Open-access Rural women’s access to Health: rethinking the meanings of care from Mato Grosso do Sul, Brazil

Abstract

The article analyzes access to healthcare for rural populations in Mato Grosso do Sul, with an emphasis on the municipalities of Dourados and Rio Brilhante. Based on a qualitative approach, we articulate field observations and interviews with managers, professionals, users, and companions of SUS patients to understand how meanings of care are produced in territories marked by socio-territorial and gender inequalities. The collected narratives reveal challenges such as precarious services, scarcity of infrastructure, and the centralization of public policies and public facilities in large urban centers. The research draws on references from the Social Sciences in Health to reflect on the concrete conditions of care in inland contexts. By bringing to light experiences from the so-called “deep Brazil,” the study seeks to destabilize the epistemological hegemony of large centers and to strengthen more humane, territorialized care practices committed to equity.

Key words:
Rural health; Gender; Inequalities; SUS

Resumo

O artigo analisa o acesso à saúde por populações rurais em Mato Grosso do Sul, com ênfase nos municípios de Dourados e Rio Brilhante. Com base em uma abordagem qualitativa, articulamos observações de campo e entrevistas com gestoras(es), usuárias(os) e acompanhantes de pacientes do SUS para compreender como os sentidos de cuidado são produzidos em territórios marcados por desigualdades socioterritoriais e de gênero. As narrativas colhidas revelam desafios como a precariedade dos serviços, a escassez de infraestrutura e a centralização das políticas públicas e de equipamentos públicos nos grandes centros urbanos. A pesquisa mobiliza referenciais das Ciências Sociais em Saúde para refletir sobre as condições concretas do cuidado em contextos interioranos. Ao trazer à tona vivências do chamado “Brasil profundo”, o estudo busca desestabilizar a hegemonia epistemológica dos grandes centros e fortalecer práticas de cuidado mais humanas, territorializadas e comprometidas com a equidade.

Palavras-chave:
Saúde rural; Gênero; Desigualdades; SUS

Resumen

El artículo analiza el acceso a la salud por parte de poblaciones rurales en Mato Grosso do Sul, con énfasis en los municipios de Dourados y Rio Brilhante. Basándonos en un enfoque cualitativo, articulamos observaciones de campo y entrevistas con gestoras(es), profesionales, usuarias(os) y acompañantes de pacientes del SUS para comprender cómo se producen los sentidos del cuidado en territorios marcados por desigualdades socioterritoriales y de género. Las narrativas recogidas revelan desafíos como la precariedad de los servicios, la escasez de infraestructura y la centralización de las políticas públicas y los equipamientos públicos en los grandes centros urbanos. La investigación moviliza referentes de las Ciencias Sociales en Salud para reflexionar sobre las condiciones concretas del cuidado en contextos del interior. Al visibilizar vivencias del llamado “Brasil profundo”, el estudio busca desestabilizar la hegemonía epistemológica de los grandes centros y fortalecer prácticas de cuidado más humanas, territorializadas y comprometidas con la equidad.

Palabras clave:
Salud rural; Género; Desigualdades; SUS

Introduction

In Brazil, access to the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) occurs through various “gateways” provided by public health services, although not always in the equitable, comprehensive, and universal manner originally intended. The concentration of specialized services, especially those focused on treating highly complex diseases, in urban areas and large centers reveals a scenario marked by historical and structural inequalities1. These inequalities become even more profound when they affect rural populations, people of the countryside, and traditional, peripheral, and Black communities living in what has come to be called “deep Brazil2”. Pessoa et al. 3 state that “recognizing this rural Brazil is fundamental for intervening in the health-disease process, since the rural universe has singularities and specificities that shape the organization of services and health practices.”

We seek to reflect on rural populations’ access to health care, which also entails recognizing the challenges these populations face, especially women, who frequently assume the role of companion/caregiver, even in contexts of illness and in the absence or precariousness of public services. In this context, we draw on our academic research experiences at the undergraduate and graduate levels, as well as on our respective involvement in the field of health, as forms of knowledge that intersect with the women who are our interlocutors in research, care, and itineraries within and through public policies.

This article is nested in the research project “Access of Rural Populations to Health Care: An Analysis of Socio-territorial, Ethnic-racial, and Gender Inequalities,” coordinated by the first author. The project’s overall objective is to analyze the mobility and access of rural populations, residents of small and medium-sized Brazilian cities, to the SUS, considering the ways socio-territorial, ethnic-racial, and gender inequalities shape this process, to identify Social Determinants of Health (SDH), defined by Buss and Alberto Filho4 as “social, economic, cultural, ethnic/racial, psychological, and behavioral factors that influence the occurrence of health problems and their risk factors in the population.”

