Peters et al. (2003)23
|
three-rooted maxillary molars |
IA based on CV |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 (MB/DB) |
30/.09 (P) |
Hubscher et al., (2003)24
|
maxillary molars |
IA based on CV |
FlexMaster |
45/.02 |
Peru et al., (2006)80
|
mandibular molar - mesial root |
EA (RL, CD) and IA |
ProTaper Universal |
20/.07 |
System GT |
20/.06 |
Loizides et al., (2007)81
|
mandibular 1st molar - mesial root |
IA (PR) |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Hero |
30/.06 |
Cheung et al., (2008)82
|
mandibular 2nd molar |
IA (CS) |
ProFile |
25/.06 |
Hero |
30/.06 |
Gekelman et al., (2009)68
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
EA (RS and CD) |
GT Rotary Files |
No mention |
ProTaper Universal |
Peters et al., (2010)83
|
maxillary incisors |
IA and SD (CV and CG based on µCT) |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
2.0 mm |
Metzger et al., (2010)2
|
mandibular molars, premolars, incisors and canines |
Pair selection based on 3D models of IA and EA features |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Self-Adjusting File |
No mention |
Peters et al., (2011)84
|
maxillary molars |
IA (µCT) |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
Paqué et al., (2011)87
|
mandibular molars - distal root |
IA (CS) based on µCT |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
Versiani et al., (2011)85
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (CS) and CD based on PR |
K3 |
40/.02 |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
You et al., (2011)86
|
maxillary molars - MB e DB canals |
CD (Schneider, 1971) |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
Paqué et al., (2011)31
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
Yang et al., (2011)88
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA (CS) and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Mtwo |
30/.05 |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Freire et al., (2011)89
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR (Pruett, 1997) |
Twisted File |
30/.06 |
EndoSequence |
Moura-Netto et al., (2012)107
|
mandibular premolars |
EA |
EndoEZE AET |
30/.06 |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Freire et al., (2012)106
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR (Pruett, 1997) |
Twisted File |
30/.06 |
EndoSequence |
Stern et al., (2012)7
|
mandibular 1st and 2nd molars - mesial root |
EA (RS), IA (CS on PR) and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
Twisted File |
Yamamura et al., (2012)90
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA and CD (Pruett, 1997) |
Vortex |
40/.04 |
EndoSequence |
Kim et al., (2013)92
|
maxillary molars - MB and DB canals |
CD (Schneider, 1971) |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
Zhao et al., (2013)93
|
maxillary 1st molar |
IA (CS), CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR (Pruett, 1997) |
Twisted File |
30/.06 |
Hyflex CM |
K3 |
Versiani et al., (2013)33
|
mandibular canine |
IA (CS on PR) and SD based on µCT |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
WaveOne |
40/.08 |
Reciproc |
40/.06 |
ProTaper Universal |
40/.06 |
McRay et al., (2014)39
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA (CS on µCT) and CD (PR and µCT – Pruett, 1997) |
WaveOne |
25/.08 |
ProTaper Universal |
Ceyhanli et al., (2014)94
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
CD and CR (Pruett, 1997) and IA based on PR |
RaCe |
30/.04 |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Safesider |
30/.04 |
Junaid et al., (2014)38
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Twisted File |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
Hwang et al., (2014)9
|
maxillary molars |
IA based on µCT and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Reciproc |
25/.08 |
Mtwo |
25/.07 |
Al-Sudani et al., (2014)95
|
maxillary 1st premolars |
CD (Schneider, 1971) |
ProFile Vortex |
30/.06 |
Revo-S |
Gergi et al., (2014)37
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Reciproc |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
Twisted File Adaptive |
Sant'Anna Júnior et al., (2014)40
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Mtwo |
40/.04 |
Reciproc |
40/.06 |
Zhao et al., (2014)41
|
mandibular 1st molars - all roots |
IA and SD based on µCT |
WaveOne |
25/.08 (M)/40/.08 (D) |
CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 (M)/40/.06 (D) |
|
ProTaper Next |
25/.06 (M)/40/.06 (D) |
Almeida et al., (2015)96
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
CD |
K3 |
30/.04 |
K3XF |
Gergi et al., (2015)44
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Reciproc |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
