Biological parameters of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) biotype B (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae) on Jatropha gossypiifolia, commercial (Manihot esculenta) and wild cassava (Manihot flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis) (Euphorbiaceae)

ECOLOGY, BEHAVIOR AND BIONOMICS

Biological parameters of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) biotype B (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae) on Jatropha gossypiifolia, commercial (Manihot esculenta) and wild cassava (Manihot flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis) (Euphorbiaceae)

Arturo Carabalí^{I, II}; Anthony C Belloti^I; James Montoya-Lerma^II

^ICentro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT), A.A. 6713, Cali, Colombia; [e-mail]

^IIGrupo de Investigaciones Entomológicas, Depto de Biología, Univ del Valle, AA 25360, Cali, Colombia; [e-mail]

ABSTRACT

Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) is one of the most important pests of cassava in Africa and several countries of Asia due to the damage caused by direct feeding, the excretion of honeydew, and its capacity as a vector of cassava mosaic geminivirus. There is a general consensus that B. tabaci is a complex of morphologically indistinguishable populations with different biotypes. In the Americas, the polyphagous biotype B does not appear to feed on cassava. Recent studies indicate that it is possible, however, for biotype B to gradually adapt to cassava using phylogenetically related hosts. Therefore, the possibility that some wild species of cassava constitute intermediate hosts in the adaptation process may lead to the establishment of biotype B on commercial varieties of Manihot esculenta. In here, we evaluated Jatropha gossypiifolia, two wild species of cassava (Manihot flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis) and a commercial cassava variety (MCol 2063) as hosts of biotype B. The highest oviposition rate (2.7 eggs /two days) occurred on M. esculenta, although the development time (44 d) was the longest when compared to M. carthaginensis and J. gossypiifolia. About 60% of the population could reproduce on the wild cassava species vs. 55% on J. gossypiifolia and 27.5% on the commercial variety. Our data suggest that J. gossypiifolia is a suitable host and the wild species M. carthaginensis can constitute a potential intermediate host in the adaptation of biotype B to commercial varieties of cassava.

Key words: Adaptation, trophic relationship, whitefly

Cassava, Manihot esculenta, is the third largest source of carbohydrates for humans in the Tropics, particularly in Africa and Asia (Fauquet & Fargette 1990, Legg et al 2002). In Africa, the most limiting factor and utmost economic importance for cassava production is the cassava mosaic disease (CMD), caused by a complex of cassava mosaic geminivirus (CMGs) (Geminiviridae: Begomovirus) (Legg et al 2002). There is a strong overlap between the geographic ranges of distribution of the African cassava mosaic virus (ACMV) and its only known vector, the sweet potato whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Robertson 1987, Fauquet & Fargette 1990).

Bemisia tabaci is a complex of morphologically indistinguishable biotypes and depending on the host, cultivar, environmental conditions and pathogen involved, they can cause until 95% of yield losses (Legg 1999). Although monophagous and oligophagous populations of B. tabaci have been reported, e.g., Jatropha (Brown et al 1995) and the cassava biotype (Abdullahi et al 2003), respectively, the complex is formed mainly by polyphagous populations (Mound 1983). Among them, the biotype B appears to have the widest host range (Brown et al 1995). On this respect, it is suggested that there is a wide range of genetic differences among the B. tabaci populations that permit them to adapt to new hosts and climates in different geographic regions (Basu 1995).

The distribution of biotype B into new areas in the Americas and the Caribbean is often associated with the movement of plants and the ability of some B. tabaci populations to adapt to a broad spectrum of new hosts (Bedford et al 1994). In Latin America, the biotype B is displacing biotype A and becoming adapted to new hosts such as cassava (M. esculenta) (Lima et al 2002, Rodríguez et al 2005). Indeed, very soon after being firstly reported on this crop in the Dominican Republic (Brown et al 1995), it was found in Cuba (Vásquez et al 1995) and, more recently, in Colombia and Ecuador (Anderson et al 2005). It is important to bear in mind that the B. tabaci complex includes vectors of viruses to crops often grown in association with cassava (e.g., common beans, sweet potatoes, tomatoes, cotton and soybeans) (Costa & Russell 1975, Bellotti & Arias 2001). In addition, studies in India revealed that B. tabaci could transmit CMV (Matew & Muniyappa 1993). All of these point to the possible circulation of viral diseases between cassava and other hosts and/or the possibility of acquirement and transmission of new viruses.