In situating this research, it is essential to underscore that rural women’s access to health care in Mato Grosso do Sul is not limited to service availability alone. It is intertwined with their concrete living conditions: long journeys to nearby urban centers or state capitals, precarious transportation, insufficient institutional and programmatic support, and the overload of domestic and family responsibilities. These women-most of them poor, Brown or Black-experience distinct modes of oppression and vulnerability in an intersectional way, including gender, class, and territory. These factors shape their therapeutic itineraries and constitute structural barriers to exercising the right to health. Incorporating this dimension is essential if we are to understand care not merely as an available, free, and accessible service, but as a situated experience traversed by historical and social inequalities.

In this article, we turn our attention to the state of Mato Grosso do Sul, more specifically to Dourados and Rio Brilhante, where we conducted fieldwork with managers, users, and companions/caregivers. Our aim is to understand how notions of access and care are constructed and experienced in inland and rural contexts. As Merhy5 argues, care is a process that takes shape at the interface of the technical, the affective, and the political; it is produced in the encounter between subjects, traversed by their values, knowledge, limits, and potentials. By listening to the narratives of those who live and work in these territories, we seek to bring out of invisibility the everyday dynamics surrounding illness, care, and the struggle for rights, thereby highlighting the urgency of public policies that consider the multiple dimensions of inequality structuring access to health in the country1.

Methods

This qualitative research aims to understand the meanings attributed to managers’, users’, and companions/caregivers’ access to health care and care practices in rural and inland contexts. This method is justified by the need to bring forth, beyond statistical and structural data, the experiences, perceptions, and meanings that permeate the therapeutic and care itineraries experienced and narrated by people in their everyday lives6. Here, itinerary is understood as “a set of plans, strategies, and projects directed toward a preconceived object: the treatment of affliction7.”

By adopting a qualitative perspective, our attention focused on narratives about health and care itineraries and, beyond that, on the material and social conditions structuring the everyday lives of our interlocutors. Conducting interviews in women’s homes, for example, allowed us to observe the overlap between domestic and health-care spaces, showing how the “kitchen,” the “bedroom,” or the “porch” is transformed into a therapeutic setting. This methodological choice revealed how family arrangements, neighborhood networks, and religious beliefs are coordinated with strategies for coping with illness, allowing health to be understood as a process lived amid economic constraints, infrastructural precariousness, and the overload of women’s work.

The groups studied here were divided into three segments: (i) management, (ii) users, and (iii) companions/caregivers, thus allowing us to observe institutional practices, mobilized affects, and the informal strategies that sustain care in the SUS within specialized care. The analysis, structured into thematic categories, is articulated through references to Collective Health and Community Social Psychology-their practices and production in health-thus consolidating a multifaceted, plural field.

By focusing on the meanings produced and mobilized by managers, users, and companions/caregivers, we sought to understand health and care itineraries as processes marked by social, political, symbolic, and institutional dimensions. In this direction, the dialogue with the Human and Social Sciences offers an analytical lens sensitive to these complex processes, enabling an approach that values both the socio-territorial contexts in which practices are engendered, and the meanings constituted and produced by the subjects and groups involved1,8.

The hermeneutic perspective constituted a central axis in the conduct and analysis of this qualitative research. Inspired by Clifford Geertz’s9 interpretive approach, we started from the assumption that understanding a social practice requires more than describing it; it requires interpreting it in light of the meanings it carries for those who live it. As Geertz9 proposes, in understanding culture as a web of meanings, the researcher’s task in the Social Sciences is to conduct an analysis that does not stop at the action itself, but seeks to interpret the culturally constructed meanings that confer sense upon that action.

Thus, rather than simply knowing what people do on a daily basis in their health and care itineraries, we sought to understand how they signify what they do, what meanings they produce, what narratives they construct about their experiences, and how these narratives are intertwined with broader structures of inequality, belonging, exclusion, and resistance. Careful listening and an ethical commitment to our interlocutors formed the foundation for producing knowledge that reveals inequalities in access to health care while also recognizing the everyday strategies of coping and care developed by rural populations.

