|
This study |
Moon et al. (2008b) |
Ozler et al. (2011) |
Ozler et al. (2013) |
P (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
E (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clg (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clt (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Exine (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
P (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
E (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clg (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clt (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Exine (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
P (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
E (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clg (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clt (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Exine (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
P (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
E (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clg (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Clt (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
Exine (µm) (Min.-Max.) M S(±) |
1 |
S. aethiopis
|
(37.90-40.01) 40.01 ±0.97 |
(40.01-41.06) 40.64 ±0.54 |
(29.48-31.59) 30.53 ±0.99 |
(2.10-3.15) 2.47 ±0.43 |
(2.10-2.63) 2.21 ±0.22 |
(38.3-43.2) 41.1 |
(32.9-44.1) 37.6 |
(29.2-37.7) 32.6 |
_ |
(1.7-2.7) 2.1 Po (1.5-2.3) 1.8 Eq |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(25.0-33.6) 30.7 ±2.4 |
(35.5-43.2) 39.2 ±2.2 |
(22.1-28.8) 26.1 ±2.0 |
(6.2-9.6) 7.7 ±1.0 |
(1.2-1.7) 1.5 ±0.2 |
2 |
S. argentea
|
(34.74-41.06) 36.50 ±2.43 |
(38.96-47.38) 42.00 ±2.24 |
(26.32-28.43) 27.37±0.99 |
(2.63-3.15) 2.84 ±0.27 |
(2.10-3.15) 2.36 ±0.37 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(37.4-50.9) 41.5 ±3.2 |
(43.2-56.6) 48.6 ±3.3 |
(31.7-47.0) 35.3 ±3.2 |
(7.7-10.6) 9.2 ±0.8 |
(1.2-1.9) 1.6 ±0.3 |
3 |
S. aytachii
|
(32.00-34.28) 33.76 ±0.87 |
(29.48-31.59) 30.64 ±0.60 |
(30.00-31.40) 31.16 ±0.21 |
(1.40-1.57) 1.43 ±0.07 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.36 ±0.27 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
4 |
S. blepharochlaena
|
(61.00-62.01) 71.77 ±0.41 |
(42.01-44.06) 43.61 ±0.59 |
(58.00-59.50) 58.72 ±0.73 |
(0.20-0.50) 0.35 ±0.13 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.15 ±0.22 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(49.9-61.4) 57.0 ±2.8 |
(45.1-65.3) 53.0 ±5.0 |
(48.0-60.5) 52.9 ±3.2 |
(5.3-8.2) 6.5 ±0.8 |
(1.0-1.4) 1.2 ±0.2 |
5 |
S. cadmica
|
(42.12-43.17) 42.54 ±0.54 |
(34.74-37.90) 36.85 ±1.40 |
(29.48-31.59) 30.74 ±0.97 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.15 ±0.22 |
(1.57-2.10) 1.99 ±0.22 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(43.2-51.8) 47.7 ±2.4 |
