Open-access Computational analysis of stress concentration in steel plates with holes: Systematic determination of the stress concentration factor

Abstract

The concentrations of stress and strain along the edges caused by the presence of geometric discontinuities in solids, such as circular, elliptical, and square shapes, have attracted the attention of the scientific community for more than a century due to their wide applicability in engineering. In this context, this research conducts a computational simulation using COMSOL Multiphysics software based on the Finite Element Method (FEM), performing a parametric study varying the dimensions of a perforated plate with a circular hole in seventy-two combinations. The plate has a constant thickness, and the combinations were obtained by varying the width (L), length (a), hole position, and radius (⌀). For a better analysis, the seventy-two combinations were divided into two groups of thirty-six, in which the influence of width (L) variation on the stress concentration factor (k) was evaluated. The results show that varying the plate width from 0.3a to 0.7a does not significantly affect the values of k. Finally, among the analyzed combinations and for the established parameters, the stress-strain curves demonstrated that the regions near the hole edge enter the plastic zone more rapidly, emphasizing the importance of analyzing strain distribution and stress concentration in structural design.

Keywords:
Stress concentration; Strain distribution; Finite element method (FEM); Perforated plate; Computational simulation

INTRODUCTION

Understanding the behavior of materials under different conditions has always driven humanity toward significant advances in the field of engineering. Thus, analyzing the performance of materials subjected to specific loading conditions is essential for the development of aircraft, structures, vehicles, and other applications. According to Callister 1, it is fundamental to understand the characteristics of a material and to design the component in such a way that any resulting deformation is not excessive and does not lead to fracture. In this context, the mechanical behavior of a material reflects the relationship between its response or deformation and the applied load or force.

Hooke’s Law describes the behavior of materials exhibiting a linear relationship between stress and strain within their elastic regime. This linearity remains valid only up to the so-called proportional limit. As Beer et al. 2 note, many structural materials, such as steels - despite their differences in strength and ductility - demonstrate similar elastic moduli, indicating comparable behavior within the linear zone. However, when stress exceeds this limit, the material begins to exhibit nonlinear behavior, including plastic deformation.

In structures with geometric discontinuities, such as plates with holes, stresses are not uniformly distributed, leading to regions of stress concentration. In such cases, even when the global load is small, the local stress at the hole’s edge may exceed the proportional limit, resulting in localized nonlinear behavior. Kirsch 3 pioneered the study of the influence of circular discontinuities on the stress state in an elastic plane subjected to uniaxial tension, providing fundamental insights into this phenomenon.

Experimental, analytical, and computational methods have been progressively refined and applied to validate stress state variations in plates due to the presence of holes. Experimentally, Durelli et al.4)-(5 evaluated the influence of circular and elliptical holes in two-dimensional systems using photoelasticity techniques (i.e., a method that exploits stress-induced birefringence in transparent materials). The authors concluded that stresses around discontinuities, such as holes, are not uniformly distributed, leading to stress concentrations that may exceed the material’s strength limits.

Murphy 7 explains that birefringence causes polarized light to split into two orthogonal components that propagate at different velocities within the material. Upon emerging, these waves exhibit a relative phase shift, generating colored fringes known as isochromatic fringes. The quantity and intensity of these fringes are directly related to the applied mechanical stress. At rest, the photoelastic material remains dark; as the load increases, fringes emerge from the regions of highest stress. Each fringe represents a constant level of birefringence. This behavior can be observed in Figure 1.

Figure 1:
Stress concentration visualization in a plate with a circular hole under uniaxial tension.

