Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Experimental study on flexural creep of self-compacting concrete reinforced with vegetable and synthetic fibers

Abstract

This article evaluates the impact of different fiber types on the flexural creep of self-compacting concretes (SCC). The study focuses on the effects of vegetable fibers (Hemp, [H] and Dis [D]) and synthetic fibers (Polypropylene [P]) on SCC. To assess the SCC, various tests such as spreading, J Ring, compressive strength, and flexural strength are conducted. The authors developed a test configuration and methodology to subject beams measuring 120 cm in length to sustained flexural stresses for 200 days. Two curing modes of the beams are also studied: total creep (beams exposed to air) and endogenous creep (beams protected from air). Moreover, the plant fibers were previously subjected to two treatments separately; the first involves immersing them in a 5% alkaline solution of NaOH (HN and DN) and the second in a solution of the polymer styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) (HS and DS). The findings show that the treatment of vegetable fibers by SBR reveals high mechanical properties as well as a good capacity for endogenous and total creep. SCC-DS shows an increase in flexural strength of 9% and 13% with a decrease in total creep of 4% and 16% compared to SCC without fiber and SCC-DN, respectively. These results are promising for further reflection on a large scale to explore the issue of strengthening SCC with treated vegetable fibers.

Keywords:
self-compacting concrete; vegetable fibers; hemp; dis; polypropylene; styrene-butadiene rubber; flexural creep

1. Introduction

The deformation of concrete structural members under continuous load (creep) is known to be several times greater than the instantaneous deformation during loading (Babafemi & Boshoff, 2015BABAFEMI, A. J.; BOSHOFF, W. P. Tensile creep of macro-synthetic fibre reinforced concrete (MSFRC) under uni-axial tensile loading. Cement and Concrete Composites, 55, p. 62-69, 2015.). This allows us to consider the deformation due to creep as an important factor in the realization of constructions in the medium to long term (García-Taengua et al., 2014GARCÍA-TAENGUA, E.; ARANGO, S.; MARTÍ-VARGAS, J. R.; SERNA, P. Flexural creep of steel fiber reinforced concrete in the cracked state. Construction and Building Materials, 65, p. 321-329, 2014.). The bending creep type has two major advantages. It is easier to perform and can be directly correlated to the bending test for better characterization. Self-compacting concrete (SCC) is generally considered as a special type of ordinary concrete containing high amounts of fines and a lower water-to-binder ratio compared to other concretes (Bensalem et al., 2014BENSALEM, S.; AMOURI, C.; HOUARI, H.; BELACHIA, M. Elaboration and characterization of self-compacting concrete based on local by-products. International Journal of Engineering, Science and Technology, v. 6, n. 1, p. 98-105, 2014.). This leads to greater delayed deformations of SCC compared to ordinary concrete (Benkechkache & Houari, 2009BENKENKECHKACHE, G.; HOUARI, H. Comparaison des retraits et fluages des betons autoplacants et des betons ordinaires vibres. Sciences & Technologie. B, Sciences de l'ingénieur, p. 9-16, 2009.). Therefore, self-compacting concrete has particular responses concerning creep.

The effectiveness of using fibers as reinforcement in self-compacting concrete has already been demonstrated in reducing creep deformation and improving some mechanical properties (Basser et al., 2022BASSER, H.; SHAGHAGHI, T. M.; AFSHIN, H.; AHARI, R. S.; MIRREZAEI, S. S. An experimental investigation and response surface methodology-based modeling for predicting and optimizing the rheological and mechanical properties of self-compacting concrete containing steel fiber and PET. Construction and Building Materials, 315, 125370, 2022.; Li et al., 2021bLI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 9, p. 5257-5268, 2021b.; Marangon et al., 2012MARANGON, E.; TOLEDO FILHO, R.; FAIRBAIRN, E. Basic creep under compression and direct tension loads of self-compacting-steel fibers reinforced concrete. High Performance Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites, 6, p. 171-178, 2012.). However, most of the tests have been conducted on SCC reinforced with steel fibers and/or polypropylene, despite their high cost and considerable CO2 emissions during production from non-renewable resources (Denzin Tonoli et al., 2010TONOLI, G. H. D.; ALMEIDA, A. E. F. de S.; SILVA, M. A. P. da, BASSA, A.; OYAKAWA, D.; SAVASTANO, H. Surface properties of eucalyptus pulp fibres as reinforcement of cement-based composites. Holzforschung, v. 64, n. 5, p. 595-601, 2010.). As a result, current research is exploring the possibility of replacing these fibers with natural ones (Wei & Meyer, 2015WEI, J.; MEYER, C. Degradation mechanisms of natural fiber in the matrix of cement composites. Cement and Concrete Research, 73, p. 1-16, 2015.). Plant fibers, which are biodegradable and renewable (Di Bella et al., 2014DI BELLA, G.; FIOE, V.; GALTIERI, G.; BORSELLINO, C.; VALENZA, A. Effects of natural fibres reinforcement in lime plasters (kenaf and sisal vs. Polypropylene). Construction and Building Materials, 58, p. 159-165, 2014.), offer a sustainable option and can be obtained from local resources in certain countries, such as Algeria.

