Temperature and pH of the nutrient solution on wheat primary root growth

Temperatura e pH da solução nutritiva no crescimento das raízes primárias do trigo

Abstracts

O crescimento das raízes primárias é de grande importância para o estabelecimento da cultura do trigo (Triticum aestivum L.) em condição de sequeiro no Estado de São Paulo. Quatorze genótipos (linhagens mutantes e cultivares) de trigo foram comparados quanto ao crescimento das raízes primárias durante 7 e 15 dias de desenvolvimento em soluções nutritivas completas, com arejamento, em condição de laboratório. No primeiro experimento, empregaram-se soluções com três valores de pH (4,0; 5,0 e 6,0) mantendo-se constante a temperatura (24 ± 1°C) e no segundo, utilizaram-se soluções com mesmo pH (4,0), porém com três temperaturas (18°C ± 1°C, 24°C ± 1°C e 30°C ± 1°C). Observou-se grande variabilidade genética entre os genótipos avaliados para crescimento das raízes primárias nos primeiros estádios de desenvolvimento independentemente do pH, temperatura e período de crescimento nas soluções nutritivas. Os genótipos 6 (BH-1146) e 13 (IAC-17), tolerantes ao Al³+ exibiram potencial genético para maior crescimento radicular nos primeiros estádios de desenvolvimento (7 e 15 dias), independentemente da temperatura e do pH das soluções nutritivas. Os genótipos 14 (IAC-24 M), 15 (IAC-24), 17 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M2, 18 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M3 e 24 (KAUZ"S" / IAC-24 M3), tolerantes ao Al³+, apresentaram reduzido crescimento radicular nas mesmas condições.

Triticum aestivum L.; cultura de sequeiro; crescimento radicular

SOILS AND PLANT NUTRITION

Temperature and pH of the nutrient solution on wheat primary root growth

Temperatura e pH da solução nutritiva no crescimento das raízes primárias do trigo

Carlos Eduardo de Oliveira Camargo^*; Antonio Wilson Penteado Ferreira Filho; Marcus Vinicius Salomon

IAC - Centro de Análise e Pesquisa Tecnológica do Agronegócio de Grãos e Fibras - C.P. 28 - 13001-970 - Campinas, SP - Brasil

ABSTRACT

Primary root growth is very important for wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) crop in upland conditions in the State of São Paulo. Fourteen wheat genotypes (mutant lines and cultivars) were evaluated for primary root growth during 7 and 15 days of development in complete and aerated nutrient solutions, in the laboratory. In the first experiment, solutions with three pH values (4.0, 5.0 and 6.0) at constant temperature (24 ± 1°C), and in the second experiment, solutions with the same pH (4.0) but with three temperatures (18°C ± 1°C, 24°C ± 1°C and 30°C ± 1°C) were used. High genetic variability was observed among the evaluated genotypes in relation to primary root growth in the first stages of development in nutrient solutions independent of pH, temperature and growth period. Genotypes 6 (BH-1146) and 13 (IAC-17), tolerant to Al³⁺ showed genetic potential for root growth in the first stages of development (7 and 15 days), regardless of nutrient solution temperature and pH. Genotypes 14 (IAC-24 M), 15 (IAC-24), 17 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M₂, 18 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M₃ and 24 (KAUZ"S" / IAC-24 M₃), tolerant to Al³⁺, showed reduced root growth under the same conditions.

Key words:Triticum aestivum L., upland crop, root growth

RESUMO

O crescimento das raízes primárias é de grande importância para o estabelecimento da cultura do trigo (Triticum aestivum L.) em condição de sequeiro no Estado de São Paulo. Quatorze genótipos (linhagens mutantes e cultivares) de trigo foram comparados quanto ao crescimento das raízes primárias durante 7 e 15 dias de desenvolvimento em soluções nutritivas completas, com arejamento, em condição de laboratório. No primeiro experimento, empregaram-se soluções com três valores de pH (4,0; 5,0 e 6,0) mantendo-se constante a temperatura (24 ± 1°C) e no segundo, utilizaram-se soluções com mesmo pH (4,0), porém com três temperaturas (18°C ± 1°C, 24°C ± 1°C e 30°C ± 1°C). Observou-se grande variabilidade genética entre os genótipos avaliados para crescimento das raízes primárias nos primeiros estádios de desenvolvimento independentemente do pH, temperatura e período de crescimento nas soluções nutritivas. Os genótipos 6 (BH-1146) e 13 (IAC-17), tolerantes ao Al³⁺ exibiram potencial genético para maior crescimento radicular nos primeiros estádios de desenvolvimento (7 e 15 dias), independentemente da temperatura e do pH das soluções nutritivas. Os genótipos 14 (IAC-24 M), 15 (IAC-24), 17 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M₂, 18 (MON"S" / ALD "S") ´ IAC-24 M₃ e 24 (KAUZ"S" / IAC-24 M₃), tolerantes ao Al³⁺, apresentaram reduzido crescimento radicular nas mesmas condições.

