Abstract
Objective
To analyze the meanings attributed by sex workers to the quality of life evidenced in the structure of social representations.
Methods
Qualitative study based on the Theory of Social Representations, with a total of 133 women from the Alto Sertão Produtivo Baiano. A script containing the stimulus ‘quality of life’ was applied to the test of free evocation of words. The evocations were analyzed with the four houses chart and the maximum tree of similarity.
Results
It is assumed that the meanings attributed to quality of life, present in the central structure of the participants’ representations, are associated with the words healthy life, mental health, peace, protection, safety, money and family, referring to a positive meaning of the concept pointed out by the World Health Organization. However, a possible subgroup in the contrast zone is evident, perhaps due to the context, experiences and experiences different from the other participants, with emphasis on the evocations of sadness, stress and anxiety, which refer to the problems faced in the everyday sexual service.
Conclusion
It was present in the structure of the social representations of sex workers, meanings focused on healthy life and financial resources (important for their and their family’s survival) that refer to the conceptual and attitudinal aspects that shape the concept of quality of life.
Sex workers; Quality of life; Women’s health
Resumo
Objetivo
Analisar os sentidos atribuídos por trabalhadoras do sexo à qualidade de vida evidenciados na estrutura das representações sociais.
Métodos
Estudo qualitativo baseado na Teoria das Representações Sociais, com 133 mulheres do Alto Sertão Produtivo Baiano. Aplicou-se um roteiro contendo o estímulo ‘qualidade de vida’ para o teste de evocação livre de palavras. As evocações foram analisadas com o quadro de quatro casas e a árvore máxima de similitude.
Resultados
Pressupõe-se que os sentidos atribuídos à qualidade de vida, presentes na estrutura central das representações das participantes, estão associados aos léxicos vida saudável, saúde mental, paz, proteção, segurança, dinheiro e família, remetendo a uma acepção positiva do conceito apontado pela Organização Mundial de Saúde. Contudo, evidencia-se um possível subgrupo na zona de contraste, talvez pelo contexto, vivências e experiências distintas das demais participantes, com destaque para as evocações tristeza, estresse e ansiedade, as quais remetem aos problemas enfrentados no cotidiano do serviço sexual.
Conclusão
Fez-se presente na estrutura das representações sociais das trabalhadoras sexuais, sentidos voltados à vida saudável e aos recursos financeiros (importante para sobrevivência delas e dos familiares) que remetem aos aspectos conceituais e atitudinais que conformam o conceito de qualidade de vida.
Profissionais do sexo; Qualidade de vida; Saúde da mulher
Resumen
Objetivo
Analizar los sentidos atribuidos por trabajadoras sexuales a la calidad de vida evidenciados en la estructura de las representaciones sociales.
Métodos
Estudio cualitativo basado en la teoría de las representaciones sociales, con 133 mujeres del Alto Sertão Produtivo del estado de Bahia. Se aplicó un guion que contenía el estímulo “calidad de vida” en la prueba de evocación libre de palabras. Las evocaciones se analizaron con el cuadro de cuatro casas y el árbol máximo de similitud.
Resultados
Se presupone que los sentidos atribuidos a la calidad de vida, presentes en la estructura central de las representaciones de las participantes, están asociados a los léxicos vida saludable, salud mental, paz, protección, seguridad, dinero y familia, que remite a una aceptación positiva del concepto indicado por la Organización Mundial de la Salud. Sin embargo, se evidencia un posible subgrupo en la zona de contraste, tal vez por el contexto, las vivencias y las experiencias distintas de las demás participantes, con énfasis en las evocaciones tristeza, estrés y ansiedad, que remiten a los problemas enfrentados en la cotidianidad del servicio sexual.
Conclusión
En la estructura de las representaciones sociales de las trabajadoras sexuales, se observan sentidos orientados a la vida saludable y a los recursos financieros (importante para su supervivencia y la de sus familiares), que remiten a los aspectos conceptuales y actitudinales que conforman el concepto de calidad de vida.
Trabajadores sexuales; Calidad de vida; Salud de la mujer
Introduction
Paid and consented sexual service can be conceptualized as the exchange of sexual pleasure (of the client) for income or other means that allow not only cisgender women, but also some transgender and transvestite men and women included in this practice, a form of livelihood/subsistence, which predates capitalism and goes hand in hand with the historical development of civilizations.(11. Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.
2. Martynowskyj E. Prostituição e feminismo(s). Disputas de reconhecimento nos Encontros Nacionais de Mulheres (Argentina, 1986-2017). Sex Salud Soc. 2018;30:22-49.-33. Silva AP, Santos CR, Carvalho MG. Entre prazeres e sofrimentos: vivências subjetivas de trabalhadoras sexuais em São Paulo. Cad Psicol Social Trab. 2018;21(2):181-95.) For progressive feminist theorists, sex work must be regulated in order to guarantee labor rights and legal support from the State.(11. Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.,33. Silva AP, Santos CR, Carvalho MG. Entre prazeres e sofrimentos: vivências subjetivas de trabalhadoras sexuais em São Paulo. Cad Psicol Social Trab. 2018;21(2):181-95.
4. Piscitelli A. Sexual economies, love and human trafficking – new conceptual issues. Cad Pagu. 2016;47:e16475.-55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.)