Thus, vegetable fibers can make it possible to achieve interesting mechanical properties, while significantly reducing the cost price of the cementitious composite (Denzin Tonoli et al., 2010TONOLI, G. H. D.; SAVASTANO JÚNIOR, H.; FUENTE, E.; NEGRO, C.; BLANCO, A.; LAHR, F. A. R. Eucalyptus pulp fibres as alternative reinforcement to engineered cement-based composites. Industrial crops and products, v. 31, n. 2, p. 225-232, 2010.; de Andrade Silva et al., 2010SILVA, F. A; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D.; MELO FILHO, J. A.; FAIRBAIRN, E. M. R. Physical and mechanical properties of durable sisal fiber-cement composites. Construction and Building Materials, v. 24, n. 5, p. 777-785, 2010.; Ahmed, 2013AHMED, S. A. Properties and mesostructural characteristics of linen fiber reinforced self-compacting concrete in slender columns. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, v. 4, n. 2, p.155-161, 2013.). In research (Mohamed et al., 2010MOHAMED, M.; GHORBEL, E.; WARDEH, G. Valorization of micro-cellulose fibers in self-compacting concrete. Construction and Building Materials, v. 24, n. 12, p. 2473-2480, 2010.), the authors found that natural fibers reduce the static segregation of SCCs. (Ahmed , 2013AHMED, S. A. Properties and mesostructural characteristics of linen fiber reinforced self-compacting concrete in slender columns. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, v. 4, n. 2, p.155-161, 2013.) showed that adding 2 kg/m2 of flax fibers reduces SCC workability and increases compressive and tensile strength with a percentage of 8.3 and 17, respectively. (Awwad et al., 2012AWWAD, E.; MABSOUT, M.; HAMAD, B.; FARRAN, M. T.; KHATIB, H. Studies on fiber-reinforced concrete using industrial hemp fibers. Construction and Building Materials, 35, p. 710-717, 2012.) found an increase in flexural strength of 30% for concrete with 0.5% hemp fibers and a decrease in compressive strength of 20% at 28 days. Walid Laifa (Laifa et al., 2014LAIFA, W.; BEHIM, M.; TURATSINZE, A.; ALI-BOUCETTA, T. Caractérisation d’un béton autoplaçant avec addition de laitier cristallisé et renforcé par des fibres de polypropylène et de diss. Synthèse: Revue des Sciences et de la Technologie, v. 29, n. 1, p. 100-110, 2014.) explained that the improvement in tensile strength by bending of SCCs with Dis fiber is probably due to the roughness of this fiber.

Most of these studies were conducted for the effect of natural fibers on the properties of cementitious materials in the short term (de Azevedo et al., 2021AZEVEDO, A. R. G de; MARVILA, M. T.; ANTUNES, M. L. P.; RANGEL, E. C.; FEDIUK, R. Technological perspective for use the natural pineapple fiber in mortar to repair structures. Waste and Biomass Valorization, v. 12, n. 9, p. 5131-5145, 2021.; Banjo Ayobami Akinyemi & Dai, 2020AKINYEMI, B. A.; DAI, C. Development of banana fibers and wood bottom ash modified cement mortars. Construction and Building Materials, 241, 118041, 2020.; Reis, 2012REIS, J. Sisal fiber polymer mortar composites: introductory fracture mechanics approach. Construction and Building Materials, 37, p. 177-180, 2012.). However, in order to use these fibers in structural applications, it is necessary to study their long-term behavior. Sales (2006)SALES, Â. T. C. Retração, fluência e fratura em compósitos cimentícios reforçados com polpa de bambu. 2006. 273 f. Tese (Doutorado) - Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio de Janeiro, 2006. studied the effect of bamboo pulp fibers on the compression creep of cementitious composites. It was concluded that the presence of 8% and 14% of bamboo fibers causes an increase in basic creep capacity of 6 and 11 times greater than for the matrix without fiber, respectively. Iranildo Barbosa da Silva et al. (da Silva Junior et al., 2021SILVA JUNIOR, I. B. da; SOUZA, L. M. S. de; SILVA, F. A. Creep of pre-cracked sisal fiber reinforced cement based composites. Construction and Building Materials, 293, 123511, 2021.) studied the tensile and flexural creep behavior of cementitious materials containing sisal fibers. The authors used these fibers with natural humidity and saturated with water. They found that the composites made from the natural moisture fibers showed larger cracks due to the low pull-out strength of these fibers. On the other hand, composites with saturated fibers showed greater deformation and efficiency in maintaining cracks. They concluded that it is necessary to give importance to the ITZ between the plant fiber and the matrix.