Palavras-chave:Triticum aestivum L., cultura de sequeiro, crescimento radicular

INTRODUCTION

In Brazil, wheat is cultivated in upland acidic soil conditions, in rotations with soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] or (and) maize (Zea mays L.) crops, in the period of April to August. The development of plants with higher yielding potential, semi-dwarf, resistant to diseases, tolerant to aluminum toxicity and showing good nutritive and technological qualities, are the main goals of the brazilian wheat breeding programs for acidic soils. In addition, inbred-line breeding and selection for longer primary roots is important considering the short sowing period (April) when the occurrence of water stress associated or not with short periods of high air-temperature, namely "heat shocks" is frequent (Mundstock, 1983). Besides the Al³⁺-tolerance, plants must have long primary roots in the initial growth stages, to allow for good crop establishment. Such periods of drought stress may also occur from May to August, requiring that plants have longer adventitious roots able to reach deeper into the soil.

The mechanisms involved in drought resistance in wheat include early grain maturation, allowing that harvest happens before the period of water stress; vigorous and deep root system able to use the soil available moisture efficiently, stomata closure ability to reduce water loss, and a waxy leaf surface to avoid transpiration (Poehlman & Sleper, 1995).

The early wheat cultivar BH-1146, highly Al³⁺ - tolerant in acidic soils, has also shown high tolerance to drought compared to other cultivars. Previous research using Al-free nutrient solution has shown that the cultivar has the longest root system compared to other 26 wheat genotypes (Camargo et al., 1995). Similar results were reported by Camargo & Oliveira (1981a), studying BH-1146 under non-limiting nutrient level, Al-free, pH 4.0 solution who reported a higher potential for root growth in these plants, evidencing their specificity for this trait.

The use of gamma radiation in seeds of some wheat cultivars generated plants with specific agronomic characteristics, such as tolerance to Al, usually present in acidic soils (Camargo et al., 1997; Tulmann Neto et al., 1995a; 1995b; 1996 and 2001). Most of the published research on this subject has been done in the presence of Al³⁺ and has shown that in the wheat early development stages, root growth is affected by temperature, pH, salts and phosphorus concentrations of the nutrient solutions (Ali, 1973; Camargo & Oliveira, 1981a; Camargo, 1983; 1984; Moore, 1974; Moore et al., 1976).

The objective of this research was to evaluate the root growth of several wheat genotypes (mutant inbred lines and cultivars) after 7 and 15 days of growth in nutrient solutions without Al³⁺, under different temperature and pH conditions.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two experiments were conducted in the laboratory. The first was set up with variable nutrient solution pH values and controlled temperature, and the second, with variable nutrient solution temperatures and controlled pH, in order to evaluate the pH and temperature effects on the wheat seedling primary root growth. Fourteen genotypes were used in each experiment (Table 1), which were previously selected from 45 genotypes as to root growth in nutrient solutions (Camargo et al., 2002). Except for the cultivar Anahuac and the mutant line Anahuac M₃, both susceptible to Al³⁺ toxicity (no growth of primary central roots after 48-hour treatment in nutrient solution containing 2 mg L^-1 of Al³⁺), all the other genotypes evaluated had shown tolerance to Al³⁺ toxicity, i.e. root growth after a 48-hour treatment in nutrient solution containing 10 mg L^-1 of Al³⁺, according to technique developed by Camargo & Oliveira (1981a).

In experiment 1, seeds of wheat genotypes (originated from Tatuí, State of São Paulo - 23^o20'S, 47^o52'W alt. 600 m - harvested in 1999 and stored in cold/dry chamber) were rinsed in 10% sodium hypochloride solution and put to germinate in Petri dishes in the refrigerator at 12°C during 72 h. After this period, root emergence was starting and 25 germinated seeds of each genotype were put on top of a nylon netting, using nippers, adapted over 8.3 L-plastic recipients, containing complete full strength nutrient solutions, with three pH treatments: 4.0, 5.0 and 6.0. The treatment solutions were arranged in a randomized complete block design with two replications. The nylon netting with the seeds on top was kept in contact with a complete nutrient solution, which consisted of the following nutrient concentrations: Ca(NO₃)₂ 4 mmol L^-1, MgSO₄ 2 mmol L^-1, KNO₃ 4 mmol L^-1, (NH₄)₂SO₄ 0.435 mmol L^-1, KH₂PO₄ 0.5 mmol L^-1, MnSO₄ 2 mmol L^-1, CuSO₄ 0.3 mmol L^-1, ZnSO₄ 0.8 mmol L^-1, NaCl 30 mmol L^-1, Fe-CYDTA 10 mmol L^-1, Na₂MoO₄ 0.10 mmol L^-1 and H₃BO₃ 10 mmol L^-1.