The analytical formulations derived by Timoshenko and Goodier 9 regarding the effect of circular holes on stress distribution in plates establish that, given a plate subjected to uniform tension of magnitude S in the x-direction (Figure 2), the introduction of a small circular hole at the plate’s center alters the stress distribution in the hole’s vicinity. Furthermore, based on Saint-Venant’s principle 10, this variation becomes negligible at distances large compared to the hole radius a and thus, for the configuration shown in Figure 2, the stress components σr, σθ and τr can be obtained from Equations A, B and C

σ r = 1 r · ∂ φ ∂ r + 1 r 2 ∂ 2 φ ∂ θ 2 = - 2 A + 6 C r 4 + 4 D r 2 cos θ (A)

σ θ = ∂ 2 ∅ ∂ r 2 = 2 A + 12 B r 2 + 6 C r 4 cos 2 θ (B)

τ r θ = ∂ ∂ r 1 r ∂ ∅ ∂ θ = 2 A + 6 B r 2 - 6 C r 4 - 6 D r 2 s e n 2 θ (C)

Figure 2:
Plate subjected to uniform tension of magnitude S in the x-direction.

The integrtion constants must now be determined through boundary conditions:

  1. At the plate’s outer edge,

  2. The requirement that the hole’s edge remains free of external forces.

The integration constants are determined from the boundary conditions listed above. Assuming ab≈0 (i.e., n infinitely large plate), the following values are obtained: A=-S4; B=0; C=-a44S; D=a22S, Substituting these constants into Equations A and C, superimposing the stresses produced by the uniform tension applied at the outer boundary lead to Equations D and E.

σ r = S 2 · 1 - a 2 r 2 + S 2 1 + 3 a 4 r 4 - 4 a 4 r 2 cos 2 θ (D)

σ θ = S 2 · 1 - a 2 r 2 - S 2 1 + 3 a 4 r 4 cos 2 θ (E)

τ r θ = - S 2 1 - 3 a 4 r 4 + 2 a 2 r 4 s e n 2 θ (F)

Altan and Kartal 11 investigated the variation of buckling coefficients (i.e., structural instability) in symmetrically laminated reinforced concrete plates containing a central rectangular hole under biaxial static compression. The finite element method (FEM) was employed to simulate the structural behavior. The analyzed plates were composite structures composed of varying numbers of steel and concrete laminas, with configurations including 4, 6, 8, and 10 layers.

The study aimed to assess the influence of the hole’s size and orientation on the buckling response. The results support the understanding that, regardless of geometry, structural discontinuities such as circular, elliptical, or rectangular holes lead to stress concentrations along their edges, which in turn amplify deformation and accelerate the buckling process. The plate is defined in Cartesian coordinates x, y, and z, with the x- and y-axes lying on the mid-surface of the plate. It is subjected to biaxial compressive forces N1 and N2 in the x- and y-directions, respectively, as illustrated in Figures 3a and 3b.

Figure 3:
(a) Geometry of a plate with a central rectangular hole subjected to biaxial loadings N1 and N2 (b) Composite structure with symmetric laminated reinforcement comprising multiple layers of distinct materials.

Khechai et al. 12 investigated stress concentration factors in isotropic and laminated composite plates with central circular holes under uniaxial loading. The study employed a 4-node quadrilateral finite element with 32 degrees of freedom per node, based on classical plate theory, combining isoparametric membrane elements and Hermitian elements (i.e., interpolation functions derived from Hermite polynomials). Numerical results showed agreement with analytical data from the literature, validating the model’s accuracy. Additionally, different failure criteria were applied to predict first-ply failure, while analyzing the influence of each plate’s elastic modulus ratio as a function of fiber orientations.

The Finite Element Method (FEM) is widely used to solve problems involving partial differential equations, particularly those with complex geometries, varied loading conditions, and linear or nonlinear structural behaviors in multiple dimensions 13. Despite its versatility, FEM has significant limitations, such as the need to discretize the entire domain, which demands greater computational effort, especially in critical regions like holes and cracks 14.

Furthermore, the method proves less effective for field derivatives and becomes impractical for high-order differential equations, as encountered in plates and shells. In contrast, the Boundary Element Method (BEM) emerges as an efficient and accurate alternative, since it requires only boundary discretization, making it advantageous for problems involving infinite domains and irregular geometries 14.