Because this study involved sensitive listening in contexts of vulnerability and social inequality, we adopted an ethical posture attentive to singularity and lived experience10. We were committed to respecting the dignity, autonomy, and confidentiality of the information shared and produced during interviews and field observations. The Research Ethics Committee of the Federal Rural University of Pernambuco (UFRPE) approved the study under Certificate of Ethical Review Submission (CAAE) No. 81217624.9.0000.9547 and Opinion No. 7.114.113, in compliance with the ethical procedures established by National Health Council Resolution No. 510/2016, which regulates ethics in research in the Human and Social Sciences.

Contextualizing the field

The research was conducted from September 5 to December 16, 2024. These contexts were selected because of the social and territorial relevance of these localities to the constitution of Health Care Networks, particularly regarding therapeutic and care itineraries among women and their interactions with managers and companions/caregivers in the daily life of health services.

Dourados, with an estimated population of approximately 243,367 inhabitants11, is the most populous municipality in the inland region of the state and serves as an important regional hub for services and education, housing institutions such as the Federal University of Grande Dourados (UFGD), the State University of Mato Grosso do Sul (UEMS), and the University Center of Grande Dourados (UNIGRAN). It plays a strategic role in the state economy, especially in the agribusiness, commercial, and educational sectors.

The municipality has experienced marked demographic growth-an increase of more than 1200% between 1940 and 2010-and stands out for its high Municipal Human Development Index (MHDI), which was 0.747 in 201011.

In the municipality of Dourados, although specialized services are more available, women living in rural areas face considerable distances to the urban area and depend almost exclusively on public transportation or support from family members to reach appointments. Many times, the lack of regular transportation compromises adherence to treatment, especially when it involves chemotherapy or radiotherapy, which require frequent trips to Campo Grande or even to other municipalities within and outside Mato Grosso do Sul. In addition, care for the home, children, and older adults-that is, care for others-remains their responsibility, so prolonged absences for treatment disrupt everyday routines.

Rio Brilhante is located about 67 km from Dourados. It has distinct sociocultural and economic characteristics. It had an estimated population of 40,419 inhabitants in 202212 and a high Municipal Human Development Index (0.715 in 2010)12. Its economic development was driven mainly by agriculture and, more recently, by the establishment of sugar-energy plants, which significantly expanded local revenue and consolidated the municipality’s status as the largest sugarcane producer in the state.

Its history features a strong presence of immigrants from the Brazilian South, Southeast, and Northeast, contributing to its heterogeneous social configuration. In Rio Brilhante, the reality of rural women links difficulties in accessing health care to the effects of local socioeconomic transformations. The expansion of sugar-energy plants and the predominance of intensive agriculture have shaped a territory of contrasts, where economic growth coexists with persistent inequalities. This setting shows that access to health cannot be analyzed in isolation but must be understood in relation to the social determinants of health, especially housing, work, and mobility conditions that directly affect women’s lives and care.

The simultaneous presence of urban-industrial and rural contexts in both municipalities allows us to explore different dimensions of health itineraries, institutional arrangements, and the relationships between subjects and territories. The sociocultural diversity of the populations studied provides important elements for reflecting on how meanings of care are produced and mobilized daily in health services.

Results and discussion: access to health care and the meanings of care in rural space

Access to health care constitutes a dense and multifaceted field of reflection whose complexity becomes even more pronounced when analyzed from the perspective of historically marginalized populations, such as those living in rural and peripheral areas. Specialized literature1,13 has pointed out that access to health services must be understood beyond a merely structural or geographic dimension, involving political, organizational, cultural, symbolic, and ethical aspects. It is essential to reflect on how rural populations access care, which requires recognizing the existence, singularity, and complexity of the different territories and territorialities present in the context of ruralities.

Assis and Jesus14 propose an analytical model that recognizes the multidimensional nature of access, including the social determinants of health, conditions of service provision, institutional practices, relationships between professionals and users, and the role of public policies. These authors affirm that, although there have been advances in the SUS with respect to expanded coverage and reduced inequities-especially in Basic Care, or with emphasis on its Primary Health Care dimension-limitations remain related to accessibility, fragmentation, and the regionalization of services, in addition to regional asymmetries that directly affect specific populations such as rural and traditional groups. This situation reveals the need for a care model grounded in comprehensiveness, equity, and accountability, especially in territories where care is shaped by other logics, such as community-based and traditional ones.