The nutrient solution pH treatments were adjusted using a 0.5 mol L^-1 H₂SO₄ or 1 mol L^-1 NaOH solution. The nutrient solutions in the recipients were continuously aerated and maintained in water-bath at 24 ± 1°C, in the laboratory. After that, ten 7-day-old seedlings of each genotype were removed from each recipient and evaluated for central primary root length. The remaining seedlings were kept eight more days under the same conditions. After that ten other seedlings (15 days old) were sampled for root length measurements. During Experiment 1, the pH treatments were adjusted daily to 4.0, 5.0 or 6.0, in their respective recipients, using 0.5 mol L^-1 H₂SO₄ or 1 mol L^-1 NaOH solutions.

The average primary root length of each genotype was calculated for the 7-day-old and 15-day-old seedlings, for each pH treatment. The data were submitted to analysis of variance (F test, 0.05), for a randomized complete block design with two replications, for the genotype effect, nutrient solution pH effect and the interaction genotype x pH on the root growth. Mean comparisons were done using Duncan's test (0.05).

In Experiment 2, the same procedures and materials were used regarding seed germination, experimental design, recipient size and seed support, nutrient solution composition and aeration, and the same 14 genotypes. The nutrient solution pH was adjusted to 4.0. Treatments consisted of three nutrient solution temperatures: 18°C ± 1°C, 24°C ± 1°C and 30°C ± 1°C. The 8.3 L- plastic recipients with nutrient solutions were kept in water-bath with temperature control. Ten 7-day-old and 15-day-old seedlings were sampled for the primary root length measurements. During this period, nutrient solution pH was monitored and adjusted daily to as close as possible to 4.0, with 0.5 mol L^-1 H₂SO₄ and/or 1 mol L^-1 NaOH solutions.

The primary root length data were submitted to analysis of variance (F test, 0.05) for randomized complete block with two replications, for the genotype effect, temperature effect and interaction effect (genotypes ´ temperatures). Mean comparisons among genotypes within each temperature treatment and among different temperatures were done by the Duncan's test (0.05).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Experiment 1 - The ANOVA for root growth data obtained during 7 and 15 days in complete nutrient solution, with pH values of 4.0; 5.0 and 6.0 showed effects of genotype and pH but no interactions between the two.

Root growth measured on the 7^th day (145 mm – Table 1) and on the 15^th day (222 mm - Table 2) in pH 4.0 solutions were higher when compared to the root growth of the same genotypes and age at pH 6.0 (133 and 198 mm, respectively). These results are consistent with those of Camargo (1984) who found a reduction trend in wheat root growth as pH increased from 4.0 to 6.0 when cultivated in complete nutrient solution.

Lower root growth at higher pH, in the absence of Al^{3 +} may be due to lower phosphorus uptake and lower availability of iron and other micronutrients (Salisbury & Ross, 1969). This conflicts with the situation where a constant amount of aluminum is supplied in the nutrient solution and pH is changed from 4.0 to 6.0, and where reasonable root growth of wheat seedlings takes place in pH 6.0 (Camargo, 1984). The hydrolysis theory may elucidate this, since a 10-fold trivalent aluminum (Al³⁺) compared to bivalent form (AlOH²⁺) occurs under pH 4.0; 3.1-fold at pH 4.5; while at pH 5.0 the trivalent and bivalent ionic species are practically equivalent (Foy & Fleming, 1978).

Experiment 2 - The ANOVA for wheat root growth data over 7 and 15 days in complete nutrient solution under three temperatures showed effects of genotype and solution temperature but no interactions between the two.

The average 14 genotypes root growth after 7 days (117 mm – Table 3) and 15 days (208 mm – Table 4) in nutrient solution at 18°C was lower (P < 0.05) than the growth for the same genotypes and growth periods at 30°C (143 and 260 mm, respectively). This is not consistent with the data of Camargo (1983) who found a trend of wheat root growth reduction with increasing solution temperature from 22 to 34°C, in solution with varying aluminum concentrations. The same was found by Benitez (1977) for the rye cultivar 1443 which showed root growth in nutrient solution with 35 mg L^-1 of Al³⁺ at 25°C but not with 20 mg L^-1 of Al³⁺ at 30°C. According to the author the higher temperature increased the proportion of aluminum uptake induced by metabolic processes.