(43.2-54.7) 50.0 ±3.5 |
(37.4-48.0) 42.6 ±2.4 |
(4.6-7.7) 5.7 ±0.9 |
(1.2-1.7) 1.4 ±0.2 |
6 |
S. ceratophylla
|
(36.85-50.54) 41.90 ±3.50 |
(32.64-51.59) 37.30 ±6.08 |
(31.59-36.85) 32.50 ±1.72 |
(1.05-2.10) 1.89 ±0.37 |
(2.10-3.15) 2.36 ±0.45 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(31.7-43.2) 38.4 ±2.9 |
(44.2-52.8) 47.5 ±2.5 |
(25.0-36.5) 32.5 ±3.0 |
(7.7-10.6) 9.2 ±0.8 |
(1.4-1.9) 1.6 ±0.2 |
7 |
S. cryptantha
|
(33.69-43.17) 39.90 ±3.18 |
(27.37-37.90) 31.30 ±3.06 |
(26.32-33.69) 30.04 ±2.78 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.26 ±0.27 |
(1.05-2.10) 1.36 ±0.37 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
8 |
S. frigida
|
(44.80-45.02) 44.92 ±0.16 |
(34.20-35.33) 35.08 ±0.47 |
(35.33-36.66) 36.32 ±0.55 |
(3.60-4.01) 3.82 ±0.21 |
(2.10-2.90) 2.58 ±0.20 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(30.7-44.2) 37.3 ±3.1 |
(37.4-46.1) 42.5 ±2.6 |
(24.0-37.4) 31.3 ±3.7 |
(7.2-9.6) 8.2 ±0.7 |
(1.2-1.7) 1.4 ±0.2 |
9 |
S. fruticosa
|
(30.05-31.55) 31.20 ±0.67 |
(39.05-40.05) 39.25 ±0.41 |
(25.01-29.00) 27.12 ±1.36 |
(4.50-5.01) 4.60 ±0.22 |
(1.00-1.05) 1.04 ±0.22 |
(39.1-50.6) 48.1 |
(36.5-43.6) 40.6 |
(37.8-43.7) 39.9 |
_ |
(1.5-2.4) 2.0 Po (1.3-2.1) 1.7 Eq |
(30.7-41.3) 35.7 ±2.8 |
(27.8-43.2) 38.0 ±3.5 |
(23.0-31.7) 28.9 ±2.5 |
(2.9-6.7) 4.9 ±4.9 |
(1.0-1.2) 1.1 ±0.2 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
10 |
S. halophila
|
(47.50-49.05) 48.32 ±0.42 |
(35.05-36.05) 35.35 ±0.48 |
(40.85-42.85) 42.45 ±0.64 |
(1.05-1.10) 1.07 ±0.02 |
(1.25-1.70) 1.57 ±0.19 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(37.4-53.8) 43.2 ±3.6 |
(43.2-49.9) 47.5 ±1.7 |
(32.5-49.9) 38.6 ±3.8 |
(6.7-11.5) 8.1 ±1.3 |
(1.2-1.9) 1.6 ±0.3 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
11 |
S. napifolia
|
(42.12-44.12) 43.38 ±0.96 |
(27.37-28.43) 27.69 ±0.51 |
(24.21-25.27) 24.85 ±0.74 |
(1.57-2.10) 1.89 ±0.27 |
(1.05-2.10) 1.47 ±0.41 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
12 |
S. microstegia
|
(30.05-33.55) 31.60 ±0.96 |
(38.05-41.05) 39.35 ±0.82 |
(25.01-29.00) 26.92 ±1.51 |
(4.35-5.01) 4.64 ±0.26 |
(1.00-1.10) 1.05 ±0.05 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(32.6-50.9) 41.3 ±6.1 |
(39.4-60.5) 47.7 ±5.5 |
(26.9-43.2) 34.7 ±5.3 |
(7.2-9.8) 8.6 ±0.9 |
(1.2-1.7) 1.4 ±0.2 |
13 |
S. recognita
|
(46.40-59.65) 53.90 ±4.94 |
(44.05-45.10) 44.63 ±0.45 |
(50.75-55.31) 53.50 ±1.99 |
(1.70-2.50) 2.20 ±0.31 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.10 ±0.16 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(40.3-47.0) 43.4 ±2.1 |
(43.2-49.9) 47.5 ±1.6 |
(28.8-39.4) 35.9 ±2.4 |
(6.7-9.6) 8.4 ±0.9 |
(0.7-1.2) 1.0 ±0.1 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
14 |
S. sclarea
|
(34.50-37.80) 35.05 ±1.02 |
(39.70-40.05) 39.90 ±0.17 |
(29.50-30.25) 29.92 ±0.27 |
(7.57-9.02) 8.40 ±0.52 |