Currently, there is significant interest among researchers in the treatment of plant fibers to enhance the physical and mechanical properties of cementitious composites through improved matrix/fiber adhesion. This has been explored in several recent studies, including those by Li et al., Dridi et al., and Chiker et al. (Li et al., 2021bLI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 9, p. 5257-5268, 2021b.; Dridi et al., 2022DRIDI, M.; HACHEMI, S.; BELKADI, A. A. Influence of styrene-butadiene rubber and pretreated hemp fibers on the properties of cement-based repair mortars. European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering, p. 1-20, 2022.; Chiker et al., 2021CHIKER, T.; BELKADI, A. A.; AGGOUN, S. Physico-chemical and microstructural fire-induced alterations into metakaolin-based vegetable and polypropylene fibred mortars. Construction and Building Materials, 276, 122225, 2021.; Kundu et al., 2018KUNDU, S. P.; CHAKRABORTY, S.; CHAKRABORTY, S. Effectiveness of the surface modified jute fibre as fibre reinforcement in controlling the physical and mechanical properties of concrete paver blocks. Construction and Building Materials, 191, p. 554-563, 2018.). Belkadi et al. (Belkadi et al., 2018BELKADI, A. A.; AGGOUN, S.; AMOURI, C.; GEUTTALA, A.; HOUARI, H. Effect of vegetable and synthetic fibers on mechanical performance and durability of Metakaolin-based mortars. Journal of adhesion science and Technology, v. 32, n. 15, p. 1670-1686, 2018.) sought to replace a significant portion of cement with 30% of metakaolin to reduce the degree of alkalinity in the composite and improve the durability of plant fibers. Other researchers have investigated the effects of NaOH treatment on plant fibers such as Dis and Sisal, which has been found to increase matrix/fiber adhesion and reduce impurities on the fiber surface (Dridi et al., 2022DRIDI, M.; HACHEMI, S.; BELKADI, A. A. Influence of styrene-butadiene rubber and pretreated hemp fibers on the properties of cement-based repair mortars. European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering, p. 1-20, 2022.; Li et al., 2021bLI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 9, p. 5257-5268, 2021b.). In a recent study, (Candamano et al., 2021CANDAMANO, S.; CREA, F.; COPPOÇA, L.; DE LUCA, P.; COFFETTI, D. Influence of acrylic latex and pre-treated hemp fibers on cement based mortar properties. Construction and Building Materials, 273, 121720, 2021.) demonstrated that the use of commercial acrylic latex in the cementitious matrix improved the adhesion between chemically pretreated hemp fibers and the matrix, resulting in decreased water porosity in the composite. Ferreira et al. (Ferreira et al., 2020FERREIRA, S. R.; SENA NETO, A. R.; SILVA, F. de A.; SOUZA JR, F. G.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D. The influence of carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber coating on the mechanical performance of vegetable fibers and on their interface with a cement matrix. Construction and Building Materials, 262, 120770, 2020.) found that immersing hemp fibers in a styrene butadiene polymer significantly enhanced the adhesion of the matrix/fiber and improved the tensile strength of these fibers. Furthermore, recent works by Candamano et al. (2021)CANDAMANO, S.; CREA, F.; COPPOÇA, L.; DE LUCA, P.; COFFETTI, D. Influence of acrylic latex and pre-treated hemp fibers on cement based mortar properties. Construction and Building Materials, 273, 121720, 2021., Fidelis et al. (2016)FIDELIS, M. E. A.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D.; SILVA, F. de A.; MECHTCHERINE, V.; BUTLER, M.; HEMPEL, S. The effect of accelerated aging on the interface of jute textile reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 74, p. 7-15, 2016., and Li et al. (2021), and Banjo A Akinyemi & Adesina, (2021)AKINYEMI, B. A.; ADESINA, A. Utilization of polymer chemical admixtures for surface treatment and modification of cellulose fibres in cement-based composites: a review. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 3, p. 1241-1266, 2021.. have demonstrated good compatibility and bonding between plant fibers and polymers.

The aim of this research is to assess the potential of utilizing Hemp fiber and Dis, treated with NaOH and styrene-butadiene, as reinforcing elements in self-compacting concrete (SCC). The study investigates the impact of the nature of fibers (Dis, hemp, and polypropylene) on the fresh behavior of SCCs, evaluated using the test of spreading and J Ring, as well as their hardened behavior, measured by compressive and flexural strength. Additionally, the delayed behavior of the different SCC mixtures, including total and endogenous flexural creep, was examined. The findings of this study may assist in the acceptance of the incorporation of pre-treated plant fibers by industry and standards compliance bodies.

2. Materials and methods

2.1 Materials

Portland CEMI 42.5 cement and LF limestone filler were utilized as the binder in this study. Table 1 provides information on the chemical composition and physical properties of the cement and LF. class 0/3 sand was sourced from limestone rock with a density of 2680 kg/m3, while class 3/8 and 8/15 gravels, with a density of 2600 kg/m3, were selected. Additionally, a super-plasticizer of Glenium 26 type, based on polycarboxylic ether, was employed. The study included two types of fibers: plant-based (Hemp and Dis) and synthetic (Polypropylene).

Table 1
Chemical composition and physical properties of cement and limestone filler (LF).

Hemp fiber is widely cultivated in China, Canada, and Europe due to its high tensile strength of between 600 and 1100 MPa, making it suitable for use in various applications, including the paper industry and as a reinforcement material in cementitious composites (Hamzaoui et al., 2014HAMZAOUI, R.; GUESSASMA, S.; MECHERI, B.; ESHTIAGHI, A. M.; BENNABI, A. Microstructure and mechanical performance of modified mortar using hemp fibres and carbon nanotubes. Materials & Design, 56, p. 60-68, 2014.). Dis fiber (Ampélodesmos Mauritanicus) which is derived from Ampélodesmos Mauritanicus, is a wild grass species that is found in the Mediterranean basin. It is abundant in countries, such as the Maghreb, Greece, Spain, and southern France. Its fibrous nature makes it an ideal candidate for use as a conventional fiber in cementitious materials (Laifa et al., 2014LAIFA, W.; BEHIM, M.; TURATSINZE, A.; ALI-BOUCETTA, T. Caractérisation d’un béton autoplaçant avec addition de laitier cristallisé et renforcé par des fibres de polypropylène et de diss. Synthèse: Revue des Sciences et de la Technologie, v. 29, n. 1, p. 100-110, 2014.). The Hemp and Dis fibers used in this study were cut to a length of about 2 cm. To remove impurities and improve the adhesion between the vegetable fibers and the matrix, the fibers were treated with a solution containing 5% of sodium hydroxide (NaOH) at a temperature of 20° C for two hours. These fibers are then dried in front of a heater at a temperature of 40° C. Subsequently, the fibers were dried at 40°C to remove any residual moisture. This chemical treatment removes lignin and waxy substances from the surface of the fiber cell wall. NaOH is a commonly used chemical solution for bleaching and/or cleaning the surface of vegetable fibers (Reis, 2012REIS, J. Sisal fiber polymer mortar composites: introductory fracture mechanics approach. Construction and Building Materials, 37, p. 177-180, 2012.). Additionally, the vegetable fibers were treated by immersing them in a solution of styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) for 20 minutes, followed by drying at 25°C (Figure 1). According to literature, this treatment significantly reduces the water absorption of vegetable fibers, thereby improving the fiber/matrix adhesion (Ferreira et al., 2020FERREIRA, S. R.; SENA NETO, A. R.; SILVA, F. de A.; SOUZA JR, F. G.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D. The influence of carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber coating on the mechanical performance of vegetable fibers and on their interface with a cement matrix. Construction and Building Materials, 262, 120770, 2020.). Table 2 presents the mechanical and physical characteristics of untreated vegetable fibers and polypropylene.