Conversely, Vieira15 situates the debate on access to health within bioethics, emphasizing the human right to health as a matter of social justice. In discussing the case of quilombola communities, the author highlights how historical and cultural factors shape meanings of care and produce specific barriers to equitable access. From this perspective, bioethics emerges as a tool for building policies sensitive to the particularities of vulnerable groups, opening space for plural and sensitive forms of listening that value local knowledge. This approach is particularly relevant to the analysis of care in rural areas such as Mato Grosso do Sul, where different communities-including Indigenous, riverside, and peasant populations-develop their own understandings of health, illness, and healing, which are often rendered invisible by hegemonic care logics.

Travassos and Castro16 further deepen the discussion of the social determinants of health inequalities in access to and use of services, emphasizing the importance of equity as a structuring principle of public policies. Universal access, as provided for in the Brazilian Constitution17, still faces marked inequalities that mainly affect groups with lower socioeconomic power who live far from urban centers. The authors argue that access should be understood not only as the possibility of accessing services, but also as a continuous process involving the quality of care received, the problem-solving capacity of services, and the cultural adequacy of health practices. To this end, it is necessary to conduct research that reveals how these inequalities are expressed across different territories and contexts, thereby supporting policies that account for local specificities.

Therefore, thinking about rural populations’ access to health care in Mato Grosso do Sul requires coordination across analytical dimensions: the organizational structure of the SUS and its capillarity in rural territories; the social determinants of health that shape care; and the meanings attributed to health and care by local subjects. Considering these multiple layers allows us to understand care not merely as an institutional offering, but as a lived, relational, and situated experience crossed by cultural meanings, collective memories, and community practices1. It is thus a matter of broadening analytical horizons toward careful listening to rural populations, recognizing them as producers of knowledge and as legitimate agents in the construction of alternatives for a more equitable and comprehensive health system.

Throughout the fieldwork, we conducted interviews with 17 interlocutors, including managers, users, and companions/caregivers, distributed across the different territories studied. In the case of the users, the interviews were conducted with women who had experienced cancer treatment. For ethical reasons and in keeping with the interlocutors’ wishes, the interviews were held in the participants’ homes to ensure a more comfortable and private environment. Given the diversity of profiles and the number of participants, we chose to present sociodemographic information in a systematized way through a spreadsheet. In Charts 1, 2 and 3, relevant data were organized in order to offer a panoramic and accessible view of the set of respondents:

Chart 1
Sociodemographic profile of managers.
Chart 2
Sociodemographic profile of users.
Chart 3
Sociodemographic profile of caregivers.

We should underscore that in one case, the 55-year-old companion/caregiver was not physically present during appointments but played a fundamental role in the support network by caring for the grandchildren. Although indirect, this support was decisive in allowing the patient to devote herself to treatment. Below, we present the meanings of care mobilized in the different segments.

Meanings of care among managers

In the management axis, three main categories emerged: fear, structure, and access. These meanings reveal tensions between the principles established and normatively defined in the SUS and the patients’ concrete realities. The managers’ narratives show how care must be mediated between what is institutionally prescribed and what is actually possible, given the various logistical, emotional, and cultural barriers to access and the social determinants of health experienced by patients.

Fear emerges as a subjective barrier to mobilizing care. Managers reported that many patients refuse to continue treatment outside their municipalities or states because they fear being separated from their ties and routines, or because of a lack of information and insecurity: “They make that choice not to leave the state. Many don’t want to… Because they’re afraid, insecure. It’s really a lack of knowledge.” This fear is not merely individual, but a collective construction associated with experiencing illness as synonymous with distress and death. As Merhy5 argues, health care can only be produced in the meeting between subjects, and moving a patient away from her territory without comprehensive support may mean breaking that living process of care.

However, this analysis must shift through a feminist and intersectional approach. According to Collins and Bilge18, “the use of intersectionality as an analytical tool points to several important dimensions of the growth of global inequality. First, social inequality does not apply equally to women, children, people of color, people with disabilities, trans people, undocumented populations, and Indigenous groups. Rather than seeing people as a homogeneous mass and differentiated individuals, intersectionality provides a framework for explaining how categories of race, class, gender, age, citizenship status, and others position people differently in the world.”

Moreover, these patients are not only SUS users, but women-mostly poor and living in peripheral rural territories-whose lives are traversed by a triad of oppressions: gender, class, and territory. The fear of leaving home is not limited to fear of the unknown but also relates to the socially assigned duties of women in the domestic space: caring for children, grandchildren, and older adults, maintaining the home, food, affection, and family routines. They are the ones who sustain the everyday reproduction of life, and when they are absent, this entire system collapses or falls onto other women19.