Twisted File Adaptive |
Busquim et al., (2015)42
|
mandibular molars - distal root |
IA and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR |
Reciproc |
40/.06 |
BioRace |
40/.04 |
Marceliano-Alves et al., (2015)45
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Reciproc |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
Twisted File |
HyFlex CM |
Ahmetoglu et al., (2015)34
|
maxillary 1st molars |
CD (Schneider, 1971) |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm (MB/DB)/2 mm (P) |
Reciproc |
25/.08 (MB/DB)/40/.06 (P) |
Revo-S |
25/.06 (MB/DB)/ 40/.06 (P) |
Peters et al., (2015)97
|
mandibular molar - mesial root |
IA (CV), SD and CD based on µCT |
Vortex |
30/.06 |
TRUShape |
Pasqualini et al., (2015)98
|
maxillary 1st molar |
IA, CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR |
ProGlider/ProTaper Next |
25/.06 |
ScoutRace/Bio-Race |
Gagliardi et al., (2015)27
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA, SD and CD based on µCT and PR |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
ProTaper Next |
25/.06 |
ProTaper Gold |
25/.08 |
De-Deus et al., (2015)43
|
mandibular molar - mesial root |
IA (CV), SD and CD based on µCT and PR |
Reciproc |
40/.06 |
WaveOne |
40/.08 |
BioRace |
40/.04 |
Coelho et al., (2016)11
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (CS) |
WaveOne |
25/.08 |
Easy ProDesign Logic |
25/.06 |
OneShape |
25/.06 |
Pedullà et al., (2016)47
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA, SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR |
Twisted File Adaptive |
25/.06 |
Mtwo |
Yang et al., (2016)12
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on µCT and PR |
WaveOne |
25/.08 |
Santa-Rosa et al., (2016)99
|
maxillary molars |
IA (CS and CV), CD and CR (Schneider, 1971) |
WaveOne |
25/.08 |
OneShape |
25/.06 |
Jardine et al., (2016)13
|
maxillary molars |
SD, CD and CR (Schneider, 1971) |
Wizard Navigator |
25/.08 |
WaveOne |
25/.06 |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
Vallaeys et al., (2016)100
|
mandibular 1st molar - mesial root |
IA (CS), CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR (Pruett, 1997) |
Mtwo |
30/.05 |
ProTaper Universal |
30/.09 |
Revo-S |
30/.06 |
Da Silva Limoeiro et al., (2016)101
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
CD (Schneider, 1971) |
ProTaper Next |
25/.06 |
BioRace |
Lopes et al., (2017)57
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA (CS based on µCT) and CD (Schneider, 1971 based on PR) |
ProTaper Next |
25/.06 |
Twisted File Adaptive |
Venino et al., (2017)103
|
all teeth |
IA and EA |
Hyflex EDM |
No mention |
ProTaper Next |
Arias et al., (2017)102
|
mandibular molars - distal root |
IA and EA (CS, RS and RL) |
Vortex |
30/.06 |
TRUShape |
Guimarães et al., (2017)4
|
contralateral single-rooted mandibular premolars |
IA (CS based on PR and µCT) |
TRUShape |
40/.06 |
Reciproc |
Azim et al., (2017)62
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (AD, CS, CV, RL) and SD based on PR, CBCT and µCT |
Vortex Blue |
30/.04 |
XP-endo Shaper |
30/.01 |
Serefoglu et al., (2017)105
|
mandibular 1st molar - mesial root |
IA (AD, CS and CV), SD, CD (Schneider, 1971) and CR (Pruett, 1997) based on PR and µCT |
ProTaper Universal |
40/.06 |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
Silva et al., (2017)58
|
mandibular 1st and 2nd molars- mesial root |
IA (CS based on µCT), SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR |
ProTaper Next |
25/.06 |
Twisted File Adaptive |
Elnaghy et al., (2017)59
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA (AD and CS), SD and CD |
TRUShape |
25/.06 |
ProTaper Next |
Brasil et al., (2017)14
|
mandibular 1st molars - mesial root |
IA (CS, CV and CG), SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR and µCT |
ProTaper Next |
30/.07 |
BT-Race |
35/.04 |
Duque et al., (2017)104
|
mandibular molars - mesial root |
IA (CS) and CD based on µCT |
ProTaper Universal |
25/.08 |
ProTaper Gold |
30/.09 |
Lacerda et al., (2017)29
|
mandibular molars - distal root |
IA (CS) based on RP and CD (Schneider, 1971) and SD based on µCT |
Self-Adjusting File |
2 mm |
TRUShape |
30/.06 |
XP-endo Shaper |
30/.01 |
Versiani et al., (2018)63
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (CS) and SD based on µCT |
XP-endo Shaper |
30/.01 |
iRace |
30/.04 |
EdgeFile |
30/.04 |
Espir et al., (2018)15
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (CS) based on RP and SD based on µCT |
Reciproc |
40/.06 |
Mtwo |
Zuolo et al., (2018)30
|
mandibular incisors |
IA (CV, CG, RL, CS and AD), SD and CD (Schneider, 1971) based on PR and µCT |
BioRace |
25/.06 |
Reciproc |
25/.08 |
Self-Adjusting File |
1.5 mm |
TRUShape |
25/.06 |