Table 2
The physical, chemical, and mechanical characteristics of plant fibers and polypropylene.

Figure 1
Photographs showing the different fibers used.

2.2 Mixture proportions

The Bétonlab-Pro software (de Larrard & Sedran, 1996LARRARD, F. de; SEDRAN, T. Computer-Aided mix design: predicting final result. Concrete International, v. 18, n. 12, p. 39-41, 1996.) was utilized to determine the design of SCC mixes, taking into account all data relating to the materials used. A total of six formulations were prepared, which included SCC without fiber (SCC-C), SCC with hemp fiber treated with NaOH (SCC-HN) and with SBR (SCC-HS); SCC with Dis fiber treated with NaOH (SCC-DN) and with SBR (SCC- DS); and SCC with polypropylene fiber (SCC-P). A fixed quantity of binder, consisting of cement and limestone filler, was chosen at 520 kg/m3. Consequently, the same amount of aggregates was used for all the SCCs with fibers, with slight adjustments made to the water content and superplasticizer. The fiber content was uniformly set at 2 kg/m3. Table 3 displays the proportions of the self-compacting concrete mixtures developed in this study.

Table 3
The proportions of self-compacting concrete with and without fibers.

2.3 Sample preparation and testing procedure

All six mixes of self-consolidating concrete (SCC) were prepared in accordance with EN-206-1 (NF-206-1 2004AFNOR. NF-206-1. Béton - partie 1: spécification, performances, production et conformité, 2004.) using a 60-liter capacity concrete mixer. Fresh property tests, including the Spread and J ring tests, were conducted after preparing the SCC. The SCC mixtures were then poured into steel molds and left for 24 hours. After this time, specimens measuring 10x20 cm2 and 7x7x28 cm3 were removed from the molds for compressive and flexural strength tests, respectively. These specimens were then hardened in water at 20 ± 2°C until the age of the test (7 and 28 days).

The beams for bending creep were cast in prismatic molds measuring 10x10x120 cm3. After demolding, half of the beams were completely sealed with three layers of adhesive aluminum foil to determine the endogenous creep, while the remaining specimens were left unprotected to determine the total creep. Both types of beams were stored in a room with a temperature of 20 ± 1°C and humidity of 55 ± 5%.

To measure the deflection at the mid-span of the joist, the beams were placed on a suitable frame and subjected to "four-point" bending using a manual loading system. A comparator with a precision of 1/1000th (0.001 mm) was used to measure the displacement on the side of the face in tension. The loading was imposed after 7 days of curing in ambient air, with a constant 120 kg load applied to the four mixtures, equivalent to 35% of the breaking load of the control concrete without fiber at 7 days. The deflection was manually measured at regular intervals over a charging time of more than 200 days. Figure 2 illustrates the different beams subjected to a continuous flexural load.

Figure 2
Flexural creep device (Benkechkache & Houari, 2009BENKENKECHKACHE, G.; HOUARI, H. Comparaison des retraits et fluages des betons autoplacants et des betons ordinaires vibres. Sciences & Technologie. B, Sciences de l'ingénieur, p. 9-16, 2009.).

3. Results and discussion

3.1 Fresh properties

The spread test evaluates the ability of SCC to deform under weight against a wall surface, while the J-Ring test measures the flow capacity of SCC in a confined medium. Figure 3 illustrates the variation in the spread and J-Ring diameters of SCCs. The results show that the spread of the different SCCs ranges from 60 cm to 73 cm, indicating satisfactory spreading in all mixtures in accordance with the criteria required by the EN-206 standard. However, the presence of fibers had a slightly negative effect on workability. The treatment of plant fibers with SBR improved the fluidity of SCC compared to fibers treated with NaOH, possibly due to the decreased water absorption and the good distribution of SBR-treated fibers, avoiding the effect of clogging. According to (Ferreira et al., 2020FERREIRA, S. R.; SENA NETO, A. R.; SILVA, F. de A.; SOUZA JR, F. G.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D. The influence of carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber coating on the mechanical performance of vegetable fibers and on their interface with a cement matrix. Construction and Building Materials, 262, 120770, 2020.), coating natural fibers with SBR considerably decreases their water absorption. Regarding the J-Ring diameter, the presence of P and Hemp fibers had a negative effect on the ability of SCCs to pass through a confined medium, with values ranging from 50 to 61 cm. However, mixtures showed good homogeneity and cohesion.