Another relevant distinction concerns the theories applied to plate bending. Kirchhoff’s theory, or classical plate theory, neglects transverse shear deformations and is only suitable for thin plates with small displacements. In contrast, Reissner’s theory incorporates shear effects, providing greater accuracy in edge regions or near geometric discontinuities such as holes with diameters comparable to the plate thickness 15. This distinction directly influences the choice of numerical model and solution method for structural simulations. Table I summarizes the key characteristics of each approach.Yang et al. 17 investigated the elastic stress and strain fields in finite-thickness plates containing a circular hole using the three-dimensional FEM. The authors observed that, even under elastic conditions, the distributions of stress and strain vary with plate thickness, and the peaks of concentration do not necessarily occur on the mid-plane - a behavior observed only in thin plates. In thick plates, the locations of maximum stress and strain shift significantly.

Table I
Comparative Analysis: Finite Element Method (FEM) vs. Boundary Element Method (BEM). Adapted 16.

Furthermore, the authors found that the stress and strain concentration factors around the hole increase to a peak value and then gradually decrease with increasing plate thickness, tending toward a constant value related to Poisson’s ratio. It was concluded that the greater the plate thickness or the Poisson’s ratio, the larger the difference between the maximum stress in the critical region and the corresponding value observed on the surface.

Table II summarizes the main parameters applied in the reference simulations, which served as a comparative basis for the results obtained in this study.

Table II
Summary of geometrical parameters and material properties used by the authors 17.

The study considers a large plate with finite thickness, containing a central circular hole and subjected to uniaxial tensile loading. The geometry of the plate is defined by the dimensions 2B, 2H and 2W, corresponding to the total thickness, height, and width, respectively, while the hole radius is represented by a. The plate material is homogeneous, isotropic, and exhibits elastic behavior.

The mid-plane of the plate is located at z = 0, while its external surfaces are positioned at z = B and z = -B. For analysis purposes, the z-axis, corresponding to the plate thickness, is referred to as the notch root line. The analyses were carried out based on the behavior of the stress and strain fields along these dimensions, considering the variations induced by the presence of the hole and the plate thickness, as illustrated in Figure 4.

Figure 4:
Model established by the authors 17.

Furthermore, it is evident that experimental and numerical approaches aimed at understanding stress state analysis in solids with discontinuities-such as circular, elliptical, and rectangular ones-have achieved significant advances over time. In this context, the study analyzes seventy-two combinations and conducts a parametric investigation into the influence of geometric variations in plates with constant thickness.

The objective is to determine the stress concentration coefficient as the hole radius varies proportionally in relation to the plate’s width and length. Furthermore, the study presents stress-strain graphs for selected cases in order to highlight the degree of deformation amplification in the regions where the highest stress concentrations occur, compared to the in-plane deformations under applied loading. These findings reinforce the need for more rigorous technical monitoring of structures with discontinuities, due to the localized intensification of stresses and deformations near the hole edges.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The method addressed in this research is based on a parametric study of the systematic influence of holes applied to a steel plate. The goal is to determine the stress concentration values at the edges of the holes, using the elastic parameters presented in Table III. The parametric analysis was conducted through seventy-two simulations, varying geometric dimensions such as plate width, length, and hole radius. In addition to the elastic behavior, the material’s plastic response was modeled using the Voce isotropic hardening model, which describes the transition from elastic behavior to maximum stress capacity. For this purpose, two additional parameters were defined: the saturation flow stress σsat and the saturation exponent (β), which govern the rate and extent of hardening beyond the initial yield stress σys, according to Equation G.

σ y s = σ y s 0 + σ s a t 1 - e - β e p ε (G)

the geometric dimensions adopted for each edge of the plate, which comprise the set of analyzed combinations, are presented in Table IV.

Table III
Elastic properties of the adopted steel.

Table IV
Criteria adopted in the plate simulation.

Thus, the seventy-two simulations were organized into two groups of thirty-six, with the plate width fixed within each group, in order to determine the values of the stress concentration factor (k), as illustrated in the flowchart in Figure 5.

Figure 5:
Representation of the dimensions and the hole position relative to the plate, corresponding to the seventy-two simulated combinations based on the fixed widths of 0.3·a or 0.7·a (Authors).