Unfortunately, there are few historic events that would allow to reconstruct or to explain the entry and subsequent colonization of hosts by B. tabaci in different areas of the world. In the case of M. esculenta, for instance, the B. tabaci populations that feed on this host in Africa and Asia are included within the cassava biotype (unlike the biotype B). The origin of this biotype, regarded as oligophagous, is unknown but it is able to develop in the wild on M. esculenta, Solanum melongena and S. aethiopicum (Legg et al 1994). The reproductive capacity of the cassava biotype has been demonstrated on Nicotiana debneyi (Thompson 2003), Manihot glaziovii (Legg et al 1994), Lycopersicon esculentum and Vigna unguiculata (Omondi et al 2005). Therefore, the hypothesis that polyphagous populations of B. tabaci (biotype B) from the Americas could become adapted to cassava should not be disregarded (Carabalí et al 2005). Using the concept of gradual adaptation on a series of intermediate hosts in the genus Manihot (comparing reproduction rates), these authors successfully bred a line of the biotype B of B. tabaci able to develop on M. esculenta.

Hence, it is plausible to postulate that the wild Manihot species could be key hosts in which B. tabaci could increase its biotic potential in the process of adaptation to M. esculenta. The objective of this study was to evaluate the potential of adaptation of B. tabaci to alternative species of Manihot. We have compared the development of Colombian biotype B populations on J. gossypiifolia, two wild cassava species (M. flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis) and commercial cassava variety (MCol 2063) (M. esculenta).

Material and Methods

Bemisia tabaci and wild cassava (Manihot spp.). The biotype B strain of B. tabaci came from a colony established on Phaseolus vulgaris var. ICA-Pijao at the CIAT Common Bean Project, originated near Dapa (Cauca Valley Province, Colombia). The colony was reared for five generations on J. gossypiifolia (Carabalí et al 2005) under controlled conditions (25 ± 2°C; 70 ± 5% RH; LD12: 12), in 1 m³ cages made of cotton mesh and wood. The purity of the strain was verified periodically by testing adults using RAPD-PCR analysis (Quintero et al 2001). Ten 40-d-old plants of J. gossypiifolia, M. flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis were supplied by CIAT's Genetic Resources Unit.

Longevity and fecundity. These life history traits were studied using forty newly emerged and previously sexed pairs (males; females) of B. tabaci coming from J. gossypiifolia. Adults were introduced into insect clip cages (diameter = 2.5 cm; depth = 2.0 cm) using a manual aspirator by placing them on the underside of the leaves of ten plants of each host (J. gossypiifolia, M. flabellifolia, M. carthaginensis and M. esculenta). Every 48h, the adults in the insect clip cage were transferred to a new leaf area. This process was continued until natural death of the females; males were replaced as they died. Fecundity was estimated as the number of eggs oviposited by females every 48h (in order to minimize disturbance and mortality).

Development time, survival rate and sex ratio. Fifty unsexed, 2-day-old adults of B. tabaci were taken from the apical leaves of J. gossypiifolia with an aspirator and transferred to insect clip cages (see above) on the underside of the leaves of J. gossypiifolia, M. flabellifolia, M. carthaginensis and M. esculenta. Adults were allowed to oviposit for 6h and 200 eggs were selected at random with the aid of a binocular (40 x) stereomicroscope. Development time from egg to adult, survival rate of the immature stages and sex ratio were recorded under the same laboratory conditions as above.