Figure 3
Effect of fibers on the diameters of the spread and the J-Ring of the different SCCs.

3.2 Mechanical properties

3.2.1 Compressive strength

Figure 4 shows the compressive strength of the SCC-C, SCC-P, SSC-HN, SCC-HS, SCC-DN, and SCC-DS mixtures at different ages. The introduction of P fibers causes a decrease in compressive strength of 12% and 6% compared to the strength of the SCC-C at 7 and 28 days, respectively. Banthia & Sheng (1996)BANTHIA, N.; SHENG, J. Fracture toughness of micro-fiber reinforced cement composites. Cement and Concrete Composites, v. 18, n. 4, p. 251-269, 1996. reported that the weak interfacial bonding between polypropylene fibers and cement paste is due to their smooth surface. Furthermore, polypropylene is chemically inert and hydrophobic, which eliminates the possibility of chemical bonding.

Figure 4
Effect of vegetable fibers on the compressive strength of SCCs.

The compressive strength of the SCC-HS mixture is 6% higher than that of SCC-HN. Moreover, SCC-DS exhibits an overall increase in strength compared to the other SCCs. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of treating plant fibers with SBR. This treatment enhances the compatibility between vegetable fibers, and SBR latex and improves the adhesion of the transition zone between the fibers and the matrix (Ferreira et al., 2020FERREIRA, S. R.; SENA NETO, A. R.; SILVA, F. de A.; SOUZA JR, F. G.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D. The influence of carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber coating on the mechanical performance of vegetable fibers and on their interface with a cement matrix. Construction and Building Materials, 262, 120770, 2020.; Fidelis et al., 2016FIDELIS, M. E. A.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D.; SILVA, F. de A.; MECHTCHERINE, V.; BUTLER, M.; HEMPEL, S. The effect of accelerated aging on the interface of jute textile reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 74, p. 7-15, 2016.; Li et al., 2021aLI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, p. 1-12, 2021a.). In addition, this treatment offers protection for plant fibers against the alkaline environment of cement. Coating plant fibers with SBR considerably reduces their water absorption which promotes complete hydration of cement (Banjo A Akinyemi & Adesina, 2021AKINYEMI, B. A.; ADESINA, A. Utilization of polymer chemical admixtures for surface treatment and modification of cellulose fibres in cement-based composites: a review. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 3, p. 1241-1266, 2021.).

3.2.2.Flexural strength

Figure 5 shows the flexural strength of the SCC-C, SCC-P, SSC-HN, SCC-HS, SCC-DN, and SCC-DS mixtures obtained at different ages. The results reveal that the SCC-P mixture exhibits a decrease in bending strength by about 2% compared to the SCC-C at various ages. On the other hand, SCC-HS shows an increase in strength of 11% and 8% compared to SCC-C and SCC-HN, respectively at 7 days. Furthermore, SCC-DS demonstrates a 9%, 13%, and 4% higher flexural strength than SCC-C, SCC-DN, and SCC-HS, respectively, at 28 days. According to Walid Laifa et al., (2014)LAIFA, W.; BEHIM, M.; TURATSINZE, A.; ALI-BOUCETTA, T. Caractérisation d’un béton autoplaçant avec addition de laitier cristallisé et renforcé par des fibres de polypropylène et de diss. Synthèse: Revue des Sciences et de la Technologie, v. 29, n. 1, p. 100-110, 2014., the enhancement in tensile strength by bending of SCCs with Dis fiber is likely due to the roughness of this fiber. These findings indicate that the treatment of vegetable fibers with SBR leads to an improvement in the mechanical performance of self-compacting concrete.

Figure 5
Effect of vegetable fibers on the flexural strength of SCCs.

3.2.3 Relationship between compressive and flexural strength

The relationships between the compressive and flexural strength of the different mixtures are shown in Figure 6. It emerges from these results that the compressive strength of SCCs is proportional to the bending strength with a correlation coefficient R2= 0.82.

Figure 6
Correlation between flexural and compressive strength.

3.3 Delayed behavior under constant load

3.3.1 Endogenous creep

Figure 7 depicts the evolution of endogenous creep during bending of the mixtures up to 200 days after loading, based on the type of fibers used. During the first days of loading, the increase in the deflection is observed whatever the type of fiber. Initially, the deflection increases for all fiber types, consistent with the short-term endogenous creep theory. This theory relies on the micro-diffusion of water under pressure (Ranaivomanana et al., 2013RANAIVOMANANA, N.; MULTON, S.; TURATSINZE, A. Basic creep of concrete under compression, tension and bending. Construction and Building Materials, 38, p. 173-180, 2013.) and the capillary tensions generated by cement hydration (Benboudjema, 2002BENBOUDJEMA, F. Modélisation des déformations différées du béton sous sollicitations biaxiales. Application aux enceintes de confinement de bâtiments réacteurs des centrales nucléaires. Université de Marne la Vallée, 2002.), where the stresses applied during loading enhance the effect of capillary tensions (Bazant et al., 1997BAZANT, Z. P.; HAUGGAARD, A. B.; BAWEJA, S. ULM, F. J. Microprestress-solidification theory for concrete creep. I: aging and drying effects. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, v. 123, n. 11, p. 1188-1194, 1997.). Water plays a fundamental role in the endogenous creep mechanism of concrete.