Due to the large number of combinations, Table V was created to specify the types of cases analyzed, according to the combinations simulated in the software. In this nomenclature, A1 represents the width of 0.3·a and A2 the width of 0.7·a; B1, B2, and B3 refer to the hole positions at 0.4·a, 0.5·a, and 0.7·a, respectively.

Table V
Number of simulated cases as a function of plate width and hole position.

The simulated plate was subjected to a 100 KN load applied to its cross-section, and its opposite face was clamped as a boundary condition, as illustrated in Figure 6.

Figure 6:
Illustration of the applied loading and boundary conditions of the simulated plate (Authors).

The calibration performed in COMSOL to obtain the (k) values was based on the development of a 3D geometry linked to the Solid Mechanics interface, which is responsible for 2D, 3D, and axisymmetric structural analyses, focusing on displacements, stresses, and strains. This interface can be combined with additional modules to address nonlinearities, contact phenomena, and advanced effects. It also supports materials with plastic, hyperelastic, viscoplastic, and concrete behavior.

Furthermore, the present study, situated within the field of solid mechanics, considers a steady-state behavior (i.e., with no time variation of the variables). This approach is suitable for static or steady-state analyses. The formulation used by the software is based on the equilibrium of forces, which describes the balance between internal stresses and body forces applied to the system, as expressed in Equation H:

∇ σ + F v = 0 (H)

where:

𝛻σ = divergence of the stress tensor;

Fv = body force.

The material behavior is described by the constitutive law that relates the elastic stresses (σel), the corresponding strains(εel), and the elasticity tensor (C). This relationship depends on the material properties, represented by the Young’s modulus and the Poisson’s ratio, as expressed in Equation I:

σ e l = C : ε e l , C = f E , υ (I)

The strains are calculated from the displacement fields, following the linear kinematic relation. The total strain tensor (ε) is decomposed into elastic and inelastic components for materials with complex behavior, as a function of the displacement vector (u), according to Equation J:

ε = 1 2 ∇ u + ∇ u T , ε e l = ε - ε e l (J)

For the discretization of the plate with a central hole, a hybrid meshing approach was adopted. In the region of geometric discontinuity, corresponding to the hole, a refined mesh composed of tetrahedral elements was employed to properly capture the high stress gradients in this region. In the continuous regions of the plate, a structured mesh of hexahedral elements was used, with predominantly rectangular geometry aligned with the planes of the three-dimensional plate.

The tetrahedral elements employed in the region surrounding the hole provide greater geometric flexibility, allowing an accurate representation of the curvature and local complexity of the discontinuity. These elements, typically composed of four nodes (linear elements) or ten nodes (quadratic elements), provide sufficient degrees of freedom to capture the high strain gradients and stress concentrations in this critical region.

In contrast, the hexahedral elements used in the continuous regions of the plate offer better numerical performance and higher accuracy per degree of freedom, and are generally composed of eight nodes (linear elements) or twenty nodes (quadratic elements). This combination reduces the overall computational cost of the simulation while maintaining high accuracy in the region of interest and greater efficiency in regions with more uniform structural behavior Figures 7a and 7b.

Figure 7:
Hybrid mesh discretization applied to cases (A2-B2) (a) and (A1-B2) (b).

The adopted configuration also enabled a statistical evaluation of mesh quality, with values ranging from 0.6636 (minimum) to 0.9646 (average), indicating a numerically stable mesh suitable for stress concentration analysis in geometrically discontinuous regions. Each of the 72 simulated configurations comprised more than 25.000 elements, providing sufficient resolution for capturing localized stress gradients. Figures 8a and 8b illustrate the mesh refinement gradient and its transition near the hole, corresponding to the geometric scenarios presented in previous figures.

Figure 8:
Mesh quality Distribution applied to the simulated geometries: (a) example simulated for a plate with width 0.7·a; (b) plate with width 0.3·a.

In addition, Figure 9 presents the flowchart with the methodological steps required for conducting the numerical simulations using the COMSOL standard.