Demographic parameters. The data on the development time, the survival rate of the immature stages and the proportion of females were combined with the experimental data on reproduction (lx-mx) to generate life tables. For each experiment, the following parameters were calculated (Price 1975):

The net reproduction rate (Ro) (defined as the average number of female progeny that a female had during a generation), the generation time (T) (equivalent to the period between the eclosion of the parents and that of the progeny), the intrinsic growth rate of the population (r_m) (represents the daily contribution of each individual to population development). The intrinsic growth rate of the population (r_m) was estimated using the equation (Carey 1993):

where x, is the age of the female; lx is the specific age of survival and mx is the proportion of females of the progeny of a female at age x.

To calculate the r_m values, the corrected age (X+0.5) and the equation ln 2/ r_m for estimating the necessary days to double the population were used (Carey 1993).

Statistical analyses. Kaplan-Meier statistical package which includes four statistical tests (i.e. Gehan-Wilcoxon, Cox-Mantel, Peto-Wilcoxon and Logrank-tests) was used to compare survivorship of females among host species from median survival times (Lee 1992) (Statistix 8.0). Differences between the mean values of longevity, fecundity, oviposition rate and development time were analyzed using one-way ANOVA. Student-Newman-Keuls was used for the multiple-comparison tests. The survival rates of the immature stage were compared using χ² test (SAS Institute 1989). The life table parameters were estimated by Jackknife technique and means were compared by t test using the LIFETABLE.SAS software developed by Maia et al (2000).

Results and Discussion

Female longevity, fecundity and oviposition rate. According to the conservative Cox-Mantel and Logrank-tests, survival time was similar on all plant hosts (Table 1). However, the same B. tabaci survival on J. gossypiifolia and M. carthaginensis were statistically different when compared with M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia when analyzed with the Peto-Wilcoxon test. Further, a significant trend was observed with the Gehan-Wilcoxon test. The later is more suitable to explain the biological significance of our results as it indicates that any female reared on J. gossypiifolia survived, in average, three days (see Table 1) longer than those on M. esculenta and two days more compared with M. flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis. These differences can be observed in the survival curves (Fig 1). The survival curves also show that, the percent live females was reduced to 28, 65, 82.5 and 90% on J. gossypiifolia, M. carthaginensis, M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia, respectively, on the sixth day.

The mean longevity of B. tabaci females was higher (nine days) on J. gossypiifolia (P < 0.0001, followed by Student-Newman-Keuls P < 0.05), with females living four to six days longer on the other host plants tested (Table 2). Our data on female longevity on J. gossypiifolia was similar to that obtained when B. tabaci was reared on a suitable hosts, such as garden bean (Musa & Ren 2005).

Bemisia tabaci fecundity varied among host species (Table 2). The average number of eggs per female was 1.5, three and two times higher on J. gossypiifolia as compared with M. esculenta, M. flabellifolia and M. carthaginensis, respectively. The highest oviposition rate (2.7 eggs/female/2 days) was found on M. esculenta, being significantly higher than in the wild cassava species and J. gossypiifolia (ANOVA P < 0.0001 followed by Student-Newman-Keuls P < 0.05). In all four species, females began oviposition during the first 48h, obtaining 71% and 67% of the total fecundity on M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia, respectively; whereas on M. carthaginensis and J. gossypiifolia it reached only 36% and 12%, respectively (Fig 2). The highest number of eggs was obtained during the first 6 d of oviposition on the four hosts, with maximum values on the second day for M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia, and on the fourth day for M. carthaginensis and J. gossypiifolia. Data analyses indicated that when populations of B. tabaci were reared for some generations on J. gossypiifolia they had higher oviposition capacity and longevity.

Development time, survival rate and sex ratio. The development time of B. tabaci on J. gossypiifolia was significantly different when compared to wild Manihot species (Table 3). The survival rates of the immature stages was also affected by the host plant (χ² = 127.2, 2 d.f., P < 0.0001; Table 3). From a total of 200 eggs, 120 reached the adult stage on M. carthaginensis, compared with 101, 55 and 16 adults on J. gossypiifolia, M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia, respectively. This parameter can be a good indicator of the potential capacity that B. tabaci has for developing on the wild cassava species M. carthaginensis and on the cultivated variety. Although survival was lower on M. flabellifolia, this result has important implications, given that it constitutes a new host on which B. tabaci was able to feed, reproduce and complete its life cycle.