Figure 7
Endogenous creep of different mixtures.

Notably, has the lowest creep order among the SCCs studied. The introduction of fibers in the SCCs increased creep at 200 days by 12%, 21%, and 25% for SCC-P, SCC-HN, and SCC-DN, respectively, compared to SCC-C. The increased creep for SCC-P may be attributed to the smooth and hydrophobic nature of the polypropylene fiber, causing a decrease in adhesion and creating microcracks. The increase in creep for SCC-HN and SCC-DN is due to the dissolution of extractable on the surface of these fibers, which disturbs cement hydration and delays setting (Sedan et al., 2007SEDAN, D.; PAGNOUX, C.; SMITH, A.; CHOTARD, T. Propriétés mécaniques de matériaux enchevêtrés à base de fibre de chanvre et matrice cimentaire. In: CONGRÉS FRANÇAIS DE MÉCANIQUE, 18, Grenoble, 2007.; Diquélou et al., 2015DIQUÉLOU, Y.; GOURLAY, E.; ARNAUD, L.; KUREK, B. Impact of hemp shiv on cement setting and hardening: Influence of the extracted components from the aggregates and study of the interfaces with the inorganic matrix. Cement and Concrete Composites, 55, p. 112-121, 2015.; Tonoli et al., 2010TONOLI, G. H. D.; ALMEIDA, A. E. F. de S.; SILVA, M. A. P. da, BASSA, A.; OYAKAWA, D.; SAVASTANO, H. Surface properties of eucalyptus pulp fibres as reinforcement of cement-based composites. Holzforschung, v. 64, n. 5, p. 595-601, 2010.). The transition zone between the fibers and cement paste can also affect creep by creating microcracks in the concrete. As per (da Silva Junior et al., 2021SILVA JUNIOR, I. B. da; SOUZA, L. M. S. de; SILVA, F. A. Creep of pre-cracked sisal fiber reinforced cement based composites. Construction and Building Materials, 293, 123511, 2021.) water absorption by plant fibers reduces the kinetics of cement hydration, leading to decreased mechanical performance. Treating Hemp and Dis fibers with SBR latex resin significantly reduced endogenous creep by 14.2% and 21.3%, respectively, compared to SCC-HN and SCC-DN at 200 days (Figure 7). However, a slight increase in creep was observed compared to SCC-C. This improvement in the behavior of plant fibers treated with SBR is due to improved adhesion between the fiber and the matrix. Coating the fibers with SBR also considerably reduces water absorption, leading to complete hydration of cement and increasing mechanical performance of the cementitious composite (Li et al., 2021aLI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, p. 1-12, 2021a.).

3.3.2 Total creep

Figure 8 illustrates the progression of total deferred deformations in SCC-C and SCC-F under bending stress. The figure clearly indicates that substituting polypropylene fibers with vegetable fibers results in reduction in total creep. (Zhao et al., 2016ZHAO, Q.; YU, J.; GENG, G. JIANG, J.; LIU, X. Effect of fiber types on creep behavior of concrete. Construction and Building Materials, 105, p. 416-422, 2016.) examined the impact of polypropylene fibers and alcohol on specific creep and concluded that adding these fibers to concrete increases creep deformation due to two different mechanisms. Fibers with higher elasticity moduli exhibit better creep resistance capacities by pinning microcracks in the concrete. This study shows that SBR-treated Dis fiber is stiffer than the other fibers and demonstrates good resistance to creep deformation compared to SCC-C. Moreover, coating Hemp and Dis fibers with SBR latex leads to a decrease in total creep of 10% and 16%, respectively, at 200 days compared to SCC-HN and SCC-DN (Fig. 8). This is because good fiber/matrix adhesion promotes an increase in mechanical performance. According to (Zhao et al., 2016ZHAO, Q.; YU, J.; GENG, G. JIANG, J.; LIU, X. Effect of fiber types on creep behavior of concrete. Construction and Building Materials, 105, p. 416-422, 2016.), the addition of fibers to concrete can introduce internal defects in two ways. First, non-homogeneous distribution of fibers may result in weaknesses in various concrete performances. Second, the fiber-matrix interface may create microcracks inside the concrete.

Figure 8
Total creep of the different mixtures.

4. Conclusions

The study investigated the effect of different types of fibers, subjected to two treatments, on the fresh and hardened behavior of self-compacting concretes (SCCs). The bending creep behavior of the SCCs was evaluated. Hemp and Dis fibers were used as reinforcement in the SCCs after being immersed in NaOH and SBR solutions. The following conclusions can be drawn:

  • The addition of fibers in the SCCs led to a decrease in their filling capacity in both an unconfined (spreading) and confined (J-RING) medium. However, the treatment of plant fibers with SBR latex improved the fresh state characteristics of SCCs by approximately 8%. This can be attributed to the reduced water absorption of the treated fibers and the reduction of friction between the fibers, aggregates, and walls.

  • SCC-DS exhibited higher flexural strength than SCC-C, SCC-DN, and SCC-HS, by 9%, 13%, and 4%, respectively, at 28 days. Therefore, the treatment of plant fibers with SBR can enhance the mechanical performance of self-compacting concretes.

  • The presence of fibers in the SCCs resulted in internal defects, reducing its ability to resist creep. These defects include non-uniform fiber distribution and the defective interface between the fibers and the cementitious matrix. However, the use of Hemp and Dis fibers treated with SBR latex in the SCCs decreased the total creep by 10% and 16% compared to SCC-HN and SCC-DN, respectively.