Figure 9:
Flowchart for performing the simulations (Authors).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The obtained k values, corresponding to the seventy-two simulated combinations of the plate under compressive loading conditions, are organized according to the specification of points near the circular hole along the length of the plate, as presented in Tables 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12.

Table VI
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for case 1 (A1-B1).

Table VII
Coordinates of the point located near the edge of the hole for plate center cases A1, for a plate with the hole centered with respect to the x, y, and z axes, respectively.

Table VIII
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for Case 2 (A1-B2).

Table IX
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for Case 3 (A1-B3).

Table X
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for Case 4 (A2-B1).

Table XI:
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for Case 5 (A2-B2).

Table XII:
Geometric dimensions, cross-sectional area, maximum and average stresses, and stress concentration factor for Case 6 (A2-B2).

3.1 Evaluation of the effects of hole position: Cases 1-3

Tables VI, VII, and VIII characterize the first thirty-six simulations, performed with the fixed width A1, as shown in the flowchart in Figure 9. It is important to note that the value of the stress concentration factor in a discontinuity is defined by the ratio between the maximum normal stress (σmax), and the average normal stress (σavg) calculated at the critical section, both expressed in MPa.

The coordinates for adding the study point used to obtain (σavg) are specified in Table VII.

Furthermore, Figures 10a and 10b present the three-dimensional modeling of the plate with the insertion of the study point for case 1 (A1-B2), considering a length of 2 meters, a hole radius equal to 0.4·L, and the representation of the stress concentration at the edge of the circular hole. The coordinates of the other cases follow the same pattern, always considering the point located at the mid-thickness (0.025 m), with the longitudinal coordinate positioned proportionally to the center of the bar according to the hole position, and the transverse coordinate varying as a function of the hole radius.

Figure 10:
Three-dimensional modeling of the plate with a central hole for Case 1 (A1-B1): (a) Geometry with the insertion of the study point (red sphere); (b) Von Mises stress distribution (MPa) indicating stress concentration at the edge of the hole.

Tables VIII and IX provide the data related to cases 2 and 3, in which the stress variations are analyzed with the hole offset from the center, positioned respectively at 0.4·a and 0.6·a.

Figures 11a, 11b, and 11c present the graphs generated from the simulated data, which illustrate the behavior of the first thirty-six combinations analyzed provided the values of the coefficients ki it is observed that there is a consistency in the results when the configurations share the same hole radius (0.1∙L, 0.25∙L, 0.4·L), the same plate length (a), and the same plate width (0.3·a), while keeping the plate thickness (e) constant. Based on these findings, it can be concluded that the hole position along the three established lengths does not result in significant variations in the stress concentration factor.

Figure 11:
(a) Variation of ki as a function of the ⌀/L for Case 1 [A1-B1]; (b) Case 2 [A1-B2]; (c) Case 3 [A1-B3]. The different markers represent the plate lengths: 0.50 - 2.00 m.

This trend is visually confirmed in Figure 11, where the graphs for Cases 1, 2, and 3 display similar curve behaviors and very close values, even as the hole position changes along the length of the plate. The visual overlap of the curves reinforces the conclusion that the longitudinal position of the hole has a negligible effect on the ki factor when the other parameters are held constant.

In the subsequent cases, where the plate width is increased to 0.7·a , a similar behavior tends to be observed, as illustrated in Figures 14a, 14b, and 14c. This supports the conclusion that even the enlargement of the plate width does not significantly affect the stress concentration factor, further consolidating the understanding that the most influential parameter on the variation of ki remains the ratio between the hole radius and the main dimensions of the plate.

Figure 12:
Von Misses stress distribution around the circular hole for Case 2 (A1-B2), considering radius-to-width ratios of 0.1 (a), 0.25 (b), and 0.4 (c).

Figure 13:
Three-dimensional modeling of the plate with a central hole for Case 2 (A2-B2): (a) Geometry with the insertion of the study point (red sphere); (b) Von Mises stress distribution (MPa) indicating stress concentration at the edge of the hole.

Figure 14:
(a) Variation of ki as a function of the ⌀/L ratio for Case 4 [A2-B1]; (b) Case 5 [A2-B2]; (c) Case 6 [A2-B3].