Today’s society is permeated by inequities of gender, race and social class. Women in particular, as they are traditionally seen as a lower segment, are inserted into a plot impregnated by prejudices and devaluations that culminate in several situations that make them vulnerable, such as sex work.(66. Medrado AC, De Jesus ML. Ainda assim me levanto 1”: as narrativas históricas e a construção do eu feminino. Estud Pesqui Psicol. 2018;18(4):1348-71.)It is noteworthy that the concept of vulnerability goes beyond/diverges from risk or risky behavior, as it brings up the notion of exposure, involvement with injuries and breaking with the blaming idea fostered by risk. Thus, vulnerability was considered, after the beginning of the AIDS pandemic (in the early 1990s), to explain the context and situations that fostered the illness of certain social groups.(77. Bertolozzi MR, Nichiata LY, Takahashi RF, Ciosak SI, Hino P, Val LF, et al. The vulnerability and the compliance in collective health. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2009;43(Spe 2):1326-30.-88. Ayres JR, Paiva V, França I Jr, Gravato N, Lacerda R, Della Negra M, et al. Vulnerability, human rights, and comprehensive health care needs of young people living with HIV/AIDS. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(6):1001-6.)
Thus, thinking about vulnerability is understanding that social and State aspects, such as public policies and services in question, contribute to the presence of obstacles that interfere in the health-disease process of population groups.(88. Ayres JR, Paiva V, França I Jr, Gravato N, Lacerda R, Della Negra M, et al. Vulnerability, human rights, and comprehensive health care needs of young people living with HIV/AIDS. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(6):1001-6.) Therefore, sex workers make up a social group that has historically been helpless by the State, with their rights denied and with the possibility of being affected by a health problem, are considered vulnerable.(77. Bertolozzi MR, Nichiata LY, Takahashi RF, Ciosak SI, Hino P, Val LF, et al. The vulnerability and the compliance in collective health. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2009;43(Spe 2):1326-30.)
This contributes for them to be in a group with greater susceptibility to injuries due to stigma, prejudice, violence arising from the actions of clients and, mainly, the absence of public policies that guarantee protection and access to health services. Stereotypes attributed to sex work greatly interfere in daily life, in sociodemographic indicators, in the health-disease process and in the knowledge/perception of quality of life.(99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.
10. Leal CB, Souza DA, Rios MA. Aspectos de vida e saúde das profissionais do sexo. J Nurs UFPE On Line. 2017;11(11):4483-91. Review.-1111. Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.)
The term quality of life is determined as a subjective variable and only the individual, based on their experiences, can qualitatively assess and determine it.(1212. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.) The World Health Organization (WHO) proposes the assessment or perception of quality of life through a set of elements, encompassing spiritual, physical, mental well-being, social relationships, financial, educational, cultural issues and aspects inherent to basic sanitation.(1212. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.,1313. Carter A, Greene S, Money D, Sanchez M, Webster K, Nicholson V, Brotto LA, Hankins C, Kestler M, Pick N, Salters K, Proulx-Boucher K, O’Brien N, Patterson S, de Pokomandy A, Loutfy M, Kaida A; CHIWOS Research Team. Supporting the Sexual Rights of Women Living With HIV: A Critical Analysis of Sexual Satisfaction and Pleasure Across Five Relationship Types. J Sex Res. 2018;55(9):1134-54.)
Therefore, the objective is to analyze the meanings attributed by sex workers to the quality of life evidenced in the structure of social representations.
Methods
Descriptive and qualitative study, based on the structural approach of the Theory of Social Representations (TSR), which refers to the way in which the central nucleus is organized and structured. It reiterates that TSR emerges from knowledge formulated from common sense, composed of meanings constructed and shared within a belonging group, which reverberate in practices and behaviors.(1414. Marková I. The making of the theory of social representations. Cad Pesq. 2017;47(163):358-75.
15. Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.-1616. Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.) The central core is rigid, permanent and difficult to be modified, giving meaning to social representations. The representational structure is also shaped by a peripheral system, which is linked to the practical and behavioral attributes exercised by people.(1717. Wolter RP, SÁ CP. A relação entre representações e práticas: a trilha esquecida. Rev Int Cien Soc Hum. 2013;23(1-2):87-105.,1818. Wakiuchi J, Oliveira DC, Marcon SS, Oliveira ML, Sales CA. Meanings and dimensions of cancer by sick people – a structural analysis of social representations. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2020;54:e03504.)
The sex workers who contributed to the research came from the Alto Sertão Produtivo Baiano, whose region comprises 19 cities and approximately 400000 inhabitants.(99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.)
The sample was non-probabilistic and the selection of participants was based on convenience. A total of 133 women participated (cisgender, as no trans or transvestite women were found) who met the inclusion criteria: being 18 years old or older and being in sex work during the data collection period. As it is difficult to estimate this population, the Snowball was adopted as a technique for selecting and recruiting the participants.(1919. Vinuto J. A amostragem em bola de neve na pesquisa qualitative: um debate em aberto. Temáticas. 2014;22(44):203-20.) The researcher made the initial approach through the community health agents, who started the snowball, being responsible for locating, indicating and inviting women to participate, who later also indicated other participants.(1919. Vinuto J. A amostragem em bola de neve na pesquisa qualitative: um debate em aberto. Temáticas. 2014;22(44):203-20.)
Data collection was carried out individually, in a reserved room inside two Basic Health Units with Family Health teams, between April 2017 and June 2018. However, some participants were unable to travel to these units and requested an appointment to answer the instrument in their homes or places of work.