Thus, the fear expressed here is more than a “feeling”; it is a concrete effect of the precarization of women’s lives, of the sexual division of labor, and of the lack of public policies that recognize and support the displacements required for health care. It is, therefore, a political fear that denounces a web of inequalities rendered invisible in technical health protocols. As feminist author Angela Davis20 argues, domestic and care work is central to the functioning of society, yet remains unpaid and devalued, especially when performed by Black, poor, and peripheral women.

The structure category highlights the precariousness of institutional resources. Management recognizes the limits of the support network and, at times, resorts to improvised strategies to “ease” the situation: “We even have a support house there, but it’s inhumane. So, I don’t even refer patients there.” This choice illustrates how health decisions are shaped not only by data but also by values, ethics, and a sense of dignity. As Cecílio21 warns, comprehensiveness is achieved only when the system can respond to real needs and not just those foreseen in protocols.

Finally, the category access reveals a field of conceptual disputes and tensions. While managers reaffirm Primary Care as the gateway to the SUS, they also reveal that, in practice, transportation, distance, and lack of resources hamper the fulfillment of the principle of universality. One manager’s statement-“Primary care is the open door. I don’t have to provide transportation; I have to provide the door”-clearly expresses this contradiction. At this point, it is worth digressing on the challenges of implementing Out-of-Home Treatment (TFD), a policy designed precisely to make specialized care possible when it is unavailable in the municipality of origin or residence.

Established by SAS/MS Ordinance No. 55/1999 and consolidated in SAES/MS Consolidation Ordinance No. 1/2022, TFD consists of financial support for patients who need treatment outside their municipality of residence, provided that care is guaranteed in the referral municipality. However, despite its strategic importance, the operationalization of TFD faces numerous obstacles, especially in states with vast territories, low density of specialized services, and logistical and financial fragilities in municipal networks.

Therefore, the analysis of this excerpt shows that what is at stake is not an isolated failure but a set of weaknesses that span different dimensions of the system. On the one hand, there is a deficit in regulation, expressed in the difficulty of coordination between municipalities of origin and destination to ensure care in the referral network; on the other hand, the insufficient or irregular federal transfers and the overload placed on municipal Health Secretariats by the costs of long and precarious travel reveal limitations in both care capacity and policy follow-up. Thus, the situation described points to the interdependence among regulation, care provision, and follow-up, whose combined failures compromise the effectiveness of TFD and directly affect the guarantee of the right to health.

These obstacles reveal how the policy, although designed to expand access, runs up against a logic of individual or municipal responsibility, distancing itself from the ideal of a supportive and coordinated care network. The lack of regular transportation and the requirement of formal guarantees for TFD authorization place the most vulnerable populations in an even more precarious position, thereby perpetuating health inequities. In light of this, there is an urgent need to rethink the implementation of TFD by pursuing greater integration among federative entities, improved territorial planning, and a stronger commitment to equitable access to health care.

Meanings of care among users

Three meanings predominated in the users’ section: bond, spirituality, and care network. Here, care is experienced as a sensitive experience marked by family relationships, symbolic practices, and recognition of the care received.

The bond category appears in relationships among mothers and daughters, married patients and their husbands, and subjects and their surroundings. “My daughter cooks for me,” one user reported. These gestures, although simple and related to domestic labor, are in fact profound expressions of ethical care, as proposed by Ayres22, who understands care as a meeting between subjects in vulnerability, in which responsibility is shared, and affection sustains the continuity of life.

Spirituality emerges with symbolic density. “I’m Spiritist, I also go to a terreiro… a little coarse-salt bath with rue.” Health here extends beyond biomedical parameters to incorporate ancestral knowledge, spiritualities, rites, and purification practices. These experiences broaden the therapeutic field and show that the production of health also crosses the symbolic, ethical, and collective fields of reception and support1,7.

Finally, the care network category reaffirms care as a shared experience. “Two friends helped me. One stayed during the day, the other at night.” These bonds are not merely technical or mechanical; they are relationships that organize the meaning of life, sustain treatment, and make the process less lonely. Dimenstein et al. 23 emphasize that community social psychology should recognize these practices as a legitimate field of care, thereby strengthening policies and interventions grounded in listening, collectivity, and solidarity. Thus, the narratives reveal distress, but also gratitude, presence, and strengthening of affective ties during the treatment process.