Finally, Figures 12a, 12b, and 11c present the stress distributions around the circular hole for Case 2 (A1-B2), considering radius-to-width ratios of 0.1, 0.25, and 0.4, respectively. A gradual increase in normal stress is observed as the radius -to-width ratio increases. In Figure 12a, the maximum average normal stress reaches approximately 10.5 MPa, while in Figures 12b and 12c, this value rises to around 14.4 MPa and 34.6 MPa, respectively.

3.2 Evaluation of the effects of hole position: Cases 4-6

Tables X, XI, and XII characterize the last thirty-six simulations, performed with the width fixed at 0.7·a, as presented in Figure 4. Table X presents the results for Case 4 (A2-B1).

Figures 13a and 13b present the three-dimensional modeling of the plate with the insertion of the study point for Case 1 (A2-B2), considering a length of 2 meters, a hole radius equal to 0.4·L, and the representation of the stress concentration at the edge of the circular hole.

Tables XI and XII provide the data related to Cases 5 and 6.

Figures 14a, 14b, and 14c illustrate the graphs generated from the simulated data, which show the behavior of the stress concentration factor ki as a function of the ratio between the hole radius and the plate width (⌀/L) for each tabulated case.

Furthermore, Figures 15a, 15b, and 15c show the stress distributions around the circular hole for Case 5 (A2-B2), considering radius-to-width ratios of 0.1, 0.25, and 0.4, respectively. The pattern of gradual increase in normal stress as the radius-to-width ratio increases is maintained. In Figure 15a, the maximum average normal stress reaches approximately 4.54 MPa, while in Figures 15b and 15c, this value increases to around 6.44 MPa and 15.6 MPa, respectively.

Yang et al. 17 define the stress and strain concentration factors as kσ and kε, respectively, as expressed in Equations K and L. These quantities represent the ratio between the local stress σyy and the net section stress σnet, as well as between the local strain εyy and the net section strain εnet. The specific values at the edge of the hole, at the point x=y=o, are denoted as kσ0 and kε0.

K σ = σ y y / σ n e t K σ 0 = σ y y / σ n e t a t x = y = 0 (K)

Figure 15:
Normal stress distribution around the circular hole for Case 2 (A1-B2), considering radius-to-width ratios of 0.1 (a), 0.25 (b), and 0.4 (c)

The strain concentration factor kε:

K ε = ε y y / ε n e t K ε 0 = ε y y / ε n e x = y = 0 (L)

To describe the three-dimensional stress field behavior near the notch root, the authors introduce two auxiliary parameters: the out-of-plane stress constraint factor Tz and the in-plane stress factor Tx, defined in Equations M and N, respectively. The parameter Tz represents the ratio between the out-of-plane stress σzz and the sum of the in-plane stresses σxx + σyy, being used to characterize the plane stress state (Tz=0) and the plane strain state (Tz=ν). Meanwhile, Tx, expresses the ratio between longitudinal and transverse in-plane stresses, that is, σxx. These two parameters help characterize the transition between two-dimensional and three-dimensional stress states as the plate thickness varies.

T z = σ z z σ x x + σ y y (M)

T x = σ x x σ y y (N)

σ x x = K σ 0 · σ y 3 1 + x a - 2 · 1 - 1 + x a - 2 (O)

σ y y = K σ 0 · σ y 3 1 + 1 2 1 + x a - 2 + 3 2 1 + x a - 4 (P)

To corroborate the results obtained and discussed in this work, validation was carried out based on the study by the authors 17, specifically regarding the in-plane stress factor Tx as the ratio x/a tends to x =2·a. Thus, the finite element method, together with the adopted mesh discretization, proved to be consistent with the mesh employed by those authors and with the analytical Equations O and P developed by Timoshenko and Goodier 9, as illustrated in Figures 16a, 16b, 16c and 16d.

Figure 16:
Validations for the cases B/a = 4 and B/a = 1 from Yang et al. 17. Validation for B/a=4 is shown in (a), and validation for B/a=1 is shown in (d).