For that, a script was prepared by the researchers, which contained questions for the characterization of the participants and the Test of Free Evocation of Words (TFEW) to the inducing stimulus “quality of life”. The responsible researcher and two undergraduate monitors (previously trained) were responsible for filling out the instrument with the evoked words, as the participants quickly spoke up to five words that came to mind in association with the stimulus. It should be noted that the average response time was 35 seconds for each participant, which was not audio-recorded.
The evocations resulting from the TFEW were typed in the Microsoft Word 2016 software, then organized into a database for processing in the EVOC 2003 software, which produced the Four House Chart, through the hierarchy expressed by the frequency and average order of evocation (AOE) , for prototypical analysis, considering criteria of hierarchy and salience, highlighting its probable central nucleus and its peripheral system.(1717. Wolter RP, SÁ CP. A relação entre representações e práticas: a trilha esquecida. Rev Int Cien Soc Hum. 2013;23(1-2):87-105.,1818. Wakiuchi J, Oliveira DC, Marcon SS, Oliveira ML, Sales CA. Meanings and dimensions of cancer by sick people – a structural analysis of social representations. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2020;54:e03504.)
Then, the analysis of similitude was carried out, with the aim of deepening the degree of connectedness and co-occurrence of the central and peripheral elements, arranged in the four houses chart.(2020. Rodrigues AS, Oliveira JF, Suto CS, Coutinho MP, Paiva MS, Souza SS. Care for women involved with drugs: social representations of nurses. Rev Bras Enferm. 2017;70(1):71-8.) The Maximum Tree of Similitude (graphic representation with connection of the elements without the formation of a cycle), is constituted by means of calculations of co-occurrence between the terms, the index of similarity of the words (two by two) that are part of the whole picture, considering only the participants who evoked, at least, two words.(2020. Rodrigues AS, Oliveira JF, Suto CS, Coutinho MP, Paiva MS, Souza SS. Care for women involved with drugs: social representations of nurses. Rev Bras Enferm. 2017;70(1):71-8.,2121. Donato SP, Ens RT, Favoreto ED, Pullin EM. Da análise de similaridade ao grupo focal: estratégias para estudos na abordagem estrutural das representações sociais. Rev Educ Cult Contemp. 2017;14(37):367-91.) Thus, 26 participants who did not evoke at least two words were excluded, remaining 107 in the similarity analysis. To proceed with the manual calculation of the indices, a table of co-occurrences was set up in Microsoft Excel version 2016 software, proceeding with the similarity index for each pair of words, that is, dividing the number of times in which the pairs of words appeared by the number of participants who evoked at least two words on the board.
During the research operationalization process, the authors complied with the standards and criteria of quality rigor with the guidelines of the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ). The research was approved by the Research Ethics Committee, with protocol number 2 007 080 in 2017 and all its steps followed the recommendations of ethics in research involving human beings.
Results
Most participants were aged between 18 and 35 years old (78.2%); had a low level of education, complete elementary education (63.6%); declared themselves to be black (63.4%); Catholics (65.1%); worked for less than 5 years (68.1%); used condoms during sexual intercourse (67.8%); adopted contraceptive use (66.7%) and were not satisfied with the profession (48.4%). The constitution of values for the composition of the four houses chart (Table 1), identifying the elements possibly participating in the central nucleus and the peripheral elements was extracted from the Rangmot report, issued by the EVOC software. These indicators were: minimum frequency = 11, intermediate frequency > 26 and Average Order of Evocations (AOE) = 3.0. It was found that the inducing expression “quality of life” produced a total of 661 evoked terms, of which 64 were different.
Structural configuration of the social representation of “quality of life”: central and peripheral elements among sex workers (n=133)
The words arranged in the probable central nucleus (Figure 1) meet two criteria, having a higher frequency and being answered promptly. The terms ‘healthy life’, ‘prevention’, ‘money’ and ‘self-love’ that make up the representational symbolic system are highlighted, as they refer to the collective memory of this social group of the concept of quality of life. In the first periphery are the elements with high frequency, but not readily evoked: ‘mental health’, ‘love’, ‘protection’ and ‘care’. They are more flexible, concrete and more accessible. In the lower left quadrant are terms with low frequency, but immediately evoked. This particularity gives an ambiguous character to the contrast zone: ‘happiness’, ‘sadness’, ‘stress’ and ‘prevention’. It is noteworthy that these last three elements are opposed by their negativity to those that make up the probable central nucleus, indicating a minority subgroup among the participants. The less frequent and later evoked terms configure the second periphery (lower right quadrant): ‘family’, ‘comfort’, ‘high self-esteem’, ‘peace’, ‘having friends’, ‘being physically well’ and ‘respect’. These words make an interface between representation and social practices, that is, sex workers represent aspects of quality of life not only aimed at the presence of health, but at a whole healthy social system that they aim for. Evidence on how representational centrality occurs can be deepened through similarity analysis, through the highest degree/strength of connectedness between the elements present in the maximum similarity tree (Figure 1).
Maximum Tree of Similitude with the connection between the evocations about “quality of life” (n=107)
It can be seen in the tree that the expression healthy life is the most important term for understanding representational centrality, as it organizes the other connections and establishes nine connections with other words. The second element highlighted in the tree is the term money, for making three connections and presenting one of the high rates. The healthy life element makes four of the five strongest connections: with mental health (0.165), peace (0.165), protection (0.131) and safety (0.131). This last link with safety deserves to be highlighted, since both terms make up the central nucleus. The fifth strongest connectivity is between money and family (0.102). Therefore, the words healthy life, mental health, peace, protection, safety, money and family tend to be central in the social representation of quality of life, as well as ‘prevention’ and ‘self-love’.