Meanings of care among companions/caregivers

Four central categories emerged in the companions/caregivers’ section: overload, faith, absence, and network of affection. These meanings reveal the intensity of informal care, mainly provided by women, and the tension between affective dedication and institutional abandonment. Care here is experienced in the body, time, and soul of caregivers, revealing distress, resilience, and creativity in the face of the gaps left by the State.

The overload category emerges as central. Most companions/caregivers abandoned routines, work, and self-care to dedicate themselves fully to caring for a family member. “Today my life has become taking care of my mother,” one of them reported. In another excerpt, one said: “I was seeing a psychologist, now I’m with a psychiatrist.” These women’s mental health deteriorates while they sustain the care of another. Fleury24 analyzes this event as an expression of a public policy that delegates responsibilities without guaranteeing support, thereby exacerbating gender inequalities and producing invisible illnesses.

Alongside this, faith emerges as a fundamental resource for continuing to provide care. “I put it in God’s hands and, thank God, everything worked out,” one caregiver said. Spirituality, in this context, does not function as passive consolation but as a technology of coping that reorganizes the meaning of the experience, sustains hope, and legitimizes everyday effort. Foucault25,26 would call this a practice of “care of the self,” in which the subject creates modes of existence amid pain and scarce institutional support.

The State’s absence also forces these women to take on technical tasks for which they were not prepared. “I administered medication at home… if she had been alone, there would have been no way.” This kind of improvisation lays bare the limitations of the SUS in guaranteeing comprehensive care, as proposed by Cecílio21, by transferring specialized responsibilities to third parties-without support, training, and recognition.

It is in this overwhelmingly female setting that, albeit timidly, the presence of a man in care work also stands out. From the age and ties mentioned, we can infer that he is the partner of the person receiving care, probably her husband. His, albeit occasional, inclusion unsettles gender roles naturalized in the field of care, historically associated with women. This male presence in that place produces estrangement and symbolic displacement, because it challenges social expectations that exempt men from everyday care tasks. His participation may signal both an act of affection and the emergence of new family arrangements in the face of insufficient public policies, opening space to think about masculinities that care, even under silence and invisibility.

The network of affection category closes this section strongly: “We really are friends, but like sisters.” This simple but meaningful expression reveals the dense relationships established between companions/caregivers and users in the daily work of care. It is an affective and political network that overflows the limits of the consanguine family, articulating other forms of kinship, proximity, and belonging that emerge from the shared experience of pain, struggle, and resistance.

This type of relationship is particularly relevant when we consider vulnerable populations, often characterized by contexts of institutional neglect, State absence, and family rupture. In these settings, care is more than a task delegated to professionals; it is a relational practice grounded in trust, listening, and presence. The closeness between caregivers and users gives shape to a community fabric sustained not by formal obligation, but by lived solidarity and responsive empathy-what Vilma Piedade27 calls dororidade, that is, an alliance among women mediated by shared pain and also by the possibility of reconstruction and strength.

This network, therefore, does not replace the traditional family, but reinvents it according to other criteria: affection, mutual recognition, and everyday availability. Companions/caregivers become figures of reference and support for users, weaving bonds that are at once therapeutic and political. Such relationships are configured as informal care devices, often more effective than institutional and bureaucratic arrangements precisely because they operate on the plane of everyday life, reciprocity, and active listening.

Moreover, by transcending blood ties, these networks destabilize normative conceptions of family, broadening the idea of community and belonging. They point to other possible ways of being together, caring, and resisting, especially in contexts where state care is insufficient. Thus, recognizing and valuing these networks of care and affection is also a political act of legitimizing the knowledge and practices that emerge from the territories themselves and that sustain life in its simplest-and precisely therefore most powerful-forms.

Final considerations

In this article, produced within the research project “Access of Rural Populations to Health Care: An Analysis of Socio-territorial, Ethnic-racial, and Gender Inequalities,” we sought to understand the meanings attributed to health care work in Mato Grosso do Sul, specifically in Dourados and Rio Brilhante. Based on a qualitative approach grounded in social research in health5, we organized the experiences narrated by managers, users, and SUS companions/caregivers into three thematic and analytical axes. Through attentive listening to those who live and work in these territories, we highlighted the relational, affective, and structural dimensions that traverse the production of care1.

The analysis corroborates the theoretical-methodological framework of Collective Health, especially regarding understanding care as a living, relational, and situated practice rather than merely the provision of services or compliance with clinical protocols. This dimension is also highlighted by Ayres22, who proposes care as an ethical commitment of mutual responsibility that can only be realized when the other is recognized as a subject of rights and desires.