3.4 Increase of strains around the circular discontinuity.

Considering the elastic parameters and the plastic behavior values presented in Table III, this final section briefly discusses two cases out of the seventy-two simulations, highlighting the trend of strain amplification in the vicinity of the circular discontinuity, now under a stress of 140 MPa. The simulation was performed as a stationary analysis over a total time of 1 second, starting from zero and progressing in increments of 0.05 s to ensure greater accuracy in the results.

The strains analyzed are located along the y-axis, which allows a more precise evaluation of the deformation behavior in this direction. This outcome corroborates the behavior reported by Yang et al. 17, regarding the need for special attention in structures with such characteristics, since these regions rapidly enter the plastic regime due to stress accumulation.

Table XIII presents the simulated cases and the coordinates used to measure the strain in the plane.

Table XIII
Simulated cases and coordinates of Point-1and Point-2 used for strain measurements in the plate.

Figure 17a and 17b show Points 1 and 2 for case A2-B2, considering a circular hole radius of 0.25∙L.

Figure 17:
Location of the reference points considered for strain evaluation: (a) Point 1, positioned along the edge of the circular hole, and (b) Point 2, positioned on the plate surface away from the discontinuity.

The stress-strain curves illustrate the behavior at Point 1 in comparison with Point 2 (Figures 18a and 18b). It can be observed that, for the same stress applied to the solid surface, Point 1 deforms more rapidly, leaving the elastic region and entering the plastic region.

Figure 18:
Stress-strain curves for case [A2-B2]: (a) hole radius of 0.1L and (b) hole radius of 0.25L.

Figure 19 illustrates, through successive frames, the accumulation of strain in the plate as the applied stress increases, reaching its peak at the end of one second for the case ⌀ = 0.25∙L , with computational steps of (0.1) s.

Figure 19:
Successive frames of the strain in the plate as the applied stress.

CONCLUSIONS

The results demonstrated that the stress concentration factor is strongly influenced by the geometric discontinuities introduced in the plate. In particular, the variation of the hole radius revealed consistent changes in the local stress field, showing that larger discontinuities tend to increase stress amplification around their edges. This finding reinforces the importance of considering geometric proportions when evaluating the mechanical performance of perforated plates.

Furthermore, the analysis of hole positioning along the plate length confirmed that, for equal radii, the change in position has little effect on the stress concentration factor. Similarly, variations in plate length and width do not significantly modify the stress distribution when the ratio between hole radius and plate dimensions is maintained. These results suggest that geometric scaling preserves the general behavior of the stress field in such configurations.

Regarding strain concentration, the simulations indicated that Point 1, located at the edge of the discontinuity, experiences accelerated strain accumulation, quickly transitioning from the elastic regime to the plastic regime. In contrast, Point 2 exhibited slower strain evolution under the same applied load. This highlights the sensitivity of strain distribution to the proximity of geometric discontinuities, which can serve as critical regions for material failure.

Overall, this study advances the understanding of stress and strain concentration in perforated plates through the application of finite element simulations. By validating the numerical approach with analytical solutions and previous studies, the work contributes to consolidating hybrid meshing strategies as reliable tools for capturing local mechanical effects. These findings provide valuable insights for the design and optimization of structural elements containing discontinuities, supporting the development of safer and more efficient engineering applications.

Acknowledgments The authors would like to express their gratitude to the research institutions and laboratories that provided technical support and computational resources for this study. Special thanks are extended to colleagues and advisors whose guidance contributed to the improvement of the analyses and discussions presented in this work.