In conclusion, the coating of vegetable fibers with styrene-butadiene rubber is highly effective in improving the shortand long-term mechanical performance of self-compacting concretes.

Acknowledgments

The authors are very thankful to the University of Bordj Bou Arreridj laboratory sympathetic staff and the LMDC laboratory group of Constantine-Algeria.

References

  • AFNOR. NF-206-1. Béton - partie 1: spécification, performances, production et conformité, 2004.
  • AHMED, S. A. Properties and mesostructural characteristics of linen fiber reinforced self-compacting concrete in slender columns. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, v. 4, n. 2, p.155-161, 2013.
  • AKINYEMI, B. A.; ADESINA, A. Utilization of polymer chemical admixtures for surface treatment and modification of cellulose fibres in cement-based composites: a review. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 3, p. 1241-1266, 2021.
  • AKINYEMI, B. A.; DAI, C. Development of banana fibers and wood bottom ash modified cement mortars. Construction and Building Materials, 241, 118041, 2020.
  • AZEVEDO, A. R. G de; MARVILA, M. T.; ANTUNES, M. L. P.; RANGEL, E. C.; FEDIUK, R. Technological perspective for use the natural pineapple fiber in mortar to repair structures. Waste and Biomass Valorization, v. 12, n. 9, p. 5131-5145, 2021.
  • AWWAD, E.; MABSOUT, M.; HAMAD, B.; FARRAN, M. T.; KHATIB, H. Studies on fiber-reinforced concrete using industrial hemp fibers. Construction and Building Materials, 35, p. 710-717, 2012.
  • BABAFEMI, A. J.; BOSHOFF, W. P. Tensile creep of macro-synthetic fibre reinforced concrete (MSFRC) under uni-axial tensile loading. Cement and Concrete Composites, 55, p. 62-69, 2015.
  • BANTHIA, N.; SHENG, J. Fracture toughness of micro-fiber reinforced cement composites. Cement and Concrete Composites, v. 18, n. 4, p. 251-269, 1996.
  • BASSER, H.; SHAGHAGHI, T. M.; AFSHIN, H.; AHARI, R. S.; MIRREZAEI, S. S. An experimental investigation and response surface methodology-based modeling for predicting and optimizing the rheological and mechanical properties of self-compacting concrete containing steel fiber and PET. Construction and Building Materials, 315, 125370, 2022.
  • BAZANT, Z. P.; HAUGGAARD, A. B.; BAWEJA, S. ULM, F. J. Microprestress-solidification theory for concrete creep. I: aging and drying effects. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, v. 123, n. 11, p. 1188-1194, 1997.
  • BELKADI, A. A.; AGGOUN, S.; AMOURI, C.; GEUTTALA, A.; HOUARI, H. Effect of vegetable and synthetic fibers on mechanical performance and durability of Metakaolin-based mortars. Journal of adhesion science and Technology, v. 32, n. 15, p. 1670-1686, 2018.
  • BENBOUDJEMA, F. Modélisation des déformations différées du béton sous sollicitations biaxiales. Application aux enceintes de confinement de bâtiments réacteurs des centrales nucléaires. Université de Marne la Vallée, 2002.
  • BENKENKECHKACHE, G.; HOUARI, H. Comparaison des retraits et fluages des betons autoplacants et des betons ordinaires vibres. Sciences & Technologie. B, Sciences de l'ingénieur, p. 9-16, 2009.
  • BENSALEM, S.; AMOURI, C.; HOUARI, H.; BELACHIA, M. Elaboration and characterization of self-compacting concrete based on local by-products. International Journal of Engineering, Science and Technology, v. 6, n. 1, p. 98-105, 2014.
  • CANDAMANO, S.; CREA, F.; COPPOÇA, L.; DE LUCA, P.; COFFETTI, D. Influence of acrylic latex and pre-treated hemp fibers on cement based mortar properties. Construction and Building Materials, 273, 121720, 2021.
  • CHIKER, T.; BELKADI, A. A.; AGGOUN, S. Physico-chemical and microstructural fire-induced alterations into metakaolin-based vegetable and polypropylene fibred mortars. Construction and Building Materials, 276, 122225, 2021.
  • DI BELLA, G.; FIOE, V.; GALTIERI, G.; BORSELLINO, C.; VALENZA, A. Effects of natural fibres reinforcement in lime plasters (kenaf and sisal vs. Polypropylene). Construction and Building Materials, 58, p. 159-165, 2014.
  • DIQUÉLOU, Y.; GOURLAY, E.; ARNAUD, L.; KUREK, B. Impact of hemp shiv on cement setting and hardening: Influence of the extracted components from the aggregates and study of the interfaces with the inorganic matrix. Cement and Concrete Composites, 55, p. 112-121, 2015.
  • DRIDI, M.; HACHEMI, S.; BELKADI, A. A. Influence of styrene-butadiene rubber and pretreated hemp fibers on the properties of cement-based repair mortars. European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering, p. 1-20, 2022.
  • FERREIRA, S. R.; SENA NETO, A. R.; SILVA, F. de A.; SOUZA JR, F. G.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D. The influence of carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber coating on the mechanical performance of vegetable fibers and on their interface with a cement matrix. Construction and Building Materials, 262, 120770, 2020.
