Arizola HGA et al., 2012, Brazil6
|
11 F: 11 M: 0 |
40-50 years |
10 |
Twice a week for 5 weeks |
Not reported |
-Facial muscle release management -Facial muscle stretching -Exercise for aesthetic speech treatment -Counter-resistance exercise |
Clinical observation with photography and muscle palpation. A questionnaire was conducted on the changes perceived by patients and third parties. Satisfaction before and after speech-language-hearing therapy was assessed using a 100 mm visual analogue scale. |
Speech-language-hearing treatment provided facial changes perceived by clients, third parties, and specialists. After speech-language-hearing aesthetic treatment, 8 (72.7%) reported a good feeling and 2 (27.3%) perceived a more relaxed face. |
Case-control |
De Vos MC et al., 2013, Belgium18 |
18 F: 18 M: 0 |
47 years in the experimental group and 46 in the control group |
49 |
Daily for 7 weeks |
4 isometric exercises |
An exercise to reduce horizontal wrinkles on the forehead (frontal muscle); an exercise to reduce vertical wrinkles above the upper lip (orbicularis oris); an exercise to reduce the nasolabial fold (orbicularis oris and zygomaticus minor muscles); and an exercise to reduce double chin and define the jaw better (masseter, sternocleidomastoid and mylohyoid muscles) |
Judges evaluated the participants' images. There were 10 lay people (5 men and 5 women), aged 30 to 40 years. |
The panel chose the image of the upper lip after therapy most often as the younger-looking one in the experimental group. |
Case-control |
Frazão Y et al., 2012, Brazil1
|
3 F: 3 M: 0 |
41, 48, and 49 years |
12 |
Once a week + maintenance at home |
Isotonic and isometric exercises and massages; adjustment of vocal intonation and amplitude of articulatory movements; drainage; reorganization of facial muscle dynamics |
Not reported |
Initial interview, filming chewing and swallowing functions; filming facial expressions in spontaneous speech and performing specific movements; photographic record |
Reduction of exaggerated facial expressions in communication (n=3), the eyes were more symmetrical and there was a reduction in bags in the lower eyelid (n=1), a reduction in malar wrinkles, improved chewing and swallowing, and improved facial contour (n=1) The effectiveness of speech-language-hearing intervention in facial aesthetics has been proven. |
Case series |
Nishimura H et al., 2017, Japan13 |
20 F: 20 M: 0 |
30-54 years |
Not reported |
Not reported |
Facial massage |
Facial massage |
The nasolabial folds, upper, lower, and lateral cheeks, and lower eyelids were analyzed based on photographs. |
Facial massage caused morphological changes in several facial sites; soft tissues were moved upwards around the jaw; the thickness of the adipose tissue in the nasal ala increased after massage. The shapes of the facial expression muscles were also changed after massage. Apparently, massage did not affect the shape of the nasolabial folds but caused morphological changes in the cheek, changing the appearance of the nasolabial folds. |
Case series |
Okuda I et al., 2022, Japan17 |
5 F: 3 M: 2 |
29-37 years |
14 |
Twice a day for 2 weeks |
Massage |
Massage |
CT scan (analyzed by two radiologists) |
The malar mound thinned and shifted cranially and horizontally. The SMAS height (the greatest vertical distance from the SMAS) increased. The rate of change in cheek thickness was significantly correlated with SMAS height. These changes were attributed to the lifting and tensor effects of facial massage. SMAS: superficial musculoaponeurotic system |
Case series |
Paes C et al., 2007, Brazil12 |
10 Sex not reported |
33-63 years (mean: 43.5) |
16 |
1 meeting a week |
Guidelines for facial care, isotonic, isometric, and isokinetic exercises, massages, facial manipulations, and stomatognathic functional balance, including masticatory training |
Not reported |
Medical history survey, assessment, photographic record, and a performance protocol |
The projection measures of the nasolabial fold to the tragus on both sides decreased significantly. Positive results were found in the cheek and mouth areas. All patients noticed some change in their faces after speech-language-hearing treatment. Other people noticed some change in the faces of 7 patients but not in 3 - the ones who performed the exercises least frequently. Smoothness and relaxation occur after performing the isometric exercises Regarding wrinkles, 8 patients observed that they became smoother, and 4 patients reported having noticed greater firmness in facial tone. Sensation of lightness (n=6) and rest and rejuvenation (n=4) |
Case series |
Takacs AP et al., 2002, Brazil14 |
8 F: 6 M: 2 |
31-66 years (mean: 48.4)* |
90 |
6 exercises once a day for 3 months |
Six isometric exercises |
Raising the eyebrows by wrinkling the forehead for 7 seconds; bringing the eyebrows together for 7 seconds; closing the eyes tightly for 7 seconds; protruding the lips for 7 seconds; lateralizing the corners of the mouth by opening the lip line for 7 seconds; contracting the right and left cheeks with resistance for 7 seconds. |
Questionnaire. 11 individuals were given pre- and post-therapy photographs of each patient and were asked to specify the photographs in which the patient appeared younger and older |
The exercises helped reduce wrinkles, expression lines, and facial sagging in all individuals, with varying degrees and locations of improvement. There was a reduction in the nasolabial fold (n=7); reduction in dark circles (n=5); reduction in sagging cheeks (n=4); reduction in transverse wrinkles on the forehead (n=3); reduction in wrinkles around the eyes (n=3); a rested, relaxed, and serene face (n=3); more defined lips, and a change in posture (n=1). Patients noticed firmer mouths and foreheads, thicker lips, a more relaxed expression, a rested face, bright and fresh skin, and lifted lines on the lips, eyes, eyebrows, and cheeks. |
Case series |