From the respondents’ accounts, it becomes evident that care is sustained by invisible networks, often informal ones, built in the interstices left by the State. As Cecílio21 argues, responding to health needs is not merely a matter of offering services, but of recognizing experienced needs, which requires sensitive listening, bonds, and institutional responsiveness.

This analysis also reveals the intertwining of care and the social determinants of health, governed by social inequalities. Women are protagonists of care not by individual choice, but through a social and sexual division of labor that naturalizes their function as compulsory caregivers in capitalist societies and under neoliberal modes of production.

At this point, intersectionality becomes an indispensable analytical tool. The experiences analyzed cannot be understood without coordinating gender, race, class, and territory19. As Angela Davis20 teaches us, inequalities are historical and structural and, therefore, require equally deep responses. In the field of care, this implies public policies that recognize the multiple layers of exclusion and that value local, popular, and affective forms of knowledge.

As Vilma Piedade27 reminds us through the concept of dororidade, care is also the sharing of pain, affection, and resistance among women who live through the same oppressions. These are insurgent networks that create health where the State fails. And, as bell hooks28 proposes, love-understood as an ethical commitment to the other - is a political gesture that breaks with the logic of abandonment, indifference, and the capitalist logic of appropriation and disposal.

By making visible the meanings of care in the voices of those who care, suffer, and resist, this article reaffirms that care is not a privilege, but a right and a collective political practice. Recognizing care as living, affective, and situated production, as proposed by Collective Health, is the first step toward building public policies that are more sensitive, inclusive, and committed to social justice. It is a matter of recognizing, as Araujo19 points out, that one cannot “trivialize what is most fundamental to understanding care, namely, social inequalities and power relations.” Care, therefore, is both an everyday practice and an ethical and political horizon.

The living conditions of rural women in the municipalities examined here reveal that health care is crossed by multiple inequalities that exceed the lack of services and include domestic overload, economic precariousness, and the lack of policies to support travel for treatment. By naturalizing women’s responsibility for care, the health system reinforces gender inequalities, produces illness, and shows that these women, more than SUS users, are subjects whose lives concretely expose the inequities of rural Brazil.

Their narratives of fear, faith, solidarity, and overload show that care is sustained by informal and affective networks, often more present than institutional policies. Making these living conditions visible constitutes an indispensable ethical and political step toward building public policies sensitive to the specificities of rural territories.

Finally, reflecting on rural populations’ access to health care requires recognizing the inequities that traverse territories and subjects, especially when it comes to the communities that make up the so-called “deep Brazil2.” The experiences narrated by managers, users, and companions/caregivers in the municipalities presented here show that care practices are built amid adversities, but also carry forms of resistance, affection, and knowledge that challenge hegemonic and dehumanizing models. By bringing these voices to the fore, we challenge the production of knowledge on health, still strongly anchored in the large urban centers of the South and Southeast, while rendering visible realities that call for territorialized, intersectional, and inequality-sensitive public policies. Thinking about care from the itineraries of and within rural territories is, therefore, an ethical, political, and epistemological exercise that is fundamental to the construction of a more equitable, universal, and comprehensive SUS13.

Acknowledgments

This work was conducted with funding from the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) and the Ministério da Saúde (MS), support without which the research would not have been possible.