Discussion
The aforementioned results indicate that future studies should consider the relationship between psychological aspects and the assessment of the quality of life of sex workers, as an association with mental health was evidenced in the representational structure. However, as inquiries about psycho-emotional disorders were not present in the data collection script, some interpretations were not deepened, and it constituted a limiting factor of the study.
Analyzing the meanings of quality of life for sex workers will help health professionals such as nurses, to have a broader understanding of health promotion for these women, in addition to the prevention and treatment of STIs, which will ensure advances in planning the care offered, congruent with aspects that enable a good perception of quality of life: support and denunciation of violence suffered on the streets, broad promotion of sexual, reproductive and mental health (such as the detection of stressors), in order to provide humanized care and welcoming, free from stigmas, prejudices and value judgments.
In this perspective, the conditioning of sex workers, considering their socially formed convictions, determines the positive or negative representation of quality of life.(22. Martynowskyj E. Prostituição e feminismo(s). Disputas de reconhecimento nos Encontros Nacionais de Mulheres (Argentina, 1986-2017). Sex Salud Soc. 2018;30:22-49.,1111. Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.,1212. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.) While there are some people who associate it with greater access to health services, others condition mental well-being and/or the attainment of purchasing power.(2222. Foley EE. Regulating sex work: subjectivity and stigma in Senegal. Cult Health Sex. 2017;19(1):50-63.)The mental constructions that shape social representations are unveiled as the practices developed in daily life show the reality that social groups are part of and how much they influence and are influenced by it, in an exchange of experiences, ideas and attitudes among those involved.(1515. Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.,1616. Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.) Thus, women who experience paid sexual service reveal the situations that contribute to the association with quality of life, that is, faced with a multifaceted daily life, there are problems that increase demands and needs.
The conceptual debate on quality of life goes beyond reductionist arguments of association with health, biological dynamics in good compliance or the absence of pathological mechanisms. The indicators that permeate this term are influenced by variables such as education, culture, leisure, life expectancy, biopsychosocial aspects, and above all, the context of individual insertion and its interrelationships.(1212. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.,1313. Carter A, Greene S, Money D, Sanchez M, Webster K, Nicholson V, Brotto LA, Hankins C, Kestler M, Pick N, Salters K, Proulx-Boucher K, O’Brien N, Patterson S, de Pokomandy A, Loutfy M, Kaida A; CHIWOS Research Team. Supporting the Sexual Rights of Women Living With HIV: A Critical Analysis of Sexual Satisfaction and Pleasure Across Five Relationship Types. J Sex Res. 2018;55(9):1134-54.)
In this study, there is evidence of the articulation of a healthy life and self-love in the understanding of quality of life and it is correlated with self-care, respect for one’s intimacy and self-love. A previous study pointed out that despite using their bodies in the occupational environment, they determine which sexual practices are consensual, deciding whether to use condoms during sexual intercourse, as a means of protecting the body and maintaining health.(2323. Couto PL, Gomes AM, Erdmann AL, Brito OO, Nogueira VP, Porcino C, et al. Co-relação entre marcadores de vulnerabilidade social e uso de preservativo por profissionais do sexo. Saude Pesq. 2019;12(3):591-9.)
Self-love was shown to be correlated in another study carried out with sex workers in Belo Horizonte, in which the symbolic idealization of “dirty”, “precarious” women was criticized, as many practiced cares with intimate hygiene, physical appearance. Therefore, it is a way to experience the feeling of emotional and psychic well-being, as they reinforce their self-esteem by taking care of themselves.(2424. França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.) In addition, self-love can be related to subjective aspects of self-esteem, such as respect for feelings and emotions to face the impositions imposed by clients, in the face of gender issues and the power relations that surround this profession.(55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.,66. Medrado AC, De Jesus ML. Ainda assim me levanto 1”: as narrativas históricas e a construção do eu feminino. Estud Pesqui Psicol. 2018;18(4):1348-71.
7. Bertolozzi MR, Nichiata LY, Takahashi RF, Ciosak SI, Hino P, Val LF, et al. The vulnerability and the compliance in collective health. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2009;43(Spe 2):1326-30.
8. Ayres JR, Paiva V, França I Jr, Gravato N, Lacerda R, Della Negra M, et al. Vulnerability, human rights, and comprehensive health care needs of young people living with HIV/AIDS. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(6):1001-6.-99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.)
The socially rooted stigma about the transmission of HIV that is still attributed to these women is unjustified, as they perform protected sexual practices and perform sexual autonomy, although some are (still) subjugated to the acceptance of any and all activities in search of financial ascension.(2323. Couto PL, Gomes AM, Erdmann AL, Brito OO, Nogueira VP, Porcino C, et al. Co-relação entre marcadores de vulnerabilidade social e uso de preservativo por profissionais do sexo. Saude Pesq. 2019;12(3):591-9.,2525. Villela WV, Monteiro S. Gênero, estigma e saúde: reflexões sobre prostituição, aborto e HIV / AIDS entre mulheres. Epidemiol Serv Saúde. 2015;24(3):531-40.) However, other researches consulted do not point to the rupture of this social paradigm in the sphere of the State, also blaming them for the expansion of STIs with HIV-positive stereotypes.(11. Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.,2323. Couto PL, Gomes AM, Erdmann AL, Brito OO, Nogueira VP, Porcino C, et al. Co-relação entre marcadores de vulnerabilidade social e uso de preservativo por profissionais do sexo. Saude Pesq. 2019;12(3):591-9.