  • FIDELIS, M. E. A.; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D.; SILVA, F. de A.; MECHTCHERINE, V.; BUTLER, M.; HEMPEL, S. The effect of accelerated aging on the interface of jute textile reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 74, p. 7-15, 2016.
  • GARCÍA-TAENGUA, E.; ARANGO, S.; MARTÍ-VARGAS, J. R.; SERNA, P. Flexural creep of steel fiber reinforced concrete in the cracked state. Construction and Building Materials, 65, p. 321-329, 2014.
  • HAMZAOUI, R.; GUESSASMA, S.; MECHERI, B.; ESHTIAGHI, A. M.; BENNABI, A. Microstructure and mechanical performance of modified mortar using hemp fibres and carbon nanotubes. Materials & Design, 56, p. 60-68, 2014.
  • KUNDU, S. P.; CHAKRABORTY, S.; CHAKRABORTY, S. Effectiveness of the surface modified jute fibre as fibre reinforcement in controlling the physical and mechanical properties of concrete paver blocks. Construction and Building Materials, 191, p. 554-563, 2018.
  • LAIFA, W.; BEHIM, M.; TURATSINZE, A.; ALI-BOUCETTA, T. Caractérisation d’un béton autoplaçant avec addition de laitier cristallisé et renforcé par des fibres de polypropylène et de diss. Synthèse: Revue des Sciences et de la Technologie, v. 29, n. 1, p. 100-110, 2014.
  • LARRARD, F. de; SEDRAN, T. Computer-Aided mix design: predicting final result. Concrete International, v. 18, n. 12, p. 39-41, 1996.
  • LI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, p. 1-12, 2021a.
  • LI, Q.; IBRAHIM, L.; ZHOU, W.; ZHANG, M.; YUAN, Z. Treatment methods for plant fibers for use as reinforcement in cement-based materials. Cellulose, v. 28, n. 9, p. 5257-5268, 2021b.
  • MARANGON, E.; TOLEDO FILHO, R.; FAIRBAIRN, E. Basic creep under compression and direct tension loads of self-compacting-steel fibers reinforced concrete. High Performance Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites, 6, p. 171-178, 2012.
  • MOHAMED, M.; GHORBEL, E.; WARDEH, G. Valorization of micro-cellulose fibers in self-compacting concrete. Construction and Building Materials, v. 24, n. 12, p. 2473-2480, 2010.
  • RANAIVOMANANA, N.; MULTON, S.; TURATSINZE, A. Basic creep of concrete under compression, tension and bending. Construction and Building Materials, 38, p. 173-180, 2013.
  • REIS, J. Sisal fiber polymer mortar composites: introductory fracture mechanics approach. Construction and Building Materials, 37, p. 177-180, 2012.
  • RIZZO, G., COMOTTI, D.; FABRIS, L.; GRASSI, M.; LODOLA, L.; MALCOVATI, P. et al. The PixFEL: project: development of advanced X-ray pixel detectors for application at future FEL facilities. Journal of Instrumentation, v. 10, n. 02, 2015, C02024.
  • SALES, Â. T. C. Retração, fluência e fratura em compósitos cimentícios reforçados com polpa de bambu. 2006. 273 f. Tese (Doutorado) - Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio de Janeiro, 2006.
  • SEDAN, D.; PAGNOUX, C.; SMITH, A.; CHOTARD, T. Propriétés mécaniques de matériaux enchevêtrés à base de fibre de chanvre et matrice cimentaire. In: CONGRÉS FRANÇAIS DE MÉCANIQUE, 18, Grenoble, 2007.
  • SILVA, F. A; TOLEDO FILHO, R. D.; MELO FILHO, J. A.; FAIRBAIRN, E. M. R. Physical and mechanical properties of durable sisal fiber-cement composites. Construction and Building Materials, v. 24, n. 5, p. 777-785, 2010.
  • SILVA JUNIOR, I. B. da; SOUZA, L. M. S. de; SILVA, F. A. Creep of pre-cracked sisal fiber reinforced cement based composites. Construction and Building Materials, 293, 123511, 2021.
  • TONOLI, G. H. D.; ALMEIDA, A. E. F. de S.; SILVA, M. A. P. da, BASSA, A.; OYAKAWA, D.; SAVASTANO, H. Surface properties of eucalyptus pulp fibres as reinforcement of cement-based composites. Holzforschung, v. 64, n. 5, p. 595-601, 2010.
  • TONOLI, G. H. D.; SAVASTANO JÚNIOR, H.; FUENTE, E.; NEGRO, C.; BLANCO, A.; LAHR, F. A. R. Eucalyptus pulp fibres as alternative reinforcement to engineered cement-based composites. Industrial crops and products, v. 31, n. 2, p. 225-232, 2010.
  • WEI, J.; MEYER, C. Degradation mechanisms of natural fiber in the matrix of cement composites. Cement and Concrete Research, 73, p. 1-16, 2015.
  • ZHAO, Q.; YU, J.; GENG, G. JIANG, J.; LIU, X. Effect of fiber types on creep behavior of concrete. Construction and Building Materials, 105, p. 416-422, 2016.

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    17 July 2023
  • Date of issue
    Jul-Sep 2023

History

  • Received
    24 Jan 2023
  • Accepted
    14 Mar 2023
Fundação Gorceix Rua Carlos Walter Marinho Campos, 56, Cep: 35400-000, Tel: (31) 3551-4730 - Ouro Preto - MG - Brazil
E-mail: editor@rem.com.br