With the exception of Anahuac and Anahuac M₃ all genotypes were tolerant to Al³⁺ toxicity, i.e., showed root growth in standard nutrient solution after 48 hours in a solution with 10 mg L^-1 of Al³⁺ (Tulmann Neto et al., 2001). The non-tolerant genotypes do not show root growth in similar conditions due to the occurrence of an irreversible damage in the primary root apical meristem. The classification proposed by Moore et al. (1976) and modified by Camargo & Oliveira (1981a), considers as tolerant a genotype that shows some root growth and non-tolerant when no growth is detected. In practice, a tolerant genotype may show higher or lower root growth in relation to another tolerant genotype in the same conditions (Camargo & Oliveira, 1981a).

The difference between a tolerant and a non-tolerant genotype to a given toxic Al³⁺ concentration is due to a pair of dominant alleles (Camargo et al., 2000b). Data from this research suggest that the pair of alleles linked to Al³⁺ toxicity tolerance would not be the same genes involved in the control of root growth in the absence of aluminum stress. Furthermore, it would not be correct to state that a genotype is more Al-tolerant than another based upon a higher root growth in solutions without aluminum, after a developing period in solutions with a given aluminum content, as proposed by Camargo et al., 1995 and Camargo, 1993.

Despite the decrease in root growth as nutrient solution pH increased from 4.0 to 6.0 and the opposite reaction as temperature raised from 18 to 30^oC, considering the average values, all tested genotypes showed similar response to the solution pH and temperature treatments. This was confirmed by the absence of interactions between genotype and pH and between genotype and temperature in the nutrient solutions. At lower temperatures root growth usually surpasses that of above-ground parts, but as temperature raises, both plant parts have increased growth, although, shoots grow at a faster rate than roots (Evans, 1975).

It has been suggested that root growth is genetically controlled and is little affected by environment (pH and temperature) in the same way as tall genotypes differ from dwarf ones (Camargo et al., 2000a). High restrict sense heritability values for plant height were found by several authors (Johnson et al., 1966; Camargo et al., 1980, 2000a), thus, indicating that this trait is controlled by a few genes (Camargo & Oliveira, 1981b), with environment not playing an important role upon their expression. Consequently, successful selection in segregating populations can be performed in the F₂ generation.

To demonstrate that root growth is genetically controlled, crosses between high and reduced root growth genotypes should be done and seedlings from F₂ and F₃ generations selected according its growth ability in nutrient solution. As a result, in the segregating generations distribution frequencies, heritabilities for this trait as well as the number of involved genes for the root growth could be established. In the future, selected lines with high root growth could be incorporated in the wheat breeding program to develop genotypes well adapted to the State of São Paulo short sowing period (April), when the occurrence of moisture stresses is common, thus improving the chances of successful crops.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

To 'Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo' (FAPESP), to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Vienna, Austria and to 'Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico' (CNPq) for the financial support and scholarships.