24. França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.-2525. Villela WV, Monteiro S. Gênero, estigma e saúde: reflexões sobre prostituição, aborto e HIV / AIDS entre mulheres. Epidemiol Serv Saúde. 2015;24(3):531-40.)
Over time, the social representations have shown in their structure that sex workers have re-signified their demands and the daily life of the profession, since the service is provided with their body and, with it, the (self)care is essential for its functioning.(55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.,99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.) Ensuring a healthy life and taking care of the physical, emotional and spiritual aspects to the fullest means obtaining financial resources.(66. Medrado AC, De Jesus ML. Ainda assim me levanto 1”: as narrativas históricas e a construção do eu feminino. Estud Pesqui Psicol. 2018;18(4):1348-71.,1111. Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.,2626. Caravaca-Morera JA, Padilha MI. Bodies in motion: spaces, emotions and representations that (de)construct realities. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2017;51:e03203.)
The money earned from this occupation subsidizes their and their family’s livelihood, making the acquisition of consumer goods and self-care easier and accessing private health services, corroborated by studies in France(55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.) and in Brazil, which showed that the professionals in charge of the Unified Health System – Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS) do not meet them in a universal, integral and equitable way.(1111. Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.,1212. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.,2626. Caravaca-Morera JA, Padilha MI. Bodies in motion: spaces, emotions and representations that (de)construct realities. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2017;51:e03203.) Previous studies showed that money was represented as synonymous with sexuality (quality of life dimension) because the objective of being in the sex work is the acquisition of income.(99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.,2424. França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.,2727. Thng C, Blackledge E, Mclver R, Watchirs Smith L, McNulty A. Private sex workers’ engagement with sexual health services: an online survey. Sex Health. 2018;15(1):93-5.
28. Karamouzian M, Foroozanfar Z, Ahmadi A, Haghdoost AA, Vogel J, Zolala F. How sex work becomes an option: Experiences of female sex workers in Kerman, Iran. Cult Health Sex. 2016;18(1):58-70.
29. Cruz NL, Ferreira CL, Martins E, Souza M. O cuidado à saúde das profissionais do sexo feminino: uma revisão narrativa. Disciplinarum Sci. 2016;17(3):339-52. Review.-3030. Pasini E. Limites simbólicos corporais na prostituição feminina. Cad Pagu. 2015;14:181-200.)
Women included in paid and consensual sexual services develop a new system of social and decolonial production, as they break with counter-colonial paradigms and desires, since they are at the same time mothers, sisters, neighbors, lovers, wives or girlfriends and ‘’sex professionals’’, to obtain income and independence,(11. Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.,3131. Montes LM, López RQ. Reflexiones sobre los cuerpos negados: mujeres mayas contemporáneas en Tahdziú, México. Sex Salud Soc. 2019;32:40-64.,3232. Olivar JM. Género, dinero y fronteras amazónicas: la “prostitución” en la ciudad transfronteriza de Brasil, Colombia y Perú. Cad Pagu. 2017;(51):e175115.) as presented by an ethnographic study carried out on the Amazon border between Brazil, Colombia and Peru.(3232. Olivar JM. Género, dinero y fronteras amazónicas: la “prostitución” en la ciudad transfronteriza de Brasil, Colombia y Perú. Cad Pagu. 2017;(51):e175115.)
It is confirmed that social representations, as instances of practical knowledge, are constituted in the perception and dialogue about common sense, social and ideational context in which each person is inserted.(1515. Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.,1616. Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.) Thus, the representations of these women are structured as they perform sex work and, even with the demands necessary for survival and subsistence, inhibit access to health services.
The literature points to the systematic advance of the National Policy for Integral Attention to Women’s Health (NPIAWH), which has in its premises the visualization of the feminine beyond the reproductive aspect. The deficit in the practical implementation of this policy enhances the lack of care for sex workers, when they are subjected to prejudice and, when exposed to a corporation, they characterize them as promiscuous and transgressors of social well-being.(2727. Thng C, Blackledge E, Mclver R, Watchirs Smith L, McNulty A. Private sex workers’ engagement with sexual health services: an online survey. Sex Health. 2018;15(1):93-5.,2828. Karamouzian M, Foroozanfar Z, Ahmadi A, Haghdoost AA, Vogel J, Zolala F. How sex work becomes an option: Experiences of female sex workers in Kerman, Iran. Cult Health Sex. 2016;18(1):58-70.)
Although it related positive aspects of quality of life in the representational structure, the findings of this study showed that there is insufficiency in the safety issue. The particularity of being a woman, a sex worker, poor and mostly black (intersectionality that enhance social inequities), makes them feel insecure to carry out their activities, in view of the fear of being raped and judged as guilty.(11. Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.,22. Martynowskyj E. Prostituição e feminismo(s). Disputas de reconhecimento nos Encontros Nacionais de Mulheres (Argentina, 1986-2017). Sex Salud Soc. 2018;30:22-49.,2929. Cruz NL, Ferreira CL, Martins E, Souza M. O cuidado à saúde das profissionais do sexo feminino: uma revisão narrativa. Disciplinarum Sci. 2016;17(3):339-52. Review.)