(1.05-2.02) 1.56 ±0.23 |
(43.9-55.0) 49.0 |
(43.0-50.5) 48.0 |
(37.2-49.3) 42.3 |
_ |
(1.5-2.2) 1.9 Po (1.2-2.0) 1.5 Eq |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(38.4-47.0) 42.3 ±2.6 |
(47.0-59.5) 53.0 ±3.4 |
(33.6-41.3) 37.2 ±2.5 |
(7.2-10.6) 8.8 ±0.8 |
(1.2-1.7) 1.4 ±0.2 |
15 |
S. smyrnaea
|
(38.96-60.00) 43.50 ±6.20 |
(32.64-43.17) 37.50 ±3.41 |
(30.53-54.16) 33.50 ±7.30 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.10 ±0.16 |
(1.57-2.10) 1.62 ±0.17 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(39.4-49.9) 42.7 ±2.7 |
(42.2-53.8) 49.1 ±3.1 |
(34.6-45.6) 38.1 ±2.8 |
(6.7-9.6) 8.3 ±0.9 |
(1.2-1.9) 1.6 ±0.2 |
16 |
S. suffruticosa
|
(31.59-56.25) 37.10 ±6.89 |
(24.21-30.53) 28.80 ±1.83 |
(22.11-50.00) 27.30 ±8.41 |
(1.57-3.15) 2.36 ±0.45 |
(1.57-2.10) 1.68 ±0.22 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(34.6-49.0) 41.9 ±4.0 |
(37.4-49.9) 45.0 ±2.9 |
(28.8-43.2) 35.0 ±4.1 |
(3.8-6.7) 5.3 ±0.8 |
(0.7-1.2) 1.0 ±0.1 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
17 |
S. tchihatcheffii
|
(43.50-46.64) 45.70 ±0.97 |
(34.64-35.50) 34.72 ±0.28 |
(39.50-42.89) 41.54 ±1.56 |
(1.05-2.01) 1.51 ±0.23 |
(1.02-1.05) 1.02 ±0.01 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(31.7-38.40) 34.7 ±1.7 |
(31.7-49.9) 39.6 ±3.8 |
(25.0-35.5) 28.8 ±2.2 |
(4.8-8.64) 6.5 ±1.2 |
(1.0-1.7) 1.2 ±0.2 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
18 |
S. tomentosa
|
(30.80-35.70) 32.30 ±1.34 |
(21.70-23.70) 22.24 ±0.69 |
(24.75-25.06) 24.99 ±0.12 |
(1.05-2.20) 1.58 ±0.50 |
(1.57-1.80) 1.62 ±0.08 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(38.4-43.2) 41.2 ±1.4 |
(45.1-49.0) 47.2 ±1.2 |
(33.6-39.4) 37.1 ±1.6 |
(7.7-9.6) 8.9 ±0.6 |
(1.4-1.9) 1.7 ±0.2 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
19 |
S. verbenaca
|
(44.50-45.75) 45.16 ±0.30 |
(32.41-32.50) 32.44 ±0.05 |
(38.25-39.65) 39.27 ±0.59 |
(1.02-1.57) 1.52 ±0.17 |
(1.02-2.02) 1.51 ±0.29 |
(35.8-46.0) 42.0 |
(32.8-39.3) 35.6 |
(30.0-40.0) 35.5 |
_ |
(1.6-2.7) 1.9 Po (1.2-1.9) 1.6 Eq |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
20 |
S. viridis
|
(31.59-41.06) 38.20 ±3.10 |
(30.53-44.22) 36.40 ±5.96 |
(25.27-35.80) 31.40 ±3.09 |
(1.05-1.57) 1.36 ±0.27 |
(1.05-2.10) 1.94 ±0.35 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(31.7-37.4) 34.1 ±1.6 |
(37.4-47.0) 42.1 ±2.3 |
(26.9-34.6) 29.7 ±2.2 |
(6.7-9.1) 7.7 ±0.7 |
(1.0-1.4) 1.2 ±0.2 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
21 |
S. wiedemannii
|
(31.59-32.64) 31.90 ±0.51 |
(25.27-31.59) 29.30 ±1.70 |
(24.21-26.32) 25.06 ±0.83 |
(1.57-2.10) 1.68 ±0.22 |
(1.05-2.63) 1.52 ±0.58 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
(34.6-52.8) 40.7 ±3.7 |
(35.5-58.6) 46.6 ±3.8 |
(31.7-52.8) 36.3 ±3.6 |
(4.3-6.2) 5.4 ±0.5 |
(1.2-1.4) 1.3 ±0.1 |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |
_ |