Received May 29, 2003

Accepted March 26, 2004

• ALI, S.M.E. Influence of cations on aluminum toxicity in wheat (Triticum aestivum Vill., Host). Corvallis: Oregon State University, 1973. 102p. (Thesis - Doctorate).
• BENITEZ, A.L. Influence of aluminum toxicity in intergeneric crosses of wheat and rye. Corvallis: Oregon State University, 1977. 107p. (Thesis - Ph.D).
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O. Efeito da temperatura da solução nutritiva na tolerância ao alumínio de cultivares de trigo. Bragantia, v.42, p.51-63, 1983.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O. O pH das soluções nutritivas no comportamento de cultivares de trigo à toxicidade de alumínio. Bragantia, v.43, p.327-335, 1984.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O. Trigo. In: FURLANI, A.M.C.; VIEGAS, G.P. (Ed.) O melhoramento de plantas no Instituto Agronômico. Campinas: Instituto Agronômico, 1993. cap.12, p.433-488.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; OLIVEIRA, O.F. Tolerância de cultivares de trigo a diferentes níveis de alumínio em solução nutritiva e no solo. Bragantia, v.40, p.21-31, 1981a.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; OLIVEIRA, O.F. Melhoramento do trigo. II. Estudo genético de fontes de nanismo para a cultura do trigo. Bragantia, v.40, p.77-91, 1981b.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; FELICIO, J.C.; TULMANN NETO, A.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P.; PETTINELLI JR., A.; CASTRO, J.L. de. Melhoramento do trigo: XXVIII. Novos genótipos obtidos por seleções em população segregante interespecífica submetida à irradiação gama. Bragantia, v.54, p.51-65, 1995.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P.; FELICIO, J.C. Estimativas de herdabilidade e correlações quanto à produção de grãos e outras características agronômicas em populações de trigo. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, v.35, p.369-379, 2000a.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; KRONTAD, W.E.; METZGER, R.J. Parent-progeny regression estimates and associations of height levels with aluminum toxicity and grain yield in wheat. Crop Science, v.20, p.255-358, 1980.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; TULMANN NETO, A.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P.; FELICIO, J.C.; CASTRO, J.L. de; PETTINELLI JR., A. Novos genótipos de trigo (Triticum aestivum L.) obtidos por irradiação gama. Scientia Agricola, v.54, p.195-202, 1997.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; TULMANN NETO, A.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P.; FELICIO, J.C. Genetic control of aluminum tolerance in mutant lines of the wheat cultivar Anahuac. Euphytica, v.114, p.47-53, 2000b.
• CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P.; RAMOS, L.C. da S.; FELICIO, J.C.; TULMANN NETO, A. Primary root growth: genetics and differential among wheat mutant lines in nutrient solutions. In: RESEARCH CO-ORDINATION MEETING OF FAO/IAEA CO-ORDINATED RESEARCH PROJECT ON MUTATIONAL ANALYSIS OF ROOT CHARACTERS IN ANNUAL FOOD PLANTS RELATED TO PLANT PERFORMANCE, 1., Viena, 2000. Report Viena: IAEA, 2002. p.43-46.
• EVANS, L.T. Crop physiology some case histories Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1975. 374p.
• FOY, C.D.; FLEMING, A.L. The physiology of plant tolerance to excess available aluminum and manganese in acid soils. In: CROP TOLERANCE TO SUBOPTIMAL LAND CONDITIONS, Houston, 1978. Proccedings Madison: ASA, 1978. p.301-328.
• JOHNSON, V.A.; BIEVER, K.J.; HAUNOLD, A.; SCHMIDT. J.W. Inheritance of plant height, yield of grain, and other plant and seed characteristics in a cross of hard red winter wheat, Triticum aestivum L. Crop Science, v.6, p.336-338, 1966.
• MOORE, D.P. Physiological effects of pH on plant roots. In: CARSON, E.W. (Ed.) The plant root and its environment Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1974. p.135-151.
• MOORE, D.P.; KRONSTAD, W.E.; METZGER, R.J. Screening wheat for aluminum tolerance. In: WORKSHOP ON PLANT ADAPTATION TO MINERAL STRESS IN PROBLEM SOILS, Beltsville, 1976. Proccedings Ithaca: Cornell University, 1976. p.287-295.
• MUNSTOCK, C.M. Cultivo dos cereais de estação fria: trigo, cevada, aveia, centeio, alpiste e triticale. 1.ed. Porto Alegre: Gráfica e Editora NBS Ltda, 1983. 265p.
• POEHLMAN, J.N.; SLEPER, D.A. Breeding field crops. 4.ed. Ames: Iowa State University Press, 1995. 494p.
• SALISBURY, F.B.; ROSS, C. Plant physiology. Belmont: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1969. 747p.
• TULMANN NETO, A.; CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; ALVES, M.C.; CASTRO, J.L. de; GALLO, P.B. Indução de mutação visando a redução de altura de planta e resistência às doenças no cultivar de trigo (Triticum aestivum L.) IAC-17. Scientia Agricola, v.52, p.287-293, 1995a.
• TULMANN NETO, A.; CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; ALVES, M.C.; SANTOS, R.R. dos; FREITAS, J.G. de. Indução de mutação visando a obtenção de resistência às doenças na cultivar de trigo IAC-24. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, v.30, p.497-504, 1995b.
• TULMANN NETO, A.; CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; PETTINELLI JR., A.; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P. Plant height reduction and disease resistance in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivar IAC-18 by gamma irradiation-induced mutations. Revista Brasileira de Genética, v.19, p.275-281, 1996.
• TULMANN NETO, A.; CAMARGO, C.E. de O.; CASTRO, J.L. de; FERREIRA FILHO, A.W.P. New Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes tolerant to aluminum toxicity obtained by mutation breeding. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, v.36, p.61-70, 2001.

Publication Dates

• Publication in this collection
  02 July 2004
• Date of issue
  June 2004

History

• Received
  29 May 2003
• Accepted
  26 Mar 2004