This condition reflects on the high rate of femicide in Brazil, where the fact of being a woman is enough to ‘justify’ the violent behavior of men, even more so when sex workers fit into the pejorative ideal of the female figure, linked to some overview of the expression of sexuality.(2828. Karamouzian M, Foroozanfar Z, Ahmadi A, Haghdoost AA, Vogel J, Zolala F. How sex work becomes an option: Experiences of female sex workers in Kerman, Iran. Cult Health Sex. 2016;18(1):58-70.,3030. Pasini E. Limites simbólicos corporais na prostituição feminina. Cad Pagu. 2015;14:181-200.) These situations corroborate evidence from a study carried out in Malaysia and another one in Mexico, on the accountability of women in the context of violence,(2121. Donato SP, Ens RT, Favoreto ED, Pullin EM. Da análise de similaridade ao grupo focal: estratégias para estudos na abordagem estrutural das representações sociais. Rev Educ Cult Contemp. 2017;14(37):367-91.,3131. Montes LM, López RQ. Reflexiones sobre los cuerpos negados: mujeres mayas contemporáneas en Tahdziú, México. Sex Salud Soc. 2019;32:40-64.) by the State considering that they violate the behaviors expected for women.(2121. Donato SP, Ens RT, Favoreto ED, Pullin EM. Da análise de similaridade ao grupo focal: estratégias para estudos na abordagem estrutural das representações sociais. Rev Educ Cult Contemp. 2017;14(37):367-91.,3131. Montes LM, López RQ. Reflexiones sobre los cuerpos negados: mujeres mayas contemporáneas en Tahdziú, México. Sex Salud Soc. 2019;32:40-64.,3232. Olivar JM. Género, dinero y fronteras amazónicas: la “prostitución” en la ciudad transfronteriza de Brasil, Colombia y Perú. Cad Pagu. 2017;(51):e175115.)
Furthermore, it is noteworthy that a subgroup of the participants of this study represented the quality of life with a negative connotation, verified in the contrast zone. Even constituting a minority, they verbalized affective-attitudinal words such as sadness, stress, anxiety, having a distant and utopian conception of happiness. This understanding was shown in previous studies to be represented in association with the conditions experienced: physical and psychological abuse and submission to men.(77. Bertolozzi MR, Nichiata LY, Takahashi RF, Ciosak SI, Hino P, Val LF, et al. The vulnerability and the compliance in collective health. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2009;43(Spe 2):1326-30.,2424. França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.,3030. Pasini E. Limites simbólicos corporais na prostituição feminina. Cad Pagu. 2015;14:181-200.,3333. Howard S. Covid-19: Health needs of sex workers are being sidelined, warn agencies. BMJ. 2020;369:m1867.)
Thus, it is suggested that the fact that they are prostituting themselves is due to the impasses experienced in the past and present, such as economic and family issues, difficulties in integrating into the labor market, low education, lack of employment and affective aspects.(55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.,99. Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.
10. Leal CB, Souza DA, Rios MA. Aspectos de vida e saúde das profissionais do sexo. J Nurs UFPE On Line. 2017;11(11):4483-91. Review.
11. Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.
12. Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.
13. Carter A, Greene S, Money D, Sanchez M, Webster K, Nicholson V, Brotto LA, Hankins C, Kestler M, Pick N, Salters K, Proulx-Boucher K, O’Brien N, Patterson S, de Pokomandy A, Loutfy M, Kaida A; CHIWOS Research Team. Supporting the Sexual Rights of Women Living With HIV: A Critical Analysis of Sexual Satisfaction and Pleasure Across Five Relationship Types. J Sex Res. 2018;55(9):1134-54.
14. Marková I. The making of the theory of social representations. Cad Pesq. 2017;47(163):358-75.
15. Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.
16. Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.
17. Wolter RP, SÁ CP. A relação entre representações e práticas: a trilha esquecida. Rev Int Cien Soc Hum. 2013;23(1-2):87-105.
18. Wakiuchi J, Oliveira DC, Marcon SS, Oliveira ML, Sales CA. Meanings and dimensions of cancer by sick people – a structural analysis of social representations. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2020;54:e03504.
19. Vinuto J. A amostragem em bola de neve na pesquisa qualitative: um debate em aberto. Temáticas. 2014;22(44):203-20.
20. Rodrigues AS, Oliveira JF, Suto CS, Coutinho MP, Paiva MS, Souza SS. Care for women involved with drugs: social representations of nurses. Rev Bras Enferm. 2017;70(1):71-8.
21. Donato SP, Ens RT, Favoreto ED, Pullin EM. Da análise de similaridade ao grupo focal: estratégias para estudos na abordagem estrutural das representações sociais. Rev Educ Cult Contemp. 2017;14(37):367-91.
22. Foley EE. Regulating sex work: subjectivity and stigma in Senegal. Cult Health Sex. 2017;19(1):50-63.
23. Couto PL, Gomes AM, Erdmann AL, Brito OO, Nogueira VP, Porcino C, et al. Co-relação entre marcadores de vulnerabilidade social e uso de preservativo por profissionais do sexo. Saude Pesq. 2019;12(3):591-9.
24. França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.
25. Villela WV, Monteiro S. Gênero, estigma e saúde: reflexões sobre prostituição, aborto e HIV / AIDS entre mulheres. Epidemiol Serv Saúde. 2015;24(3):531-40.
26. Caravaca-Morera JA, Padilha MI. Bodies in motion: spaces, emotions and representations that (de)construct realities. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2017;51:e03203.
27. Thng C, Blackledge E, Mclver R, Watchirs Smith L, McNulty A. Private sex workers’ engagement with sexual health services: an online survey. Sex Health. 2018;15(1):93-5.