References

  • 1 Fleischer S. Como as doenças compridas podem nos ensinar sobre os serviços de saúde? Equatorial 2017; 4(7):24-44.
  • 2 Oliveira EA, Nascimento LCP, Moraes LL, Caetano M. Dissidências de gênero e sexualidade(s) em contextos interioranos e/ou rurais: cruzando temas, problemas e perspectivas contemporâneas. Rev Debates Insubmissos 2020; 3:6-11.
  • 3 Pessoa VM, Almeida MM, Carneiro FF. Como garantir o direito à saúde para as populações do campo, da floresta e das águas no Brasil? Saude Debate 2018; 42(1):302-314.
  • 4 Buss PM, Pellegrini Filho A. A Saúde e seus Determinantes Sociais. Physis 2007; 17(1):77-93.
  • 5 Merhy EE. Saúde: a cartografia do trabalho vivo. São Paulo: Hucitec; 2002.
  • 6 Lorena AG. Sem Perreco: a prevenção do HIV em fluxos, festas e bailes funks. São Paulo: Ed Hucitec; 2022.
  • 7 Alves PCB, Souza IMA. Escolha e Avaliação de tratamento para Problemas de Saúde: considerações sobre o itinerário terapêutico. In: Rabelo MC, Alves PC, Souza IA. Experiência de doença e narrativa. Rio de Janeiro: Fiocruz; 1999. p. 125-138.
  • 8 Ferreira J, Fleischer S, organizadores. Etnografias em serviços de saúde. Rio de Janeiro: Garamond; 2014.
  • 9 Geertz C. A interpretação das culturas. Rio de Janeiro: LTC; 1989.
  • 10 Sathler CN, Oliveira EA. Um currículo da/na experiência: formação profissional em Psicologia, docência e resistências ético-políticas. Currículo Sem Fronteiras 2022; 22:1-22.
  • 11 Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE). Dourados. Rio de Janeiro: IBGE; 2025.
  • 12 Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE). Rio Brilhante. Rio de Janeiro: IBGE; 2025.
  • 13 Gomes RF, Oliveira PSD, Silva MLO, Miranda SVC, Sampaio CA. Itinerários terapêuticos no cuidado em saúde em comunidades quilombolas. Cien Saude Colet 2024; 29(3):e01602023.
  • 14 Assis MMA, Jesus WLA. Acesso aos serviços de saúde: abordagens, conceitos, políticas e modelo de análise. Cien Saude Colet 2012; 17(11):2865-2875.
  • 15 Vieira AD. Acesso à saúde de populações vulneráveis: uma visão sob o enfoque da bioética. Rev Bio Der 2018; 43:211-223.
  • 16 Travassos C, Castro MSM. Determinantes e desigualdades sociais no acesso e utilização de serviços de saúde. In: Giovanella L, Escorel S, Lobato LVC, Noronha JC, Carvalho AI, organizadores. Políticas e sistema de saúde no Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: Fiocruz; 2012. p. 183-206.
  • 17 Brasil. Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil de 1988. Diário Oficial da União 1988; 5 out.
  • 18 Collins PH, Bilge S. Interseccionalidade. São Paulo: Boitempo; 2021.
  • 19 Araujo AB. Da ética do cuidado à interseccionalidade: caminhos e desafios para a compreensão do trabalho de cuidado. Mediações 2018; 23(3):43-69.
  • 20 Davis A. Mulheres, raça e classe. São Paulo: Boitempo; 2016.
  • 21 Cecílio LCO. As necessidades de saúde como conceito estruturante na luta pela integralidade e equidade na atenção em saúde. In: Pinheiro R, Mattos RA, organizadores. Os sentidos da integralidade na atenção e no cuidado à saúde. 8ª ed. Rio de Janeiro: IMS/UERJ, Abrasco; 2009. p. 113-126.
  • 22 Ayres JRCM. Cuidado e reconstrução das práticas de saúde. Interface (Botucatu) 2009; 13(1):101-110.
  • 23 Dimenstein M, Siqueira K, Macedo JP, Leite J, Dantas C. Determinação social da saúde mental: contribuições à psicologia no cuidado territorial. Arq Bras Psicol 2017; 69(2):72-87.
  • 24 Fleury S. Reforma sanitária brasileira: dilemas entre o instituinte e o instituído. Cien Saude Colet 2009; 14(3):743-752.
  • 25 Foucault M. A hermenêutica do sujeito. 3ª ed. São Paulo: WMF Martins Fontes; 2010.
  • 26 Foucault M. História da sexualidade: o cuidado de si. Vol. 3. 5ª ed. São Paulo: Paz & Terra; 2014.
  • 27 Piedade V. Dororidade. São Paulo: Editora Nós; 2017.
  • 28 hooks b. Tudo sobre o amor: novas perspectivas. São Paulo: Elefante; 2020.

Data availability statement

The data sources adopted in the research are indicated in the article’s body.

Chief editors:

Maria Cecília de Souza Minayo, Romeu Gomes, Antônio Augusto Moura da Silva, Vania de Matos Fonseca

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    17 Aug 2026
  • Date of issue
    Aug 2026

History

  • Received
    18 Apr 2026
  • Accepted
    20 Apr 2026
  • Published
    22 Apr 2026
location_on
ABRASCO - Associação Brasileira de Saúde Coletiva Av. Brasil, 4036 - sala 700 Manguinhos, 21040-361 Rio de Janeiro RJ - Brazil, Tel.: +55 21 3882-9153 / 3882-9151 - Rio de Janeiro - RJ - Brazil
E-mail: cienciasaudecoletiva@fiocruz.br
rss_feed Acompanhe os números deste periódico no seu leitor de RSS
Ir para o topo