DATA AVAILABILITY

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

REFERENCES

  • 1 CALLISTER JUNIOR, W. D. Fundamentos da ciência e engenharia dos materiais. 8. ed. Rio de Janeiro: LTC, 2014.
  • 2 BEER, Ferdinand P. et al. Mecânica dos materiais. 5. ed. Porto Alegre: AMGH, 2011. Tradução técnica de José Benaque Rubert e Walter Libardi.
  • 3 KIRSCH, G. Die Theorie der Elastizität und die Bedürfnisse der Festigkeitslehre. Zeitschrift des Vereins Deutscher Ingenieure, v. 29, p. 797-807, 1898.
  • 4 DURELLI, J.; MURRAY, W. M. Stress distribution around a circular discontinuity in any two-dimensional system of combined stress. In: Proceedings of the 14th Semi-Annual Eastern Photoelasticity Conference, Yale University, New Haven, 1941.
  • 5 DURELLI, J.; MURRAY, W. M. Stress distribution around an elliptical discontinuity in any two-dimensional, uniform, and axial system of combined stress. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Stress Analysis, v. 1, p. 19-31, 1943.
  • 6 MURPHY, E. The Return of Photoelastic Stress Measurements: Utilizing Birefringence to Monitor Damage and Repair in Healable Materials. Journal of Materials Chemistry, v. 21, p. 1438-1446, 2011.
  • 7 MURPHY, E. The Return of Photoelastic Stress Measurements: Utilizing Birefringence to Monitor Damage and Repair in Healable Materials. Journal of Materials Chemistry , v. 21, p. 1438-1446, 2011.
  • 8 FRANKOVSKÝ, P.; Ostertag, O.; Ostertagová, E. Automation of Experiments in Photoelasticity. Procedia Engineering, v. 48, p. 153-157, 2012.
  • 9 TIMOSHENKO, S.; GOODIER, J. N. Theory of elasticity. 3. ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970.
  • 10 AINT-VENANT, B. de. Mémoire sur la torsion des prismes. Mémoires présentés par divers savants à l’Académie des Sciences de l’Institut de France, v. 14, p. 233-560, 1855.
  • 11 ALTAN, Mehmet Fatih; KARTAL, Murat Emre. Investigation of buckling behavior of laminated reinforced concrete plates with central rectangular hole using finite element method. Materials and Design, v. 30, p. 2243-2249, 2009. DOI:10.1016/j.matdes.2008.08.002.
    » https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2008.08.002
  • 12 KHECHAI, A.; TATI, A.; GUETTALA, A. Finite element analysis of stress concentrations and failure criteria in composite plates with circular holes. Frontiers of Mechanical Engineering, v. 9, n. 3, p. 281-294, 2014. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11465-014-0307-9
    » https://doi.org/10.1007/s11465-014-0307-9
  • 13 CHENG, A. H. D.; CHENG, D. T. Heritage and early history of the boundary element method. Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, v. 29, p. 268-302, 2005.
  • 14 KATSIKADELIS, J. T. Boundary elements: theory and applications. New York: Elsevier, 448 p., 2002.
  • 15 REISSNER, E. The effect of transverse shear deformation on the bending of elastic plates. Journal of Applied Mechanics, v. 3, p. 69-77, 1945.
  • 16 FERNANDES, G. R.; ARAÚJO, D.; PITUBA, J. L. C. Non-linear analysis of reinforced concrete plates by the boundary element method and continuum damage mechanics. Acta Scientiarum. Technology, v. 31, n. 1, p. 25-33, 2009.
  • 17 Yang, Z., Kim, C.-B., Cho, C., & Beom, H. G. (2008). The concentration of stress and strain in finite thickness elastic plate containing a circular hole. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 45(3-4), 713-731. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsolstr.2007.08.030
    » https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsolstr.2007.08.030

AE:

Daniel Zanetti de Florio

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    17 Aug 2026
  • Date of issue
    2026

History

  • Received
    26 July 2025
  • Reviewed
    14 Nov 2025
  • Reviewed
    16 Mar 2026
  • Accepted
    01 May 2026
location_on
Associação Brasileira de Cerâmica Av. Prof. Almeida Prado, 532 - IPT - Prédio 36 - 2º Andar - Sala 03 , Cidade Universitária - 05508-901 - São Paulo/SP -Brazil, Tel./Fax: +55 (11) 3768-7101 / +55 (11) 3768-4284 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
E-mail: ceramica.journal@abceram.org.br
rss_feed Stay informed of issues for this journal through your RSS reader
Go to top