The sex ratio (0.5) was not affected when B. tabaci was reared on J. gossypiifolia, M. carthaginensis and M. esculenta, but had a slight difference on M. flabellifolia (0.56: 0.5) (Table 3).

Demographic parameters. The net reproductive rate of B. tabaci on J. gossypiifolia was significantly different when compared to M. esculenta and wild Manihot species (P < 0.05). Data on the net reproductive rate (Ro) allowed the estimation of a population growth of 4.3 times at each generation on J. gossypiifolia. The population growth on this host plant was two times higher than that on M. esculenta and M. carthaginensis (Table 4). Females of B. tabaci had the lower values of Ro (0.2) when reared on M. flabellifolia. This variability can be explained by the lower rate of fecundity reached on M. esculenta and wild Manihot species.

The generation time (T) was also affected by the rearing host, developing faster on J. gossypiifolia, with M. flabellifolia being the host in which the insect took the longest period to develop (Table 4).

The intrinsic growth rate (r_m) was 0.055 on J. gossypiifolia and 0.033 on M. carthaginensis (Table 4). Both values were statistically different from those obtained for populations reared on M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia (P < 0.05). However, B. tabaci had the highest growth rate on J. gossypiifolia, surpassing those reared on M. carthaginensis and M. esculenta by 40% and 75%, respectively. In case of individuals reared on M. flabellifolia, the r_m value was negative (-0.028), suggesting the wild host species had a negative impact on insect development and reproduction, reducing the population capacity to increase in number. Our data suggest that there are differences in the biotic potential of the insect reared on J. gossypiifolia and M. carthaginensis as compared with M. esculenta and M. flabellifolia.

Fecundity and longevity of B. tabaci were the biological traits most affected by wild Manihot species and M. esculenta. Similarly, the results show that of the four hosts evaluated, J. gossypiifolia was the most favorable for the adaptation of biotype B. The high survival rate in the immature stage, lower development time, and the highest intrinsic growth rate of the population represent unmistakable indicators of the suitability of J. gossypiifolia for the development of this biotype. Nevertheless, the percentage of whitefly immatures that survived on M. carthaginensis was similar to those obtained by Tsai &Wang (1996) with B. tabaci on suitable hosts such as tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) and potato (Ipomoea batatus).

The reproductive success (high fecundity and reproductive rate) obtained by B. tabaci on M. esculenta was not evident later in the development of the immature stages (survival rate). These results concur with those reported by Costa et al (1991), who did not found a direct correlation between the number of eggs deposited by B. tabaci and the survival rates on different hosts. This suggests that oviposition of B. tabaci can be a phenomenon that is not mediated by evaluating the potential quality of the host plant.

Despite the polyphagous nature of populations of B. tabaci found in the Americas and the sporadic records of whitefly on cassava (Brown et al 1995, Vásquez et al 19950, Anderson et al 2005), this crop does not appear to be an important host. Nonetheless, after a process of pre-adaptation on species phylogenetically related to the genus Manihot (Euphorbia pulcherrima and Jatropha gossypiifolia), Carabalí et al (2005) were able to show that B. tabaci found in Colombia was able to develop and reproduce on commercial cassava, thereby confirming the potential of this biotype to become adapted to this host. Moreover, J. gossypiifolia, the bridge host used in this study, still continues to support high populations of B. tabaci under laboratory rearing conditions. In contrast, J. gossypiifolia has been reported as hosting monophagous populations of the biotype known as "Jatrofa" in Puerto Rico (Brown et al 1995, Perring 2001).

These variations confirm the constant dynamics or the plasticity of the variations of populations of B. tabaci and reveal the complexity of establishing a permanent boundary between them. Taken together, these facts suggest a possible explanation for the emergence of different populations, which in relatively short periods of time acquire the status of host races or biotypes.