28. Karamouzian M, Foroozanfar Z, Ahmadi A, Haghdoost AA, Vogel J, Zolala F. How sex work becomes an option: Experiences of female sex workers in Kerman, Iran. Cult Health Sex. 2016;18(1):58-70.
29. Cruz NL, Ferreira CL, Martins E, Souza M. O cuidado à saúde das profissionais do sexo feminino: uma revisão narrativa. Disciplinarum Sci. 2016;17(3):339-52. Review.
30. Pasini E. Limites simbólicos corporais na prostituição feminina. Cad Pagu. 2015;14:181-200.-3131. Montes LM, López RQ. Reflexiones sobre los cuerpos negados: mujeres mayas contemporáneas en Tahdziú, México. Sex Salud Soc. 2019;32:40-64.
32. Olivar JM. Género, dinero y fronteras amazónicas: la “prostitución” en la ciudad transfronteriza de Brasil, Colombia y Perú. Cad Pagu. 2017;(51):e175115.
33. Howard S. Covid-19: Health needs of sex workers are being sidelined, warn agencies. BMJ. 2020;369:m1867.-3434. Mastrocola EL, Taylor AK, Chew-Graham C. Access to healthcare for long-term conditions in women involved in street-based prostitution: a qualitative study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:118.) This issue refers to the lack of opportunities, resulting in a state of extreme poverty and lack of access to basic services, being a preponderant factor for the search for subsistence with sex work(22. Martynowskyj E. Prostituição e feminismo(s). Disputas de reconhecimento nos Encontros Nacionais de Mulheres (Argentina, 1986-2017). Sex Salud Soc. 2018;30:22-49.,33. Silva AP, Santos CR, Carvalho MG. Entre prazeres e sofrimentos: vivências subjetivas de trabalhadoras sexuais em São Paulo. Cad Psicol Social Trab. 2018;21(2):181-95.,55. Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.)demonstrated, also, in an English study, which pointed out the lack of opportunities as barriers faced by sex workers to access health services.(3333. Howard S. Covid-19: Health needs of sex workers are being sidelined, warn agencies. BMJ. 2020;369:m1867.)
Thus, social representations are understood as they are structured in ideas, ideologies, attitudes and behaviors, reflected in the meanings attributed to situations experienced in everyday life.(1515. Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.,1616. Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.) In this context, when apprehending the terms associated with quality of life with sex workers, we can see correlations established with mental health, love, care, suggesting a subjective and positive notion of this representation. As a result of this subjectivity, biopsychosocial support is needed in the care provided by public health services,(3434. Mastrocola EL, Taylor AK, Chew-Graham C. Access to healthcare for long-term conditions in women involved in street-based prostitution: a qualitative study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:118.) as evidenced in studies developed both in the United Kingdom,(3434. Mastrocola EL, Taylor AK, Chew-Graham C. Access to healthcare for long-term conditions in women involved in street-based prostitution: a qualitative study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:118.) and in Brazil(1010. Leal CB, Souza DA, Rios MA. Aspectos de vida e saúde das profissionais do sexo. J Nurs UFPE On Line. 2017;11(11):4483-91. Review.) by pointing out that they do not just want to be seen as women seeking treatment for STIs.(1010. Leal CB, Souza DA, Rios MA. Aspectos de vida e saúde das profissionais do sexo. J Nurs UFPE On Line. 2017;11(11):4483-91. Review.,3434. Mastrocola EL, Taylor AK, Chew-Graham C. Access to healthcare for long-term conditions in women involved in street-based prostitution: a qualitative study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:118.)
Conclusion
The meanings of quality of life, present in the representational structure developed by sex workers, were shown to be related to a positive and conceptual meaning as pointed out by the WHO, based on the assumption of having health to maintain a healthy body and acquiring money to acquire goods and to support them and their family. On the other hand, in the contrast zone, a subgroup was found to have a negative understanding of quality of life, which certainly refers to the problems faced in the daily life of the sexual service.
Referências
-
1Leite GS, Murray L, Lenz F. The Peer and Non-peer: the potential of risk management for HIV prevention in contexts of prostitution. Rev Bras Epidemiol. 2015;18 Suppl 1:7-25. Review.
-
2Martynowskyj E. Prostituição e feminismo(s). Disputas de reconhecimento nos Encontros Nacionais de Mulheres (Argentina, 1986-2017). Sex Salud Soc. 2018;30:22-49.
-
3Silva AP, Santos CR, Carvalho MG. Entre prazeres e sofrimentos: vivências subjetivas de trabalhadoras sexuais em São Paulo. Cad Psicol Social Trab. 2018;21(2):181-95.
-
4Piscitelli A. Sexual economies, love and human trafficking – new conceptual issues. Cad Pagu. 2016;47:e16475.
-
5Broqua C, Combessie P, Deschamps C, Rubio V. La sexualité au cœur des échanges intimes. Jour des Anthropol. 2019;(156-157):21-35.
-
6Medrado AC, De Jesus ML. Ainda assim me levanto 1”: as narrativas históricas e a construção do eu feminino. Estud Pesqui Psicol. 2018;18(4):1348-71.
-
7Bertolozzi MR, Nichiata LY, Takahashi RF, Ciosak SI, Hino P, Val LF, et al. The vulnerability and the compliance in collective health. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2009;43(Spe 2):1326-30.
