab.	0.869	0,000
CR = 0.840 compettion	IF	0.897	CC = 0.793 competition	0.850	0,000
	CPT	0.774		0.868	0,000
	CI	0.805		0.562	0.011
	SC	0.756		0.838	0,000
CR = 0.923 Coopetition	VL	0.925	CC = 0.935 Coopetition	0.897	0,000
	COOP	0.890		0.893	0,000
	PF	0.896		0.895	0,000
	CR	0.788		0.868	0,000

2nd Ord. Const.No/PLN	1st Order Const.	JA-No/PLN	2nd Ord. Const. PLN	JA-PLN
AC = 0.917 Coop/Collab.	EJI	0.898	AC = 0.888 Coop/Collab.	0.856
AC = 0.917 Coop/Collab.	JA	0.830	AC = 0.888 Coop/Collab.	0.810
AC = 0.798 competition	IF	0.846	AC = 0.745 competition	0.765
	CPI	0.619		0.799
	CI	0.637		0.542
	SC	0.535		0.713
AC = 0.911 Coopetition	VL	0.901	AC = 0.927 Coopetition	0.859
	COOP	0.845		0.848
	PF	0.850		0.852
	CR	0.607		0.772

2nd Ord. Const. No/PLN	1st Order Const.	R2 No/PLN	P-V, "t" No/PLN	2nd Ord. Const. PLN	R2 PLN	p-V. "t" PLN
R2= 0.291 Coopetition	EJI	0.875	0,000	R2= 0.250 Coopetition	0.897	0,000
	JA	0.813	0,000		0.825	0,000
	IF	0.738	0,000		0.753	0,000
	CPI	0.569	0,000		0.482	0,000
	CI	0.010	0.016		0.161	0.776
	SC	0.363	0,000		0.586	0,000
	VL	0.706	0,000		0.763	0,000
	COOP	0.589	0,000		0.478	0,000
	PF	0792	0,000		0.713	0,000
	CR	0.689	0,000		0.431	0,000

Cooper/collaboration	Factor Loads No/PL	Factor Loads PLN
Coop/collab → JA	0.908	0.902
Coop/collab → EJI	0.947	0.935
Coop/collab. → Coopetition	0.297	0.562

Cooperation/collaboration	Difference between factor loads No/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" No/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" MGANo/PLN vs PLN
Cooper/collab → JA	0.007	0.739	0.401
Cooper/collab → EJI	0.012	0.378	0.206
Coop/collab. → Coopetition	0.265	0,000	1,000

Competition	Factor Loads No/PLN	Factor Loads PLN	p-V "t" PLN
Compet. → CPT	0.694	0.754	0,000
Compet. → CI	0.401	0.098	0.576
Compet. → SC	0.765	0.603	0,000
Compet. → IF	0.868	0.859	0,000
Compet. → Coopetition	0.382	0.112	0.138

Competition	Difference between factor loadsNo/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" No/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" MGA No/PLN vs PLN
Compet. → CPT	0.060	0.389	0.815
Compet. → CI	0.303	0.098	0.022
Compet. → SC	0.162	0.071	0.032
Compet. → IF	0.009	0.795	0.387
Compet. → Coopetition	0.270	0.006	0.003

Coopetition	Factor LoadsNo/PLN	Factor Loads PLN
Compet. → COOP	0.691	0.768
Compet. → PF	0.844	0.890
Compet. → CR	0.656	0.830
Compet. → VL	0.873	0.840

Coopetition	Differences between factor loads No/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" No/PLN vs PLN	p-V "t" MGA No/PLN vs PLN
Compet. → COOP	0.076	0.215	0.911
Compet. → PF	0.045	0.106	0.956
Compet. → CR	0.174	0.002	1,000
Compet. → VL	0.033	0.236	0.119

Brasil