Acioli et al., 2011, Brazil |
89 speech therapists |
Questionnaire not validated |
43.8% (39) |
2.9% (2) |
Azevedo et al., 2012, Brazil |
187 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
14.3% (25) |
24% (6) |
Badger e Tuscaloosa 1989, Alabama |
276 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
324 cases of physical violence, 70% reported by pediatricians and 26% by family doctors. 226 cases of sexual violence were detected, 76% by pediatricians and 20% by family physicians |
89% of cases of physical violence were reported and 94% of cases of sexual violence |
Buldur et al., 2022, Turkey |
229 physicians and dentists |
Questionnaire developed and validated by the study authors themselves |
21.8% (50) |
39.6% |
Brattabo et al., 2016, Norway |
1.200 dentists and dental hygienists |
Questionnaire not validated |
NR |
60% (720) |
Brattabo et al., 2018, Norway |
1.200 dentists and dental hygienists |
Questionnaire not validated |
67.4% (818) |
60% (720) |
Campos, 2010, Brazil |
123 pediatric dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
36.4% (43) |
78.9% (15) |
Carvalho et al., 2010, Brazil |
96 pediatricians |
Questionnaire not validated |
55% (53) |
NR |
Carvalho et al., 2013, Brazil |
40 dentists from the public service and 40 from the private service |
Questionnaire not validated |
16% in the public network and only 3% in the private network. |
60% of dentists in the public network and 50% in the private network |
Cavalcanti et al., 2002, Brazil |
84 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
11% (9) |
NR |
Cavalcanti e Martins, 2009, Brazil |
28 pediatricians and 35 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
78.6% (22) of pediatricians and 34.3% (12) of dentists suspected cases. |
95% (19) of pediatricians and 5% (1) of dentists |
Cukovic-Bagic et al., 2015, Croatia |
510 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
26.27% (134) |
7.20% |
Dalledone et al., 2015, Brazil |
146 dentists and 77 oral health technicians |
Questionnaire on Childhood Trauma (QUESI) by Marengo et al., 2013 |
52.73% (77) of dentists and 46.75% (36) of technicians |
35.67% (66) of dentists and 22.08% (17) of technicians |
De Lima e Pieri, 2021, Brazil |
45 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
24.44% (11) |
36.36% triggered the Guardianship Council |
Denny et al., 2001, New Zealand |
148 pediatricians |
Questionnaire not validated |
18 |
61% (11) |
El Tantawi et al., 2022, Egypt |
821 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
43.1% (354) |
4.3% |
Francon et al., 2011, Brazil |
19 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
26.31% (5) |
0% (There was no notification) |
Garcia et al., 2008, Brazil |
54 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
33% |
89% |
Gunn et al., 2005, USA |
195 pediatricians |
Questionnaire not validated |
96% |
NR |
Gurgel et al., 2001, Brazil |
199 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
32.70% |
64.8% |
James et al., 1978, USA |
96 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
53% (51) |
42% |
Kugananthan et al., 2021, Australia |
228 DHPs, dentists, hygienists and dental therapists |
Questionnaire not validated |
55% |
20 |
Laud et al., 2012, Greece |
368 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
13% suspected physical and psychological violence and 35% of neglect |
6 dentists notified |
Lima et al., 2005, Brazil |
70 pediatric dentists |
Non-validated questionnaire applied via phone call |
27.1% (19) |
5% (1) |
Lima et al., 2011, Brazil |
506 professionals, 188 from the Basic Health Units and 318 from the Family Health Team |
Questionnaire not validated |
34.8% (54) of the workers of the Basic Health Units and 42.3% (121) of the Family Health Team identified some case of violence |
50% |
Losso et al., 2012, Brazil |
56 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
18% (10) |
3.5% (2) |
Luna et al., 2010, Brazil |
77 physicians and 130 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
25.4% (43) of physicians and 26.1% (44) of dentists |
30% (21) of physicians and 25.8% (18) of dentists |
Martins Júnior et al., 2019, Brazil |
27 dentists and 10 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
40.7% (11) dentists. 100% (10) physicians |
7.4 (2) dentists and 90% (9) physicians |
Merwass et al., 2021, Saudi Arabia |
371 health professionals |
Questionnaire not validated |
NR |
102% of participants a case of abuse and child abuse |
Moreira et al., 2013, Brazil |
9 physicians, 26 nurses and 16 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
37.20% |
60% |
Moreira et al., 2014, Brazil |
207 nurses, 91 doctors and 83 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
40.7% |
34.8% |
Moreira et al., 2015, Brazil |
212 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
28.3% (60) |
16.9% |
Nigri et al., 2021, 22 European countries |
1083 European pediatricians |
Questionnaire validated by the information technology department of EPA-UNEPSA, Berlin, Germany |
80% of respondents found at least one case of child emotional or psychological abuse and 76.3% at least one case of physical or sexual abuse |
47.80% - Sexual; 22.30% - Emotional. |
Noguchi et al., 2005, Brazil |
224 speech therapists |
Questionnaire not validated |
24.1% (54) |
4 professionals |
Noguchi et al., 2006, Brazil |
224 speech therapists |
Questionnaire not validated |
24.1% (54) |
NR |
Nunes et al., 2021, Brazil |
181 dentists |
Questionnaire on Childhood Trauma (QUESI) by Marengo et al., 2013 |
40.3% (73) had already recognized some cases of physical violence |
6.1% (11) |
Pires et al., 2005, Brazil |
92 pediatricians |
Questionnaire not validated |
86.96% (80) |
78.75% (63) |
Russel et al., 2004, Northern Ireland |
431 health professionals |
Questionnaire not validated |
58% (251) |
47% (201) |
Saleem et al., 2021, Pakistan |
330 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
20% suspected physical violence |
30% |
Saulsbury et al., 1985, USA |
252 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
90% |
NR |
Schweitzer et al., 2006, Australia |
91 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
74% |
21% (19) |
Silva et al., 2019, Brazil |
238 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
12.8% (28) |
39% notified the Guardianship Council and 5% dialed 100 |
Silva Júnior et al., 2017, Brazil |
227 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
53.1% |
52.6% |
Silva-Oliveira et al., 2017, Brazil |
35 dentists, 46 nurses, 63 physicians |
Questionnaire on Childhood Trauma (QUESI) by Marengo et al., 2013 |
59.7% (86) |
26.4% (38) |
Silva-Oliveira et al., 2019, Brazil |
715 health professionals |
Questionnaire on Childhood Trauma (QUESI) by Marengo et al., 2013 |
57.9% (414) |
NR |
Silva-Oliveira et al., 2020, Brazil |
715 health professionals |
Questionnaire on Childhood Trauma (QUESI) by Marengo et al., 2013 |
57.9% (414) |
41.3% (171) |
Sunitha et al., 2021, India |
109 dentists |
Questionnaire validated by the research authors |
13.7% |
19 |
Talsma et al., 2015, Sweden |
77 physicians |
Questionnaire not validated |
37 |
46% (17) |
Tilden et al., 1994, USA |
1521 health professionals |
Questionnaire not validated |
9.3% of psychologists suspected psychological violence and 7.7% sexual, 24.8% of dentists suspected psychological and 30.9% sexual violence, 40.0a% of physicians suspected psychological and 13.2% sexual violence. |
NR |
Tornavoi et al., 2011, Brazil |
180 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
34% |
45% |
Van Dam et al., 2015, Netherlands |
264 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
24% (58) |
18% |
Vergara et al., 2017, Colombia |
149 dentists |
Questionnaire not validated |
34.4% (51) |
NR |