-
8Ayres JR, Paiva V, França I Jr, Gravato N, Lacerda R, Della Negra M, et al. Vulnerability, human rights, and comprehensive health care needs of young people living with HIV/AIDS. Am J Public Health. 2006;96(6):1001-6.
-
9Couto PL, Montalvão BP, Vieira AR, Vilela AB, Marques SC, Gomes AM, et al. Social representations of female sex workers about their sexuality. Inv Educ Enferm. 2020;38(1):e03.
-
10Leal CB, Souza DA, Rios MA. Aspectos de vida e saúde das profissionais do sexo. J Nurs UFPE On Line. 2017;11(11):4483-91. Review.
-
11Belém JM, Alves MJ, Pereira EV, Maia ER, Quirino GS, Albuquerque GA. Prostituição e saúde: representações sociais de enfermeiras na estratégia saúde da família. Rev Baiana Enferm. 2018;32:e25086.
-
12Domingues JP, Oliveira DC, Marques SC. Quality of life social representations of people living with HIV/AIDS. Texto Contexto Enferm. 2018;27(2):e1460017.
-
13Carter A, Greene S, Money D, Sanchez M, Webster K, Nicholson V, Brotto LA, Hankins C, Kestler M, Pick N, Salters K, Proulx-Boucher K, O’Brien N, Patterson S, de Pokomandy A, Loutfy M, Kaida A; CHIWOS Research Team. Supporting the Sexual Rights of Women Living With HIV: A Critical Analysis of Sexual Satisfaction and Pleasure Across Five Relationship Types. J Sex Res. 2018;55(9):1134-54.
-
14Marková I. The making of the theory of social representations. Cad Pesq. 2017;47(163):358-75.
-
15Moscovici S. Representações sociais: investigações em psicologia social. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes; 2015. 408 p.
-
16Jodelet D. Representações sociais e mundos da vida. Curitiba: Champagnat; 2017. 544 p.
-
17Wolter RP, SÁ CP. A relação entre representações e práticas: a trilha esquecida. Rev Int Cien Soc Hum. 2013;23(1-2):87-105.
-
18Wakiuchi J, Oliveira DC, Marcon SS, Oliveira ML, Sales CA. Meanings and dimensions of cancer by sick people – a structural analysis of social representations. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2020;54:e03504.
-
19Vinuto J. A amostragem em bola de neve na pesquisa qualitative: um debate em aberto. Temáticas. 2014;22(44):203-20.
-
20Rodrigues AS, Oliveira JF, Suto CS, Coutinho MP, Paiva MS, Souza SS. Care for women involved with drugs: social representations of nurses. Rev Bras Enferm. 2017;70(1):71-8.
-
21Donato SP, Ens RT, Favoreto ED, Pullin EM. Da análise de similaridade ao grupo focal: estratégias para estudos na abordagem estrutural das representações sociais. Rev Educ Cult Contemp. 2017;14(37):367-91.
-
22Foley EE. Regulating sex work: subjectivity and stigma in Senegal. Cult Health Sex. 2017;19(1):50-63.
-
23Couto PL, Gomes AM, Erdmann AL, Brito OO, Nogueira VP, Porcino C, et al. Co-relação entre marcadores de vulnerabilidade social e uso de preservativo por profissionais do sexo. Saude Pesq. 2019;12(3):591-9.
-
24França M. Práticas e significados da aprendizagem no trabalho sexual. Horiz Antropol. 2017;23(47):325-49.
-
25Villela WV, Monteiro S. Gênero, estigma e saúde: reflexões sobre prostituição, aborto e HIV / AIDS entre mulheres. Epidemiol Serv Saúde. 2015;24(3):531-40.
-
26Caravaca-Morera JA, Padilha MI. Bodies in motion: spaces, emotions and representations that (de)construct realities. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2017;51:e03203.
-
27Thng C, Blackledge E, Mclver R, Watchirs Smith L, McNulty A. Private sex workers’ engagement with sexual health services: an online survey. Sex Health. 2018;15(1):93-5.
-
28Karamouzian M, Foroozanfar Z, Ahmadi A, Haghdoost AA, Vogel J, Zolala F. How sex work becomes an option: Experiences of female sex workers in Kerman, Iran. Cult Health Sex. 2016;18(1):58-70.
-
29Cruz NL, Ferreira CL, Martins E, Souza M. O cuidado à saúde das profissionais do sexo feminino: uma revisão narrativa. Disciplinarum Sci. 2016;17(3):339-52. Review.
-
30Pasini E. Limites simbólicos corporais na prostituição feminina. Cad Pagu. 2015;14:181-200.
-
31Montes LM, López RQ. Reflexiones sobre los cuerpos negados: mujeres mayas contemporáneas en Tahdziú, México. Sex Salud Soc. 2019;32:40-64.
-
32Olivar JM. Género, dinero y fronteras amazónicas: la “prostitución” en la ciudad transfronteriza de Brasil, Colombia y Perú. Cad Pagu. 2017;(51):e175115.
-
33Howard S. Covid-19: Health needs of sex workers are being sidelined, warn agencies. BMJ. 2020;369:m1867.
-
34Mastrocola EL, Taylor AK, Chew-Graham C. Access to healthcare for long-term conditions in women involved in street-based prostitution: a qualitative study. BMC Fam Pract. 2015;16:118.
Edited by
Publication Dates
-
Publication in this collection
29 Aug 2022 -
Date of issue
2022
History
-
Received
27 Apr 2021 -
Accepted
7 Dec 2021