Our data demonstrate for the first time that the biotype B of B. tabaci can feed and reproduce on J. gossypiifolia and on two wild cassava species, closely related to M. esculenta. At the same time, it is possible that the adaptation of this biotype on M. esculenta in Colombia is favored by the existence of hosts such as J. gossypiifolia or M. carthaginensis on which B. tabaci can develop successfully. In addition, this issue is particularly valid and key at moments when several developing countries, such as Colombia, Brazil and Central American countries, are adopting strategies to increase the areas to be cultivated with Jatropha spp. (especially J. curcas (Foidl et al 1996), as they have multiple uses. However, our results recall for prudence. Despite the fact that Jatropha could yield major potential economic and environmental benefits for these countries, helping to combat soil erosion, create additional income for the rural poor, and alleviate countries' balance of payment constraints (van Eijck & Romijn 2008), at the same time they represent a risk to cassava growers as Jatropha may work as a bridge for B. tabaci to become adapted to Manihot species. This would certainly require a reevaluation of the expansion of the areas cultivated with Jatropha, as cassava crop is a primary food source for many people in the third world, and may represent the sole food source in many African and Latin American countries.

Acknowledgments

To Dr. Cesar Cardona and MSc. Juan M. Bueno (both at CIAT) for their statistical help and valuable comments on the discussion while preparing this manuscript. To Hector Morales (CIAT) for his support with the green house activities. In addition, many thanks to Bean Project-CIAT for supplying B-biotype strain. To the anonymous reviewers that help to improve the manuscript.

Received 04/XII/08.

Accepted 24/XI/09.

