C. colorectal
|
Niraj et al., 201117
|
62 |
Bilateral TAP with catheter in high abdominal surgery |
TAP vs. epidural |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 72 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Walter et al., 201318
|
68 |
Bilateral TAP in c. colorectal |
TAP vs. no TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Cesarean
|
Belavy et al., 200919
|
57 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with spinal anesthesia |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized blind trial |
5 |
Costello et al., 200920
|
96 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with spinal anesthesia with ITM |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Baaj et al., 201021
|
40 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with spinal anesthesia |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
3 |
Kanazi et al., 201022
|
57 |
ITM in cesarean |
TAP vs. ITM + placebo TAP |
Time until the opioid rescue |
Randomized double-blind trial |
4 |
Loane et al., 201223
|
66 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean under spinal anesthesia |
TAP vs. ITM + placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Tan et al., 201224
|
40 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with general anesthesia |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Bollag et al., 201225
|
90 |
Bilateral TAP with clonidine in cesarean with spinal anesthesia |
clonidine TAP vs. TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Hyperalgesia index of the wound following TAP |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Eslamian et al., 201226
|
50 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with general anesthesia |
TAP vs. no TAP |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Cánovas et al., 201327
|
90 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with spinal anesthesia |
TAP vs. placebo TAP vs. ITM + placebo TAP |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Lee et al., 201328
|
51 |
Bilateral TAP in cesarean with spinal anesthesia with ITM |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
VAS pain score in movement in the first 48 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Cholecystectomy
|
El-Dawlatly et al., 200929
|
42 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic cholecystectomy |
TAP vs. no TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
3 |
Ra et al., 201030
|
54 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic cholecystectomy |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Numerical and verbal pain score in the first 24 h |
Randomized blind trial |
3 |
Petersen et al., 201231
|
80 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic cholecystectomy |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
VAS pain score in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Ortiz et al., 201232
|
80 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic cholecystectomy |
TAP vs. infiltration |
VAS pain score in the first 24 h |
Randomized blind trial |
3 |
Tolchard et al., 201233
|
43 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic cholecystectomy |
TAP vs. infiltration |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h Reduction of VAS |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Gynecological
|
Griffiths et al., 201034
|
65 |
Bilateral TAP in oncologic gynecological surgery |
TAP vs. placebo |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h Reduction of VAS |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Atim et al., 201135
|
55 |
Bilateral TAP in hysterectomy |
TAP vs. TAP placebo vs. local infiltration |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
2 |
De Oliveira et al., 201136
|
75 |
Bilateral TAP in gynecological c. laparoscopic |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
QoR-40 satisfaction score |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Kane et al., 201237
|
56 |
Bilateral TAP in laparoscopic hysterectomy |
TAP vs. no TAP |
Satisfaction score QoR-40 |
Randomized blind trial |
3 |
|
H. inguinal
|
Aveline et al., 201138
|
275 |
Unilateral TAP in inguinal herniorrhaphy |
TAP vs. b. ileoinguinal-ileohipogastric |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized blind trial |
3 |
López González et al., 201339
|
41 |
Unilateral TAP in inguinal herniorrhaphy |
TAP vs. infiltration |
VAS pain score at rest and im movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized blind trial |
2 |
Petersen et al., 201340
|
90 |
Unilateral TAP in inguinal herniorrhaphy |
TAP vs. Placebo TAP vs. IIB + infiltration LA |
VAS pain score at rest and in movement in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Appendectomy
|
Niraj et al., 200941
|
52 |
Unilateral TAP in open appendectomy |
TAP vs. no TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Nephrectomy
|
Hosgood et al., 201242
|
46 |
TAP in donor nephrectomy |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 48 h and VAS pain score |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Parikh et al., 201343
|
60 |
TAP in donor nephrectomy |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Bariatric
|
Sinha et al., 201344
|
100 |
TAP in bariatric surgery (laparoscopic Y-Roux anastomosis) |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Albrecht et al., 201345
|
70 |
TAP in bariatric surgery with local infiltration LA |
TAP vs. no TAP |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
|
Gastrectomy
|
Wu et al., 201346
|
90 |
TAP in radical gastrectomy |
TAP vs. epidural vs. no intervention |
Consumption of opioids in the first 24 h and VAS pain score |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |
Elkassabany et al., 201347
|
52 |
Bilateral TAP in retropubic radical prostatectomy |
TAP vs. placebo TAP |
VAS pain score and consumption of opioids in the first 24 h |
Randomized double-blind trial |
5 |