Edited by Wesley A Conde de Godoy ESALQ/USP

• Analytical software (2000) Statistix 8.0 user's manual, 396p.
• Abdullahi I, Winter S, Atiri G I, Thottappilly G (2003) Molecular characterization of whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae) populations infesting cassava. Bull Entomol Res 93: 97-106.
• Anderson K P, Hamon A, Hernandez P, Martin J (2005) Reproductive crop hosts of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) in Latin America and the Caribbean, p.243-250. In CIAT Whitefly and whitefly-borne viruses in the tropics: building a knowledge base for global action. CIAT International Center of Tropical Agriculture, Cali, 531p.
• Basu A N (1995) Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius): crop pest and principal whitefly vector of plant viruses. Westview Press, New Delhi, 183p.
• Bedford I, Briddon R W, Brown J K, Rosell R C, Markham P G (1994) Geminivirus transmission and biological characterization of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) biotypes from different geographic regions. Ann Appl Biol 125: 311-325.
• Bellotti A C, Arias B (2001) Host plant resistance to whiteflies with emphasis on cassava as a case study. Crop Prot 20: 813-823.
• Brown J K, Frohlinch D R, Rosell R C (1995) The sweetpotato or silverleaf whiteflies: biotypes of Bemisia tabaci or two species complex. Annu Rev Entomol 40: 511-534.
• Carabalí A, Bellotti A C, Montoya-Lerma J, Cuéllar M E (2005) Adaptation of Bemisia tabaci biotype B (Gennadius) to cassava, Manihot esculenta (Crantz). Crop Prot 24: 643-649.
• Carey J R (1993) Applied demography for biologists. Oxford University Press, New York, 206p.
• CIAT International Center of Tropical Agriculture (1999) integrated pest and disease management in major agroecosystems: annual report, project PE-1. CIAT, Cali, 136p.
• Costa H S, Brown J K, Byrne D N (1991) Life history traits of the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Genn.) (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on six virus-infected or healthy plant species. Environ Entomol 20: 1102-1107.
• Costa H S, Russell L M (1975) Failure of Bemisia tabaci to breed on cassava plants in Brazil (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae). CiÇnc Cult São Paulo 27: 388-390.
• Fauquet C, Fargette D (1990) African cassava mosaic virus: etiology, epidemiology, and control. Plant Dis 74: 401-411.
• Foidl N, Foidl G, Sanchez M, Mittlebach M, Hackel S (1996) Jatropha curcas L. as a source for the production of biofuel in Nicaragua. Bioresource Tech 58: 77-82.
• Lee E T (1992) Statistical methods for survival data analysis. 2^nd ed. Wiley & Sons, New York, 482p.
• Legg J P (1999) Emergence spread and strategies for controlling the pandemic of cassava mosaic virus disease in East and Central Africa. Crop Prot 18: 627-637.
• Legg J P, French R, Rogan D, Okao-Okuja G, Brown J K (2002) A distinct Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Hemíptera: Sternorrhyncha: Aleyrodidae) genotype 25 cluster is associated with the epidemic of severe cassava mosaic virus disease in 26 Uganda. Mol Ecol 11: 1219-1229.
• Legg J P, Gibson R W, Otim-Nape G W (1994) Genetic polymorphism amongst Uganda populations of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) vector of African cassava mosaic geminivirus. Trop Sci 34: 73-81.
• Lima L H C, Campos L, Moretzsohn M C, Navia D, Oliveira M R V (2002) Genetic diversity of Bemisia tabaci (Genn.) populations in Brazil revealed by RAPD markers. Genet Mol Biol 25: 217-223.
• Maia H N M, Luiz A J B, Campanhola C (2000) Statistical inference on associated fertility life tables parameters using jackknife technique: computational aspects. J Econ Entomol 93: 511-518.
• Matew A V, Muniyappa V (1993) Host range of Indian cassava mosaic virus. Indian Phytopathol 46: 16-23.
• Mound L A (1983) Biology and identity of whitefly vectors of plant pathogens, p.305-313. In Plumb R T & Thresh J M (eds) Plant virus epidemiology. The spread and control of insect-borne viruses. Blackwell, Oxford, 377p.
• Musa D P, Ren S X (2005) Development and reproduction of Bemisia tabaci (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on three bean species. Insect Sci 12: 25-30.
• Omondi A B, Obeng-Ofort D, Kyerematen R A, Danquah E Y (2005) Host preference and suitability of some selected crops for two biotypes of Bemisia tabaci in Ghana. Entomol Exp Appl 115: 393-400.
• Perring T M (2001) The Bemisia tabaci species complex. Crop Prot 20: 725-737.
• Price P (1975) Insect ecology. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 514p.
• Robertson I A D (1987) The whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius), as a vector of African cassava mosaic virus at the Kenya coast, and ways in which the yield losses in cassava, Manihot esculenta Crantz, caused by the virus, can be reduced. Insect Sci Appl 8: 797-801.
• Quintero C, Rendón F, García J, Cardona C, López-Avila A, Hernández P (2001) Especies y biotipos de moscas blancas (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) en cultivos semestrales de Colombia y Ecuador. Rev Col Entomol 27: 27-31.
• Rodríguez I, Morales H, Bueno J M, Cardona C (2005) El biotipo B de Bemisia tabaci (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) adquiere mayor importancia en el Valle del Cauca. Rev Col Entomol 31: 21-28.
• SAS Institute (1989) SAS/STAT User's guide version 6. 4^th ed. vol. 2, SAS Institute, Cary, N.C., 846p.
• Thompson W M O (2003) A new host plant species for the cassava biotype of Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Hom., Aleyrodidae). J Appl Entomol 127: 374-376.
• Tsai J H, Wang K (1996) Development and reproduction of Bemisia argentifolii (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on five host plants. Environ Entomol 25: 810-816.
• van Eijck J, Romijn H (2008) Prospects for Jatropha biofuels in Tanzania: an analysis with strategic niche management. Energy Policy 36: 311-325.
• Vásquez L L, Jiménez R, Iglesias M, Mateo A, López D, Vera R (1995) Moscas blancas (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) detectadas en los principales cultivos agrícolas de Cuba. Man Int Plagas 36: 18-21.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  14 Sept 2010
• Date of issue
  Aug 2010

History

• Received
  04 Dec 2008
• Accepted
  24 Nov 2009